Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 5 of 980 (351556 posts in 14689 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 980 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Thread Locked Martin Freeman Joins Captain America: Civil War Orc13 438 1 May 6, 3:31am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Thread Locked Redundant is redundant. Otaku-sempai 367 0 May 6, 3:43am

  Collapse GDT still has not seen "The Hobbit" Trilogy Silmaril 1223 8 May 5, 2:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by painjoiker)
       I honestly think his Hobbit would have been wildly different sycorax82 1012 0 May 5, 6:03pm
       I can understand that... dormouse 838 0 May 5, 10:28pm
       Collapse probably because he is pretty pissed he wasn't able to direct MouthofSauron 300 5 May 10, 4:09am
         Collapse A Question? Since he got a Screen Credit.. Bombadil 277 4 May 10, 8:48am
               Collapse Residuals Otaku-sempai 254 1 May 10, 1:50pm
                   Oops! Otaku-sempai 240 0 May 10, 2:39pm
               Collapse Does he earn royalties for all and any of his contributions, or only... Milieuterrien 245 1 May 10, 2:28pm
                   He is either payed a fixed amount before the movies are done, painjoiker 123 0 May 12, 9:02pm

  Collapse How would the story have shaped out if Azog was replaced by Bolg? boldog 874 25 May 5, 9:25am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Dain could have killed Azog... QuackingTroll 724 0 May 5, 12:50pm
       Collapse They would have had to invent another orc... dormouse 713 6 May 5, 1:22pm
           goblin army tattooed_dwarf 595 0 May 5, 5:40pm
           Collapse Well, the second orc army wasn't necessary and didn't make a great deal of sense AshNazg 496 4 May 5, 8:27pm
               Collapse Well, I suppose the two orc armies.... dormouse 445 1 May 5, 10:22pm
                   Agree... lionoferebor 307 0 May 6, 1:31pm
               Collapse I agree... lionoferebor 318 1 May 6, 1:09pm
                   The Orcs of Tattooine Otaku-sempai 312 0 May 6, 1:22pm
       It's got its pluses and minuses Kilidoescartwheels 690 0 May 5, 1:56pm
       If Azog had died at Azanulbizar Otaku-sempai 672 0 May 5, 2:31pm
       Collapse I would reply more fully but I am weeping Spriggan 621 14 May 5, 5:21pm
           Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 596 13 May 5, 5:49pm
               Collapse Well Bolg is a name in the book. Spriggan 573 12 May 5, 6:26pm
                   Collapse Azog/Bolg Otaku-sempai 559 11 May 5, 6:49pm
                       Collapse I think we may be at cross purposes. Spriggan 545 10 May 5, 7:10pm
                           Collapse You may be right. Otaku-sempai 516 1 May 5, 8:07pm
                               I don't think I was hoping for anything. Spriggan 488 0 May 5, 8:40pm
                           Collapse Yes and no... AshNazg 477 1 May 5, 8:59pm
                               I tend to think the former probably drives the latter. Spriggan 470 0 May 5, 9:19pm
                           Collapse Well that's exactly how I felt about it... Salmacis81 446 5 May 5, 10:43pm
                               Collapse Jolly good - it's nice to have the confirmation Spriggan 437 4 May 5, 11:01pm
                                   Collapse Sure, you could call it that... Salmacis81 431 3 May 5, 11:23pm
                                       I'm not sure I've ever said that, which would seem a slight difference. Spriggan 424 0 May 5, 11:33pm
                                       Collapse I think we all have different opinions... AshNazg 422 1 May 5, 11:45pm
                                           Thank you for saying that Kilidoescartwheels 129 0 May 6, 4:54pm

  Collapse Odd clips in DVD Bumblingidiot 1330 11 May 3, 6:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       probably Faleel 1235 0 May 3, 7:07pm
       Fellowship of the Ring received a new color grade on the Extended Edition Blu-ray... Aragorn the Elfstone 1199 0 May 3, 7:59pm
       Collapse Dark clips are from the EE Blu-ray QuackingTroll 1097 6 May 3, 10:49pm
           possible updated/fixed grade Mooseboy018 1031 0 May 4, 2:05am
           Collapse My avatar pic is from the EE Blu-ray... QuackingTroll 1025 1 May 4, 2:21am
               flesh tones Mooseboy018 1006 0 May 4, 3:10am
           Collapse I knew about the issue, Bumblingidiot 457 2 May 5, 7:31pm
               Collapse The green tinted sky is in AUJ too... Bofur01 433 1 May 5, 8:35pm
                   The tint in AUJ isn't so bad, for some reason. Bumblingidiot 244 0 May 7, 10:59pm
       Collapse Who knows what they were thinking with the green tint... sycorax82 807 1 May 4, 3:14pm
           Re-grading and changing the original trilogy... AshNazg 633 0 May 4, 11:32pm

  Collapse Only Azog knew lionoferebor 847 4 May 3, 1:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by marary)
       Collapse Yes... dormouse 764 2 May 3, 3:33pm
           Collapse Legolas Mooseboy018 716 1 May 3, 5:07pm
               Yes Konrad S 670 0 May 3, 6:21pm
       CSI Ravenhill marary 619 0 May 3, 8:06pm

  Collapse Lack of Fighting for Fíli AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 1269 22 May 2, 11:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Lack of Fili everywhere Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1132 0 May 3, 12:18am
       Ugh! lionoferebor 1095 0 May 3, 2:32am
       Collapse chariot Mooseboy018 1096 15 May 3, 2:37am
           Collapse I'm going over the wall... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 1094 4 May 3, 2:56am
               Collapse editing Mooseboy018 1079 3 May 3, 3:10am
                   Collapse randomly materializing battle rams! marary 996 2 May 3, 9:36am
                     Collapse "Stache BRAIDS of Awesome"....NEW MEME..? Bombadil 852 1 May 3, 6:35pm
                           I like it! :D // Riven Delve 796 0 May 3, 9:23pm
         Collapse LOL! Avandel 898 9 May 3, 5:04pm
               Collapse Ugh... lionoferebor 769 8 May 4, 12:50am
                   Collapse I'm sure it wasn't either/ or..... dormouse 725 7 May 4, 9:01am
                       Collapse Bats, lingerie, and trade-offs...I'm not sure what to call this lionoferebor 686 6 May 4, 1:20pm
                         Collapse HOW could they have made it an EVEN Match? Bombadil 660 5 May 4, 4:17pm
                               Collapse It would've been IMPOSSIBLE to make it an EVEN MATCH lionoferebor 567 4 May 5, 12:24am
                                   Collapse I tend to agree with Lion and I too think that Fili was shortchanged. Noria 490 3 May 5, 12:58pm
                                       Collapse Not quite it... dormouse 481 1 May 5, 1:34pm
                                           Agree Avandel 435 0 May 5, 4:08pm
                                       Director wisdom and/or director choice? Avandel 444 0 May 5, 3:46pm
       Collapse I can understand a lack of screentime Bishop 820 3 May 3, 9:19pm
           Collapse Fili's death Elarie 487 2 May 5, 1:08pm
               I too liked Fili's death Noria 482 0 May 5, 1:25pm
               Yes and no Kilidoescartwheels 311 0 May 6, 8:48pm

Collapse About Those WEREWORMS..? Bombadil 1189 33 May 2, 2:11pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       Were-worm Wranglers? Otaku-sempai 958 0 May 2, 7:29pm
       Collapse WER means "man" AshNazg 949 5 May 2, 7:47pm
           Did you like the Worms..? Bombadil 757 0 May 3, 4:33pm
           Collapse Were-things Otaku-sempai 757 3 May 3, 4:44pm
             Collapse O-s, you have very Valid Points..SSOoo what Bombadil 734 2 May 3, 6:25pm
                   Collapse Too much? Otaku-sempai 717 1 May 3, 7:44pm
                     In DEFENSE.... of the Wereworms..? Bombadil 681 0 May 4, 12:32am
       Collapse the were-worms Goldeneye 611 5 May 4, 2:40pm
           Collapse Well.... dormouse 575 4 May 4, 5:12pm
               Collapse well... Goldeneye 546 3 May 4, 6:42pm
                   Well, not quite... Otaku-sempai 527 0 May 4, 7:17pm
                   Collapse The concept actually came from three sources... QuackingTroll 483 1 May 4, 10:20pm
                       Well, surely.... dormouse 297 0 May 5, 7:32am
       Collapse And yet we are perfectly happy to justify the Eagles. Spriggan 597 13 May 4, 4:25pm
         Collapse There be Giants...? Bombadil 556 12 May 4, 6:24pm
               Collapse I think Spriggan is on your side, Bomby! Otaku-sempai 532 11 May 4, 7:11pm
                 Collapse I was writing when Spriggy wrote.... Bombadil 505 1 May 4, 8:55pm
                       Okay. Otaku-sempai 495 0 May 4, 9:01pm
                   Collapse Oh I'm not on anyone's side... ;) Spriggan 497 8 May 4, 9:03pm
                       Collapse Meaning that Tolkien wouldn't have written them like that? dormouse 486 3 May 4, 10:04pm
                           Tunnels Otaku-sempai 479 0 May 4, 10:23pm
                           Collapse The reverse really, or at least a tangent. Spriggan 477 1 May 4, 10:28pm
                             @ the Top of this THREAD is... Bombadil 469 0 May 4, 11:06pm
                       Collapse The "if Tolkien had written this test" doesn't work for me... AshNazg 472 3 May 4, 11:12pm
                           Collapse Whilst I tend towards the other view, it is nice to have the parity. Spriggan 463 1 May 4, 11:43pm
                               Well, there was a SLIGHT Set-UP..? Bombadil 333 0 May 5, 12:08am
                         IT takes Radagast to "RALLY the Eagles".. Bombadil 294 0 May 5, 10:18am
       The worms were on the screen for what, twenty seconds? Noria 190 0 May 7, 12:27pm
       Collapse Worms are there to build the thrill Milieuterrien 166 4 May 7, 8:49pm
           Collapse Dol Guldur Orcs Otaku-sempai 159 3 May 7, 9:50pm
               Collapse The army from Gundabad was a reserve Milieuterrien 143 2 May 8, 7:36am
                   Collapse Not sure about a reserve force. Otaku-sempai 114 1 May 8, 1:42pm
                       Yep, it surely was the dumbest moment to show Milieuterrien 90 0 May 8, 9:45pm

  Collapse Big soundtrack mistake in The Hobbit QuackingTroll 1583 32 May 2, 12:13am Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse Can anyone remember QuackingTroll 1464 1 May 2, 12:16am
           off the top of my head Mooseboy018 1441 0 May 2, 1:01am
       I agree. Mooseboy018 1442 0 May 2, 12:58am
       Collapse This was mentioned shadow0421 1391 1 May 2, 2:55am
           To the point that it became overbearing Estel78 1217 0 May 2, 9:50am
       misty mountains theme CathrineB 1350 0 May 2, 4:42am
       I hear this a lot SafeUnderHill 1304 0 May 2, 6:49am
       The final statement of Misty Mountains in AUJ was yucky... Bofur01 1302 0 May 2, 6:59am
       Collapse Let's see Shagrat 1258 8 May 2, 8:59am
           Collapse This! CathrineB 1242 5 May 2, 9:11am
               Collapse Some further thoughts... laurethiel1138 1175 4 May 2, 10:49am
                   Collapse Which part SafeUnderHill 1164 3 May 2, 11:00am
                       Collapse Details... laurethiel1138 1075 2 May 2, 12:59pm
                           Also... Bofur01 1067 0 May 2, 1:13pm
                           I get what you mean :) Although i'm not sure you got the notes exactly write SafeUnderHill 1052 0 May 2, 1:32pm
           Yes! SafeUnderHill 1228 0 May 2, 9:21am
           Totally agree with you, Shagrat Loresilme 224 0 May 3, 10:45pm
       Collapse This would have worked so well. tattooed_dwarf 1227 1 May 2, 9:29am
           Personally SafeUnderHill 1200 0 May 2, 10:15am
       Collapse Will have to disagree here Skaan 1139 3 May 2, 11:57am
           Collapse ;) SafeUnderHill 1101 1 May 2, 12:35pm
               I have to admit Skaan 1079 0 May 2, 1:02pm
           MM theme was overused in AUJ. I'm glad they didn't use it again. xxxyyy 1066 0 May 2, 1:14pm
       I loved the MM theme but prefer Sons of Durin overall Noria 1098 0 May 2, 12:36pm
       If they made a mistake... dormouse 1053 0 May 2, 1:39pm
       Collapse excellent video Goldeneye 431 1 May 2, 2:14pm
           If you could, it'd be cool to play with the soundtrack... AshNazg 392 0 May 2, 4:14pm
       I agree with two sides of the argument Bishop 424 0 May 2, 2:42pm
       Collapse could not disagree more Lindele 371 1 May 2, 6:23pm
         Really?! tattooed_dwarf 312 0 May 2, 9:18pm
       Money Issues? Otaku-sempai 349 0 May 2, 7:33pm
       That shot of the mountain SafeUnderHill 323 0 May 2, 8:43pm

  Collapse Question for Tolkienologists: Why does Gandalf have a ring? Kilidoescartwheels 818 10 May 1, 9:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse the ring is called Narya the Great geordie 776 1 May 1, 10:17pm
           The story can be found in Silverlode 750 0 May 1, 11:03pm
       Nice Backstory Bracegirdle 745 0 May 1, 11:25pm
       Collapse Galadriel was given Nenya... Bofur01 666 1 May 2, 7:03am
           the timing Elthir 605 0 May 2, 1:45pm
       Collapse I hope your question is answered in the EE of BOTFA... xxxyyy 611 2 May 2, 1:18pm
           Collapse Is it stated in the films... arithmancer 589 1 May 2, 2:52pm
               From the movies, we only know that Galadriel has one Ring. xxxyyy 542 0 May 2, 6:18pm
       In the movies... arithmancer 581 0 May 2, 3:04pm
       Answered in 'LotR' bonus features? Otaku-sempai 518 0 May 2, 7:39pm

  Collapse Has anyone done a 6 movie marathon yet? Kilidoescartwheels 899 12 May 1, 5:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       Collapse 'Twill have to wait. Otaku-sempai 811 3 May 1, 5:08pm
           Collapse Exactly Mooseboy018 797 1 May 1, 5:25pm
               Technically... Otaku-sempai 795 0 May 1, 5:30pm
           Echoing my thoughts... Pandallo 515 0 May 2, 2:56pm
       I tried, my friends decided that we should sleep after the Hobbit part though... Bofur01 807 0 May 1, 5:14pm
       No CathrineB 744 0 May 1, 7:04pm
       In about two weeks! Eruclauron 695 0 May 1, 8:41pm
       Planning a two-day event . . . Barrel Rider 648 0 May 1, 10:32pm
       Yes, over two days Elarie 634 0 May 1, 11:36pm
       Not yet... lionoferebor 462 0 May 3, 2:42am
       Haven't seen the twelfth film yet. Bumblingidiot 406 0 May 3, 4:15pm
       yes.. 24 times already.. it is great mirkwoodwanderer 90 0 May 10, 9:44pm

  Collapse Thranduil's Inner Face Wound/pain-how it affects him, Legolas, Tauriel/A Theory. the 13th warrior 998 15 Apr 30, 11:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse Thranduil is complicated Kilidoescartwheels 889 1 May 1, 3:46am
           Actually, Thran is isolationist and there seem to be good reasons for it.... the 13th warrior 818 0 May 1, 9:54am
       Collapse Hello and welcome! marary 807 6 May 1, 11:48am
           Collapse What do the elves have going for them in this era of Middle Earth? the 13th warrior 717 5 May 1, 6:51pm
               Collapse great assessment! marary 548 4 May 3, 9:45am
                   Collapse Isolationism=Checkmated?? the 13th warrior 435 3 May 4, 4:51pm
                       Collapse Thorin = Textbook tragic hero marary 418 2 May 4, 6:03pm
                           Great acting and visual conceptions too.... the 13th warrior 388 0 May 4, 9:03pm
                           Richard, Thorin and the dragon-sickness Kilidoescartwheels 224 0 May 7, 1:50pm
       Collapse The Curious Matter of Thranduil's Injury Otaku-sempai 770 2 May 1, 2:28pm
           Collapse Elf wound or a symbol of it??? the 13th warrior 710 1 May 1, 7:07pm
               Questions, questions... Otaku-sempai 686 0 May 1, 8:29pm
       Collapse This is ... arithmancer 620 2 May 2, 3:09pm
           Collapse Agreed. Otaku-sempai 585 1 May 2, 7:48pm
               I have often wondered about that Kilidoescartwheels 217 0 May 7, 3:02pm

Collapse *POSSIBLY SPOILERY* Nice 'BOFA EE speculation' compilation vid - link Avandel 1911 43 Apr 30, 9:03pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Collapse ....Makes PERFECT sense...We'll get Bombadil 1423 36 May 1, 2:16pm
           Collapse the ratings system? Goldeneye 1413 35 May 1, 2:41pm
               Collapse I'm sorry, but.... dormouse 1407 32 May 1, 2:59pm
                   Collapse really though... Goldeneye 1359 31 May 1, 3:48pm
                       Collapse No, I'm sorry but I don't buy the idea at all... dormouse 1317 30 May 1, 4:42pm
                           Collapse In Consideration of the Extended Edition. Otaku-sempai 1284 29 May 1, 5:14pm
                               Collapse Well yes.... dormouse 1244 28 May 1, 6:55pm
                                   Collapse re: Goldeneye 1166 27 May 1, 9:40pm
                                       Collapse But don't you see.... dormouse 1145 26 May 1, 10:23pm
                                           Collapse umm Goldeneye 1085 22 May 2, 2:24am
                                               Collapse Continuity is key... Bofur01 1028 21 May 2, 7:09am
                                                   Collapse re: Goldeneye 951 16 May 2, 2:06pm
                                                       Collapse So how does Bolg die? // Bofur01 938 1 May 2, 2:26pm
                                                           Bolg Goldeneye 904 0 May 2, 3:59pm
                                                       Collapse Poor Kili??? lionoferebor 921 7 May 2, 3:41pm
                                                           Collapse THAT scene w. Kili Avandel 906 6 May 2, 4:05pm
                                                               Tauriel Mooseboy018 881 0 May 2, 5:24pm
                                                               Collapse ? marary 864 1 May 2, 6:01pm
                                                                   Yes and no... Avandel 427 0 May 3, 4:17pm
                                                               Collapse Well... lionoferebor 534 2 May 2, 8:18pm
                                                                   Dwalin Mooseboy018 516 0 May 2, 9:23pm
                                                                   Argh - re Fili when I think about it, it's maddening.... Avandel 460 0 May 3, 3:30pm
                                                     Collapse a general audience... Avandel 919 5 May 2, 3:42pm
                                                           Collapse bafflement over target audience Ilmatar 206 4 May 7, 12:08am
                                                               Collapse Ah, but there's also the first part of the title AshNazg 191 1 May 7, 2:00am
                                                                   Yes of course Ilmatar 114 0 May 9, 5:19pm
                                                               Collapse Ratings lionoferebor 180 1 May 7, 5:18am
                                                                   From light to darker tones Ilmatar 104 0 May 9, 5:51pm
                                                   Collapse Too much is left unresolved. Otaku-sempai 553 3 May 2, 8:03pm
                                                     Collapse But re the TE audience, perhaps many didn't care about the unresolved issues... Avandel 444 2 May 3, 4:00pm
                                                           Collapse Bridging? Otaku-sempai 422 1 May 3, 4:34pm
                                                               Understood! Avandel 410 0 May 3, 5:24pm
                                           Collapse There is a level of objectivity in the poor quality of the film... AshNazg 855 2 May 2, 6:19pm
                                               Are you posting in the right topic? Pandallo 586 0 May 2, 6:40pm
                                               Well.... dormouse 577 0 May 2, 6:58pm
               Runtime Otaku-sempai 1397 0 May 1, 2:59pm
             Apparently you Didn't hear PJ say that..? G-Eye Bombadil 1375 0 May 1, 3:24pm
       Collapse Well, that does go a long way toward being the movie I had hoped for.... Eruonen 1115 1 May 1, 11:20pm
         One thing that is Not mentioned in the OP's Video? Bombadil 1096 0 May 2, 12:45am
       Collapse I cant access the video Jettorex 259 3 May 6, 4:26pm
           Collapse speculation Mooseboy018 244 2 May 6, 5:32pm
               Collapse Uh.. lionoferebor 194 1 May 7, 1:41am
                   probably Mooseboy018 185 0 May 7, 2:40am

  Collapse "Because the world is a stupid, stupid place" or "When directors shoot movies back-to-back, who wins?" BlackFox 1218 16 Apr 30, 8:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       *sigh* Aragorn the Elfstone 1087 0 Apr 30, 8:38pm
       Collapse The world is indeed a stupid, stupid place Shagrat 1072 1 Apr 30, 8:57pm
         ROFLOL!!!! Avandel 1050 0 Apr 30, 9:17pm
     Collapse The yrch loses... Bracegirdle 984 2 Apr 30, 11:14pm
         Hehehe! // BlackFox 830 0 May 1, 9:06am
           Oh Yes smtfhw 824 0 May 1, 9:39am
       "All of this bodes fairly poorly for Avengers" except... QuackingTroll 809 0 May 1, 11:16am
       Collapse Who won with The Hobbit? dormouse 762 1 May 1, 1:15pm
           I was waiting for someone to say that! BlackFox 725 0 May 1, 2:50pm
       Collapse We have won indeed! oliphaunt 704 2 May 1, 3:36pm
           TRY sitting though a Marathon..? Bombadil 694 0 May 1, 3:48pm
         True that! BlackFox 672 0 May 1, 4:24pm
       Collapse Sounds like the same old song Elarie 598 2 May 1, 11:40pm
           Collapse Quite. Bumblingidiot 459 1 May 3, 3:24pm
               Nice post Elarie 438 0 May 3, 5:46pm
       What an (insert nasty word here) Elessar 354 0 May 4, 1:00pm

  Collapse Soundtrack vs. Film lionoferebor 769 9 Apr 30, 5:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by SafeUnderHill)
       Collapse To the Death CathrineB 642 2 Apr 30, 8:12pm
           Collapse Unused/alternate music Goldeneye 630 1 Apr 30, 8:29pm
               Unfortunately... lionoferebor 600 0 Apr 30, 10:06pm
       Collapse There are slight differences all over the place! Bishop 504 1 May 1, 12:05pm
           scoring Goldeneye 466 0 May 1, 2:31pm
       Yes SafeUnderHill 412 0 May 1, 8:37pm
       Collapse You'll find this interesting SafeUnderHill 409 2 May 1, 8:40pm
           Collapse As someone who loves removed elements in all media... Pandallo 339 1 May 2, 3:54pm
               Yes there's more SafeUnderHill 330 0 May 2, 4:58pm

Collapse WHY did the THREE have to DIE? Bombadil 1443 67 Apr 30, 8:19am Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       Collapse Consequences Otaku-sempai 1199 10 Apr 30, 11:54am
           Collapse Regarding youth marary 1187 4 Apr 30, 12:18pm
               Collapse I don't buy that Kilidoescartwheels 454 2 May 1, 3:09am
                   Collapse If I may ask.... He is a wizard, you know! 358 1 May 1, 5:39pm
                       When did I read it Kilidoescartwheels 275 0 May 2, 1:32am
               Dain's story? Otaku-sempai 375 0 May 1, 2:40pm
           Collapse It is a very Anglo-Saxon narrative at that point... Morthoron 1183 4 Apr 30, 12:30pm
               Very interesting marary 1177 0 Apr 30, 12:40pm
               True Elanor of Rohan 1103 0 Apr 30, 2:20pm
               Collapse I don't think they had to die in the movie.... Avandel 1095 1 Apr 30, 2:34pm
                   In the movies... ThorinsNemesis 1075 0 Apr 30, 2:56pm
       Collapse Such sweet sorrow... lionoferebor 1172 46 Apr 30, 12:46pm
           Collapse Thorin's death ThorinsNemesis 1169 45 Apr 30, 12:58pm
               Collapse Character He is a wizard, you know! 1149 44 Apr 30, 1:31pm
                   Collapse But still... ThorinsNemesis 1137 3 Apr 30, 1:45pm
                       Collapse Well...... He is a wizard, you know! 874 2 Apr 30, 8:25pm
                           I'd disagree - IMO it's a bit more complicated Avandel 547 0 Apr 30, 9:41pm
                           Sorry for ranting? Kilidoescartwheels 452 0 May 1, 3:20am
                   Collapse Did he need to die for a character arc? marary 1126 39 Apr 30, 2:02pm
                       Collapse well... DisDwarfWoman 1101 34 Apr 30, 2:24pm
                           Collapse me too marary 1033 17 Apr 30, 3:50pm
                               Collapse (long post, sorry) DisDwarfWoman 1011 16 Apr 30, 4:18pm
                                   Collapse a long post but a good one! marary 972 15 Apr 30, 5:16pm
                                       Collapse Good point DisDwarfWoman 949 3 Apr 30, 5:51pm
                                           Collapse arguments that went unargued marary 919 2 Apr 30, 7:04pm
                                               Collapse Re: arguments that went unargued MEM 432 1 May 1, 5:44am
                                                   HOW could Bilbo TURN down a Feast? Bombadil 417 0 May 1, 7:21am
                                       Collapse Bard, Thranduil and Thorin Otaku-sempai 570 10 Apr 30, 8:34pm
                                           Collapse ah, true marary 560 9 Apr 30, 8:57pm
                                               Collapse me too! DisDwarfWoman 527 7 Apr 30, 10:16pm
                                                   Collapse In Bard's defense... Otaku-sempai 523 6 Apr 30, 10:23pm
                                                       Collapse Fair enough DisDwarfWoman 523 5 Apr 30, 10:29pm
                                                           Collapse Too funny! Otaku-sempai 510 4 Apr 30, 10:38pm
                                                               Collapse Welcome! DisDwarfWoman 505 3 Apr 30, 10:53pm
                                                                 JEESZZZ Louise..TOO Funny..? Bombadil 486 0 May 1, 12:03am
                                                                 Collapse Hysterical. I like the 'Evil Twin' option. // Brethil 478 1 May 1, 12:13am
                                                                       My favorite... DisDwarfWoman 471 0 May 1, 12:42am
                                               Dragon sickness or not, that's a strong point Milieuterrien 286 0 May 1, 11:35pm
                           Collapse The book is murky on this point... arithmancer 520 15 May 2, 3:26pm
                               Collapse "I have no right..." Avandel 512 13 May 2, 4:20pm
                                   Collapse hope of survival marary 499 12 May 2, 6:05pm
                                       There might be a way out... in the movie Milieuterrien 474 0 May 3, 4:08am
                                       Siege Mentality Otaku-sempai 445 0 May 3, 1:51pm
                                       Collapse Disagree that Thorin needed reminding Avandel 419 4 May 3, 5:55pm
                                           Collapse BUT Kili thought differently! marary 396 2 May 3, 8:02pm
                                               AGREED...Kili.. IS... the Catalyst.. Bombadil 364 0 May 4, 12:06am
                                             I disagree, but that's OK....(a bit OT tho...) Avandel 236 0 May 5, 7:25pm
                                           I agree and yet I disagree... lionoferebor 364 0 May 3, 11:56pm
                                       Collapse It was Dwalin lionoferebor 378 4 May 3, 11:17pm
                                           Collapse Ah, Dwalin! Kilidoescartwheels 337 3 May 4, 1:46pm
                                               and that part of the movie too DisDwarfWoman 299 0 May 4, 10:10pm
                                               Collapse I love Dwalin! lionoferebor 286 1 May 5, 1:38am
                                                   Dwalin marary 274 0 May 5, 4:02am
                               You're right it is very open to interpretation. DisDwarfWoman 424 0 May 3, 4:51pm
                       Collapse IMO no, he didn't Avandel 1067 1 Apr 30, 3:06pm
                           This whole business of "Passing into Legend"? Bombadil 1017 0 Apr 30, 4:12pm
                       Collapse One of those literature tropes Kilidoescartwheels 383 1 May 1, 2:12pm
                           bad guy redemption tropes marary 379 0 May 1, 2:24pm
       Collapse Answer inside... Brandybuckled 1061 1 Apr 30, 3:20pm
         Thang you Beery Buch Bombadil 1012 0 Apr 30, 4:25pm
       Collapse Why indeed CathrineB 873 1 Apr 30, 8:23pm
           My dad asked me the same thing. Smaug the iron 558 0 Apr 30, 8:58pm
       Meh... Gandalf the Green 523 0 Apr 30, 10:24pm
       Sailing into the West doesn't confer immortality geordie 292 0 May 1, 10:52pm
       JRRT could have had several reasons.... Eruonen 264 0 May 2, 3:29am
       They didn't have to. Bumblingidiot 403 0 May 3, 7:18pm
       because Tolkien was not a good writer mirkwoodwanderer 117 0 May 10, 9:47pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 980 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.