Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 4 of 928 (332132 posts in 13917 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 928 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Thorin's sacrifice lionoferebor 797 14 Tue, 12:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse Thorin never found out... Angharad73 457 1 Tue, 1:12pm
           Based on lionoferebor 367 0 Tue, 2:24pm
       Collapse It was like a chess move sacrifying the queen in order to win the batle but sometimes I think he could have been saved by... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 328 2 Tue, 3:34pm
           Collapse Not so sure about that Kilidoescartwheels 167 1 Tue, 8:06pm
               every day ... Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 122 0 Tue, 9:08pm
       Collapse Thorin's death was cheapened MirielCelebel 307 5 Tue, 4:39pm
           Which particular Norse texts are you thinking of? Spriggan 253 0 Tue, 4:51pm
           I "liked" it CathrineB 252 0 Tue, 5:11pm
           I agree lionoferebor 200 0 Tue, 6:39pm
           Collapse not curiosity marillaraina 189 1 Tue, 7:12pm
               Yeah, if he hadn't checked Azog would probably survive Kilidoescartwheels 160 0 Tue, 8:06pm
       Collapse I like it as well DisDwarfWoman 247 1 Tue, 5:53pm
           Exactly lionoferebor 210 0 Tue, 6:46pm
       great theory! Cirashala 100 0 Wed, 12:13am

  Collapse I miss Thorin and I feel very sad. What's going on? greenbalrog 1060 32 Tue, 12:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by BlackFox)
       Collapse You're not alone BlackFox 547 2 Tue, 12:32pm
           Collapse Straight to the point Elanor of Rohan 234 1 Tue, 9:26pm
             *gasps* BlackFox 190 0 Tue, 11:14pm
       Collapse I agree Glorfindela 505 4 Tue, 1:07pm
           Funeral Guert 492 0 Tue, 1:16pm
           I agree, and Martin also greenbalrog 465 0 Tue, 2:26pm
           Amen to THAT! Kilidoescartwheels 277 0 Tue, 7:17pm
           I thought Armitage was great when as Thorin - he saw his heir Fili killed by Azog ltnjmy 89 0 Wed, 6:15pm
       Thorin is one of the most memorable tragic heroes I've ever seen on film Elarie 500 0 Tue, 1:23pm
       Collapse Me too Ham_Sammy 431 6 Tue, 2:42pm
           Collapse Agree with your post Avandel 357 5 Tue, 5:14pm
               Collapse Killing one hero at the end of such a looong story - ? Miss-Merriweather 337 3 Tue, 6:02pm
                   Collapse Blame it on the book Kilidoescartwheels 284 2 Tue, 7:24pm
                       When the 4 set out for Ravenhill to destroy Azog... ecthelionsbeard 278 0 Tue, 7:31pm
                       I wonder swordwhale 139 0 Wed, 2:58am
               Yes, this one of the saddest moments. lionoferebor 314 0 Tue, 6:52pm
       I haven't... CathrineB 402 0 Tue, 4:07pm
       Yes Loresilme 330 0 Tue, 5:54pm
       Collapse I feel the same Kim 348 4 Tue, 5:54pm
           Collapse It's so real it's frightening greenbalrog 337 3 Tue, 6:22pm
               agreed! DisDwarfWoman 305 0 Tue, 6:27pm
               Collapse I saw it in both formats Kilidoescartwheels 277 1 Tue, 7:29pm
                   Exactly! greenbalrog 253 0 Tue, 7:53pm
       me too... mirkwoodwanderer 237 0 Tue, 8:39pm
       It's just part of being a fan... Queen of Erebor 189 0 Tue, 11:26pm
       I'm glad I'm not the only one Angharad73 195 0 Tue, 11:54pm
       Collapse i think you need to see a psychiatrist elvish.mafia 114 4 Wed, 11:11am
         Collapse I have but one question then BlackFox 93 3 Wed, 6:03pm
               I sure hope so Kim 77 0 Wed, 6:29pm
               Collapse wonder if Avandel 73 1 Wed, 7:17pm
                 Or perhaps... BlackFox 73 0 Wed, 7:31pm
       Yeah the end leaves me feeling drained Old Toby 78 0 Wed, 6:34pm

  Collapse Nazgul plot Victariongreyjoy 680 13 Tue, 11:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse The Witch King Shagrat 386 8 Tue, 12:18pm
           Collapse My take Guert 279 7 Tue, 1:14pm
               Collapse Line of kings Victariongreyjoy 256 5 Tue, 1:25pm
                   Collapse War in the North Faramir74 235 4 Tue, 1:57pm
                       Collapse I'd love to see Sauron's holiday. Spriggan 218 3 Tue, 2:00pm
                           Collapse Predictive text Faramir74 197 2 Tue, 2:15pm
                               Collapse I know but it tickled me - the great red fez, brimless and wreathed in tassels.... Spriggan 186 1 Tue, 2:22pm
                                   Bwa..HA hA Hee HEEE HOOT WOOT...Speaking Black Speak? Bombadil 137 0 Tue, 4:07pm
               You're right BlackFox 183 0 Tue, 2:21pm
       Collapse I agree with Shagrat BlackFox 294 2 Tue, 12:38pm
           Collapse My theory Victariongreyjoy 269 1 Tue, 12:56pm
               Sounds plausible BlackFox 241 0 Tue, 1:01pm
       Nothing at all - he isn't in the films. Spriggan 214 0 Tue, 1:58pm

  Collapse New TV Spot caglarkuraner 562 3 Tue, 11:19am Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse Thank you Avandel 123 1 Tue, 5:18pm
           great mirkwoodwanderer 61 0 Tue, 8:42pm
       "The #1 movie in the world!" Loresilme 61 0 Tue, 9:23pm

  Collapse Idea for an EE Epilogue Shagrat 646 5 Tue, 11:05am Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse I like that Curunir The White 241 3 Tue, 12:49pm
           You speak for me also Curunir Faramir74 190 0 Tue, 1:47pm
           Collapse Thorin's grave wmsd 211 1 Tue, 1:53pm
               Definitely both scenes Faramir74 169 0 Tue, 2:29pm
       What I was half expecting to see... moreorless 77 0 Tue, 8:27pm

  Collapse I could have done without older Bilbo/Frodo, anyone agree? MouthofSauron 653 16 Tue, 10:02am Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       It should have been left for the EE BlackFox 336 0 Tue, 10:15am
       yeah, its clunky jtarkey 326 0 Tue, 10:15am
       Well he describes Bilbo as "uncle" Spriggan 326 0 Tue, 10:15am
       I agree Azaghâl 307 0 Tue, 10:15am
       Should have been the last scene of BoFA // QuackingTroll 283 0 Tue, 11:08am
       Collapse No, I like it just fine as it is. // dormouse 269 1 Tue, 11:27am
           Agree! KingTurgon 153 0 Tue, 4:31pm
       I'm okay with it Ham_Sammy 196 0 Tue, 2:44pm
       I actually love it. Aragorn the Elfstone 161 0 Tue, 4:38pm
       I agree. Should have been left to the EE. Name 145 0 Tue, 4:49pm
       A Challenge! priell3 137 0 Tue, 5:02pm
       Was it absolutely needed? No. DigificWriter 137 0 Tue, 5:04pm
       No, for me, I rather liked the linking. Eruonen 135 0 Tue, 5:11pm
       I often skip that part Avandel 124 0 Tue, 5:46pm
       I've been saying this since AUJ's release Ardamírë 88 0 Tue, 7:54pm
       I could have done without (the one playing) Frodo mirkwoodwanderer 81 0 Tue, 8:45pm

  Collapse Sauron and NazguI scene Faramir74 539 3 Tue, 9:56am Jump to last post in thread (by MouthofSauron)
       Collapse the nine can't die unless sauron is destroyed MouthofSauron 304 2 Tue, 10:09am
           Collapse The witch-king Faramir5 139 1 Tue, 5:26pm
               Yes MouthofSauron 89 0 Tue, 8:48pm

  Collapse It's So Unfair: She Lives, But He Dies! DwellerInDale 723 18 Tue, 9:43am Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       Collapse I dont understand Glorfindela 336 3 Tue, 11:03am
           Collapse Blink and you miss her DwellerInDale 302 2 Tue, 11:24am
             Oh, it was a joke, then! Glorfindela 248 0 Tue, 12:14pm
               lol marillaraina 184 0 Tue, 3:01pm
       Collapse The Laketowners are sadly unaware Riven Delve 247 2 Tue, 1:00pm
         Collapse They are clearly all vegetarians BlackFox 230 1 Tue, 1:04pm
               As for that scene, I would have expected a long train of carts. Eruonen 155 0 Tue, 5:13pm
       Collapse As an animal lover Avandel 165 6 Tue, 5:37pm
           Collapse Maybe Thranduil can convince Riven Delve 149 2 Tue, 6:00pm
               Collapse what we need is swordwhale 138 1 Tue, 6:24pm
                   But the god thing kind of gets covered Avandel 63 0 Wed, 7:13am
           I am reading.... swordwhale 134 0 Tue, 6:22pm
           Collapse Trying to be a peacemaker here Cirashala 124 1 Tue, 7:23pm
               well said, well said! swordwhale 15 0 Thu, 3:15pm
       Collapse they may have already Cirashala 122 2 Tue, 7:08pm
           Collapse subject marillaraina 106 1 Tue, 8:19pm
               I would think Cirashala 100 0 Tue, 8:42pm
       life is never fair mirkwoodwanderer 40 0 Wed, 4:27pm

  Collapse Flag Semaphore Faramir74 328 3 Tue, 8:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Elarie)
       Collapse Loved it, but syameese 220 2 Tue, 9:05am
           Collapse Agreed Faramir74 194 1 Tue, 9:23am
               Thank goodness for those eagles Elarie 119 0 Tue, 1:00pm

  Collapse Laketown? Laineth 326 2 Tue, 5:25am Jump to last post in thread (by Laineth)
       Collapse not sure Cirashala 44 1 Wed, 12:25am
           Of course! Laineth 39 0 Wed, 12:46am

  Collapse SMAUG …. The best part of the films?? MouthofSauron 552 12 Tue, 5:20am Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       Collapse nah deskp 286 1 Tue, 5:35am
           i enjoyed the furnaces :) MouthofSauron 220 0 Tue, 6:28am
       Collapse grounded Gandy 254 1 Tue, 5:48am
           well ... MouthofSauron 215 0 Tue, 6:30am
       Collapse Smaug burning Laketown... tsmith675 219 2 Tue, 7:23am
           Collapse it was a great sequence indeed MouthofSauron 147 1 Tue, 9:50am
             2nd & 3rd Viewing today? Bombadil 141 0 Tue, 10:17am
       Collapse There wasn't enough... Angharad73 194 1 Tue, 8:04am
           agreed MouthofSauron 149 0 Tue, 9:48am
       I think that whole scene is perfection Glorfindela 137 0 Tue, 10:58am
       I found it the most thrilling and breathtaking Elarie 110 0 Tue, 12:39pm
       It was great Ham_Sammy 75 0 Tue, 2:49pm

  Collapse Is DOS the best of the three? demnation 789 28 Tue, 5:03am Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       Collapse DOS was the best out of the three, PJ said that last year when DOS came out MouthofSauron 411 7 Tue, 5:07am
           Collapse It's interesting the PJ thinks so demnation 398 3 Tue, 5:09am
               Collapse ACTUALLY ... MouthofSauron 403 1 Tue, 5:11am
                   He does seem to change his mind quite a bit demnation 382 0 Tue, 5:14am
               Funnily enough Glorfindela 190 0 Tue, 10:48am
           Collapse No he didn't Faramir5 342 1 Tue, 5:42am
               The source was Ian McKellen. Silverlode 322 0 Tue, 6:08am
           PJ says every new film is his favourite... elvish.mafia 21 0 Wed, 11:16am
       Collapse Of the Theatricals - Not in my opinion. Aragorn the Elfstone 398 3 Tue, 5:08am
           Collapse yes, the DOS EE breathes life into the rushed DOS TE MouthofSauron 380 2 Tue, 5:09am
               Collapse The DOS EE is my favorite so far Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 235 1 Tue, 9:27am
                   the AUJ TE ... MouthofSauron 219 0 Tue, 9:45am
       Far from it dubulous 340 0 Tue, 6:14am
       I think BOT5A is the most consistant, the other two were better for one half. moreorless 293 0 Tue, 7:25am
       DoS should have been the best... tsmith675 299 0 Tue, 7:27am
       I agree JTurner82 265 0 Tue, 7:54am
       Not in my opinion Angharad73 274 0 Tue, 7:57am
       Collapse On the subject of each film's quality... Aragorn the Elfstone 289 2 Tue, 8:03am
           Collapse Completely MEIGWIT 133 1 Tue, 1:09pm
             One director has done it before KingTurgon 63 0 Tue, 4:41pm
       I think BOFA is the most well rounded, but not necessarilly the best jtarkey 223 0 Tue, 9:42am
       Collapse I think DOS is the best. Spriggan 207 1 Tue, 9:48am
         Bom does NOT think it is Anywhere? Near the Time to pronounce Bombadil 187 0 Tue, 10:29am
       No – DoS is definitely not the best of the three, for me Glorfindela 201 0 Tue, 10:47am
       I am not sure. NecromancerRising 171 0 Tue, 11:04am
       I don't care about critics Ham_Sammy 111 0 Tue, 2:55pm
       Re: Is TDoS the best of the three? DigificWriter 58 0 Tue, 5:11pm
       they are all good in their own way, but Bot5A is my favorite mirkwoodwanderer 19 0 Wed, 4:28pm

  Collapse Missed opportunity …. MouthofSauron 637 8 Tue, 3:33am Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       Collapse You have a point there Ham_Sammy 296 3 Tue, 3:35am
           Collapse Perhaps they are not dead Glorfindela 219 2 Tue, 4:52am
               The boar definitely died, you can see it put its head down and close its eyes MouthofSauron 214 0 Tue, 4:59am
               perhaps Ham_Sammy 167 0 Tue, 6:57am
       Collapse LOL!!! lionoferebor 252 3 Tue, 4:10am
           Collapse We never see Daisy after the tunnels, do we? Silverlode 232 2 Tue, 4:28am
               I think Beorn killed Daisy in DoS... QuackingTroll 132 0 Tue, 10:34am
               so much for... swordwhale 35 0 Wed, 2:59am

Collapse BOT5A Bolg Observations/Nitpicks... NateGate 454 4 Tue, 2:41am Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Congratulations... ecthelionsbeard 233 0 Tue, 3:04am
       Love this post! lol! elentari3018 168 0 Tue, 4:03am
       well deskp 155 0 Tue, 4:44am
       Re: Tauriel... arithmancer 20 0 Wed, 8:17pm

Collapse Was Dain CGI or Motion Capture? delius82 758 26 Tue, 2:35am Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       IMO He looked fine on the battlefield with Thorin... Aragorn the Elfstone 429 0 Tue, 2:39am
       I was actually surprised... Misty Mountain Hop 418 0 Tue, 2:50am
       Collapse He looked perfectly fine to me. Scorchster 388 1 Tue, 2:52am
           I agree – I thought he looked perfectly fine Glorfindela 280 0 Tue, 4:50am
       LMAO. Really?? MouthofSauron 372 0 Tue, 3:27am
       I couldn't tell Ham_Sammy 331 0 Tue, 3:39am
       Something I noticed upon the 2nd viewing tarasaurus 366 0 Tue, 3:47am
       Collapse Dain was CGI/Motion Capture in every shot besides one... jtarkey 370 14 Tue, 4:39am
           Collapse but why?? MouthofSauron 325 13 Tue, 4:41am
               Its not. jtarkey 318 0 Tue, 4:46am
               Collapse The speculation is Silverlode 331 11 Tue, 4:48am
                   its telling that they spent time on it to make it look convincing, and even cause speculation jtarkey 296 0 Tue, 4:52am
                   Collapse Not health related... Aragorn the Elfstone 308 9 Tue, 5:15am
                       Collapse Thank God jtarkey 272 5 Tue, 5:25am
                           Collapse Agreed. Aragorn the Elfstone 255 4 Tue, 5:28am
                               Collapse did you by chance notice the OTS shot where its him in costume? jtarkey 262 3 Tue, 5:33am
                                   I didn't, but... Aragorn the Elfstone 241 0 Tue, 5:37am
                                   I know which one you mean. cats16 230 0 Tue, 6:00am
                                   cg Gandy 225 0 Tue, 6:03am
                       I know this is the 'official' line, but I'm sill not entirely convinced by it... adt100 170 0 Tue, 9:56am
                       Collapse Ehhh redgiraffe 33 1 Wed, 2:48am
                           I have a feeling... DigificWriter 29 0 Wed, 3:29am
       CGI/Motion capture = same thing adt100 160 0 Tue, 9:50am
       Collapse It was cg, the movement gave it away. Scourge of the Stoors 163 1 Tue, 9:52am
           ... yet the movement will have been entirely motion captured surely... adt100 150 0 Tue, 9:58am
       Whatever he was he was... adu 120 0 Tue, 2:15pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 928 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.