Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 4 of 951 (342349 posts in 14263 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 951 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
Collapse Bilbo’s Birthday Bash: BotFA Time Capsule - Capsules Retrieval Lurker in the Mirk 461 15 Jan 22, 2:28am Jump to last post in thread (by Eruvandi)
       Thanks very much for posting, Lurker Glorfindela 232 0 Jan 22, 6:36am
       Kim's Time Capsule Retrieval Kim 232 0 Jan 22, 6:49am
       Collapse DanielLB's Time Capsule Retrieval DanielLB 216 8 Jan 22, 8:19am
         Collapse Being somewhat dumb Glorfindela 183 7 Jan 22, 11:32am
               I would add Glorfindela 136 0 Jan 22, 3:52pm
               Collapse Luthien reference Eruvandi 91 5 Jan 22, 10:53pm
                   Collapse Oh, you experts Glorfindela 81 4 Jan 22, 11:35pm
                       Collapse If you get the chance... Eruvandi 59 3 Jan 23, 3:16pm
                           I have been meaning to Glorfindela 53 0 Jan 23, 4:11pm
                           Collapse In addition entmaiden 49 1 Jan 23, 5:13pm
                             I know, right! Eruvandi 48 0 Jan 23, 6:50pm
       Time capsule from a dormouse dormouse 212 0 Jan 22, 9:39am
       BlackFox's Time Capsule Retrieval BlackFox 187 0 Jan 22, 10:00am
       Riven Delve's Time Capsule Retrieved! Riven Delve 138 0 Jan 22, 4:39pm
       Eruvandi's Capsule Retrieval Eruvandi 97 0 Jan 22, 10:22pm

Collapse Is PJ everybody's Daddy? Bombadil 576 9 Jan 22, 2:05am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse I'll give a favorable vote... Ithilisa 241 2 Jan 22, 3:58am
           Collapse OUR Barefoot Director..What Bombadil 226 1 Jan 22, 4:10am
               Oh yeah, Ithilisa 220 0 Jan 22, 4:19am
       Collapse I'd just say Glorfindela 212 3 Jan 22, 6:41am
           Collapse I second that // dormouse 153 1 Jan 22, 9:01am
             Another of SIR Peter Jackson's Charm iZZZ... Bombadil 123 0 Jan 22, 12:19pm
           Hear, hear! // Loresilme 90 0 Jan 22, 3:23pm
       Collapse PJs greatest accomplishment EomundDaughter 138 1 Jan 22, 12:19pm
           The Definition of Innovation Izzz Bombadil 65 0 Jan 22, 8:46pm

  Collapse 2 new BOFTA Bluray Covers smaug the stupendous 1264 20 Jan 21, 11:49pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse Yes I saw those! tsmith675 526 6 Jan 21, 11:55pm
           Smaug and Bard steelbook Glorfindela 383 0 Jan 22, 6:37am
           Collapse Possible Bluray & DVD covers? Via Amazon Canada tsmith675 196 4 Jan 22, 6:56pm
               Amazon UK just shows the one pointing the sword for all three // dormouse 166 0 Jan 22, 7:01pm
               Collapse Admittedly worried Pandallo 138 2 Jan 22, 8:39pm
                   Collapse Why Bard? Erm...dragons;ayer, maybe?// arithmancer 110 1 Jan 22, 9:13pm
                       Yes but... Pandallo 107 0 Jan 22, 9:26pm
       Have some links... smtfhw 374 0 Jan 22, 8:25am
       Collapse I'm looking forward to a release date.... dormouse 329 1 Jan 22, 9:00am
           Could be a boxed set coming too... QuackingTroll 273 0 Jan 22, 1:07pm
       Collapse I still love that Smaug/Bard poster/cover... Arannir 231 9 Jan 22, 3:20pm
           Collapse Has anything been said about when the EE will come out? dormouse 229 8 Jan 22, 4:00pm
               Not to my knowledge, but November would be a safe bet MechaGodzilla 183 0 Jan 22, 6:40pm
               My guesses for releases tsmith675 188 0 Jan 22, 6:50pm
               I assume... Arannir 171 0 Jan 22, 6:54pm
               Collapse The fires of lsengard will spread... Voronwë_the_Faithful 163 3 Jan 22, 7:39pm
                   Collapse You seem to be very merry today! ;-) // dormouse 145 2 Jan 22, 7:42pm
                       Collapse Someone has to be! Voronwë_the_Faithful 148 1 Jan 22, 8:00pm
                           Ain't that the truth! // dormouse 93 0 Jan 22, 11:02pm
               Me either Elessar 153 0 Jan 22, 7:44pm

  Collapse BotFA the least well-received - what's your take? MechaGodzilla 1669 64 Jan 21, 7:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by Noria)
       Collapse I do consider BotFA the worst Drakblod 912 2 Jan 21, 7:43pm
           Shame Lindele 812 0 Jan 21, 8:09pm
           Dear oh dear.... patrickk 230 0 Jan 22, 10:12pm
       I don't think its the weakest but it isn't the strongest Elessar 830 0 Jan 21, 7:44pm
       My take on this pettytyrant101 829 0 Jan 21, 7:45pm
       In terms of awards.. moreorless 754 0 Jan 21, 8:05pm
       Collapse While I'm a fan of the movie LoremIpsum 752 1 Jan 21, 8:40pm
           The biggest problem with the movie i have is... NoelGallagher 731 0 Jan 21, 8:57pm
       Collapse In my opinion TnuaccayM 694 6 Jan 21, 9:16pm
           Collapse Not sure LotR's comes into it pettytyrant101 655 5 Jan 21, 9:21pm
               Collapse I understand TnuaccayM 461 1 Jan 22, 12:56am
                   It depends on how you define adaptation pettytyrant101 434 0 Jan 22, 1:47am
               Collapse Not alone redgiraffe 377 1 Jan 22, 5:34am
                   It actually precedes... patrickk 202 0 Jan 22, 10:34pm
               The LoTR... patrickk 199 0 Jan 22, 10:29pm
       BoFA is my favorite of the 3, but... tsmith675 674 0 Jan 21, 9:44pm
       Personally, I think the critics are right. Spriggan 689 0 Jan 21, 9:54pm
       Collapse It certainly has left the theaters EomundDaughter 616 1 Jan 21, 10:48pm
           In my area, Chicago suburban...it is still showing at least Eruonen 115 0 Jan 22, 8:58pm
       Collapse I think Thrain II 586 2 Jan 21, 10:50pm
           Collapse Thanks - was just thinking it would have been better here! // Eleniel 535 1 Jan 21, 10:55pm
             No problem, I thought that too! // Thrain II 517 0 Jan 21, 11:01pm
       Collapse I only know which ones I like the best Glorfindela 554 3 Jan 21, 11:24pm
           Collapse What about LotR? QuackingTroll 528 2 Jan 21, 11:28pm
               Yes, my list does too Glorfindela 518 0 Jan 21, 11:36pm
               How I'd rank all six. Elessar 253 0 Jan 22, 2:17pm
       I think it's because ghost_matt 531 0 Jan 21, 11:41pm
       Do you mean self or opinion on others? Avandel 466 0 Jan 22, 1:22am
       Collapse No surprise. Arannir 384 27 Jan 22, 8:04am
           Collapse I think.. Drakblod 383 13 Jan 22, 8:21am
               Collapse Oh dear ... DanielLB 370 5 Jan 22, 8:23am
                 Collapse It comes in books? Brethil 173 4 Jan 23, 4:42am
                       Collapse There's only one?// arithmancer 153 1 Jan 23, 5:19am
                           I *think* so. I'm just hoping it has lots of pictures. // Brethil 146 0 Jan 23, 5:58am
                       Collapse I find they are really good doorstops. DanielLB 141 1 Jan 23, 7:31am
                           Now that is Starling 125 0 Jan 23, 8:44am
               That is just wrong. Arannir 355 0 Jan 22, 8:25am
               Well that is as silly Spriggan 330 0 Jan 22, 9:24am
               John Rateliff's publishers will need to be told! Voronwë_the_Faithful 294 0 Jan 22, 1:28pm
               Collapse I suspect... patrickk 209 3 Jan 22, 10:39pm
                   Collapse The idea that it is not a great children's book is bizarre. Bumblingidiot 112 2 Jan 23, 2:26pm
                       Why so? BlackFox 110 0 Jan 23, 2:38pm
                       As I said... patrickk 81 0 Jan 23, 9:18pm
           Collapse What makes BOFA inferior to DOS/AUJ? macfalk 317 1 Jan 22, 12:24pm
               IMHO Arannir 296 0 Jan 22, 1:07pm
           Collapse WOW Elessar 291 9 Jan 22, 2:15pm
             Collapse I agree with your 'WoW' Glorfindela 244 8 Jan 22, 3:35pm
                   I'm with ya. Elessar 221 0 Jan 22, 3:39pm
                   Collapse Are you referring to my post? Arannir 233 4 Jan 22, 3:40pm
                       Collapse No, I wasn't referring to your post Glorfindela 205 2 Jan 22, 3:50pm
                           Collapse Sorry. Arannir 199 1 Jan 22, 3:51pm
                               I think I may have got the posts mixed up Glorfindela 190 0 Jan 22, 3:57pm
                       I don't think you're a hater Elessar 208 0 Jan 22, 3:53pm
                   Collapse I'm with ya all the way on this one Old Toby 185 1 Jan 22, 4:49pm
                       Yes Glorfindela 166 0 Jan 22, 5:33pm
           Yes burrahobbit 133 0 Jan 22, 8:13pm
       Collapse It maybe an internet concensus of sorts.... dormouse 349 2 Jan 22, 8:57am
           Collapse No the critical reception is relatively poor burrahobbit 166 1 Jan 22, 7:44pm
               for me... Jeffrodo 139 0 Jan 22, 8:03pm
       Its psychological !! EomundDaughter 291 0 Jan 22, 12:59pm
       For me, its biggest flaw... RosieLass 136 0 Jan 22, 9:33pm
       Collapse In the end, it has made a lot of $ so it has been well received by many theater Eruonen 198 1 Jan 22, 11:32pm
           This is how I feel Noria 48 0 Jan 24, 3:48pm
       It is not the weakest but... Bernhardina 77 0 Jan 24, 12:23am

  Collapse Article about Weta CGI software Elarie 524 4 Jan 21, 3:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by brotherbeck)
       Collapse I'll have a go at trying to explain ray-tracing for general readers... QuackingTroll 191 3 Jan 21, 6:21pm
           Oh I should also mention one of the down sides of Ray-tracing QuackingTroll 161 0 Jan 21, 6:37pm
           Collapse Thank you for that great explanation Elarie 123 1 Jan 21, 7:57pm
               Many Thanks brotherbeck 44 0 Jan 22, 10:11pm

  Collapse What are the chances that in the EE we will see... Holly Hobbit 1315 15 Jan 21, 7:18am Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       My take... arithmancer 535 0 Jan 21, 12:08pm
       A lot of posters have said they would like this issue resolved Glorfindela 556 0 Jan 21, 12:19pm
       Collapse Nothing changed between Thranduil and Thorin. annthanatos 330 12 Jan 21, 8:33pm
           Collapse it was stated Adrianna 312 11 Jan 21, 9:08pm
               I want to see Tauriel glor 292 0 Jan 21, 9:21pm
               Collapse I wish it could be added to the EE, more than anyone, but... annthanatos 302 7 Jan 21, 9:22pm
                   Collapse Hope for the best! Adrianna 264 6 Jan 21, 9:31pm
                       Collapse OK cross my fingers... annthanatos 258 1 Jan 21, 9:43pm
                           Mmm! Adrianna 161 0 Jan 22, 7:40am
                       Collapse PJ's priorities... Eleniel 279 3 Jan 21, 10:28pm
                           Collapse Hmm... Dcole4 91 2 Jan 22, 11:40pm
                               Never venture east... Pandallo 86 0 Jan 23, 12:30am
                               I think you misinterpreted PJ's statement. arithmancer 88 0 Jan 23, 1:48am
               Collapse Tauriel Harukalioncourt 190 1 Jan 22, 6:27am
                   Not all... Otaku-sempai 140 0 Jan 22, 2:23pm

  Collapse Azog should have spoken Common tongue in certain parts! boldog 932 23 Jan 21, 6:42am Jump to last post in thread (by Ereinion Nénharma)
       Collapse Not Orkish. Otaku-sempai 479 3 Jan 21, 11:11am
           Collapse I think it is Orkish though? Lio 192 2 Jan 22, 1:55am
               Orcs. Harukalioncourt 156 0 Jan 22, 6:42am
               Both? Otaku-sempai 112 0 Jan 22, 2:15pm
       Perhaps he's not good at languages... // dormouse 400 0 Jan 21, 12:07pm
       Collapse I don't find it at all odd. Glorfindela 454 4 Jan 21, 12:15pm
           Collapse I thought you of all people would understand the nit-pick. Arannir 337 3 Jan 21, 3:53pm
               Collapse What does that have to do with the subject being discussed here? Glorfindela 320 2 Jan 21, 4:05pm
                   Collapse It was a tongue in cheek comment. Arannir 309 1 Jan 21, 4:07pm
                       Oh, OK – me sorry, too Glorfindela 296 0 Jan 21, 4:14pm
       No opinion in general... arithmancer 423 0 Jan 21, 12:19pm
       As arthimancer said lionoferebor 365 0 Jan 21, 2:44pm
       The nature of Black Speech Riven Delve 366 0 Jan 21, 3:39pm
       It didn't seem to me... Aragorn the Elfstone 216 0 Jan 21, 11:19pm
       I think it worked with the kind of dialog Azog had... moreorless 149 0 Jan 22, 8:17am
       Collapse I think it would have diluted the effect Loresilme 104 1 Jan 22, 3:51pm
           I agree.... dormouse 94 0 Jan 22, 3:54pm
       I think they always pulled off the change of language moments. Arannir 100 0 Jan 22, 3:52pm
       Collapse I love the use of Black Speech for a couple of reasons... Pandallo 87 4 Jan 22, 5:51pm
           Collapse But he doesn't, though... Bofur01 83 3 Jan 22, 6:02pm
               Collapse Good point. I did not know that. Pandallo 75 2 Jan 22, 6:10pm
                   Collapse They probably don't have a specific word for "Oakenshield" in either language... Bofur01 63 1 Jan 22, 8:34pm
                       Azog's pronunciation Ereinion Nénharma 40 0 Jan 23, 6:31pm

  Collapse ouch! balbo biggins 1287 18 Jan 21, 2:44am Jump to last post in thread (by VeArkenstone)
       lol! Bishop 584 0 Jan 21, 2:52am
       Collapse Yes, I saw that the very first time I watched the movie! Old Toby 524 1 Jan 21, 4:21am
           HAHA boldog 449 0 Jan 21, 6:46am
       Collapse Eh Drakblod 454 1 Jan 21, 8:09am
           I agree // Starling 393 0 Jan 21, 8:59am
       Collapse No he doesn't.... dormouse 443 8 Jan 21, 9:48am
           Collapse yes he does i think balbo biggins 375 7 Jan 21, 12:24pm
               yes, it's the beam he hits as he goes into the other room Old Toby 312 0 Jan 21, 3:20pm
               Collapse RA was a Stormtrooper in The Phantom Menace// glor 185 5 Jan 21, 9:13pm
                   Collapse He wasn't a Stormtrooper Kim 191 4 Jan 21, 9:43pm
                       Collapse I stand corrected glor 149 3 Jan 22, 1:42am
                           Collapse Simply it's good guys vs. bad guys Ithilisa 132 2 Jan 22, 4:02am
                               Collapse I think he was a Naboo guard, not a pilot. Meneldor 87 1 Jan 22, 7:13pm
                                   I got the title from IMDB Kim 78 0 Jan 22, 8:03pm
       Isn't that the same door frame Gandalf bumps his head on? QuackingTroll 311 0 Jan 21, 3:25pm
       I'm sorry. gliido 260 0 Jan 21, 5:56pm
       very subtle swordwhale 217 0 Jan 21, 7:31pm
       I still did not see it! Probably not. VeArkenstone 44 0 Jan 23, 8:17pm

  Collapse So I finally saw BOFA - my thoughts Scalpy 1212 18 Jan 21, 12:43am Jump to last post in thread (by NoelGallagher)
       Collapse re the dragonslayer Avandel 581 1 Jan 21, 5:06am
           Of course... Scalpy 506 0 Jan 21, 5:47am
       Collapse I think you're being too nice.. Drakblod 524 5 Jan 21, 8:24am
           Collapse I think you are being too nice. NecromancerRising 462 4 Jan 21, 10:06am
               Collapse Necro... NoelGallagher 273 2 Jan 21, 5:50pm
                   Collapse I am kidding of course NecromancerRising 169 1 Jan 21, 9:23pm
                       well done NoelGallagher 163 0 Jan 21, 9:51pm
               You're the one who is being too generous Voronwë_the_Faithful 177 0 Jan 21, 9:32pm
       Collapse Well.... dormouse 481 7 Jan 21, 8:38am
           Collapse Hmmm Scalpy 431 6 Jan 21, 9:19am
               Collapse OK... dormouse 413 2 Jan 21, 9:47am
                   Collapse Smaug is a beautiful scene IMO Avandel 280 1 Jan 21, 4:53pm
                       I agree.... dormouse 206 0 Jan 21, 6:58pm
               Collapse I think Glorfindela 351 2 Jan 21, 12:23pm
                   Collapse They were WERE-worms QuackingTroll 211 1 Jan 21, 7:02pm
                       Tolkien pettytyrant101 208 0 Jan 21, 7:10pm
       Completely disagree – it's a 10/10 for me Glorfindela 393 0 Jan 21, 12:22pm
       Munchkins and deaf ears lionoferebor 232 0 Jan 21, 7:07pm

  Collapse Rambling Thoughts On Restraint and Fan Edits brotherbeck 1729 108 Jan 20, 7:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by brotherbeck)
       Collapse Agreed Istaris'staffs 785 6 Jan 20, 8:24pm
           Collapse I don't follow any vitriol either. Spriggan 750 3 Jan 20, 8:41pm
               Collapse Just one small point frodolives 591 2 Jan 20, 11:02pm
                   Collapse Of course. Spriggan 547 1 Jan 20, 11:38pm
                       Yes – I agree Glorfindela 542 0 Jan 20, 11:48pm
           Barrie Osborne and Mark Ordesky... BrandonMata 730 0 Jan 20, 9:41pm
           Totally agree with you! mangotree 436 0 Jan 21, 3:55am
       I don't really have a problem with fan edits TnuaccayM 711 0 Jan 20, 9:10pm
     *shrug* Avandel 703 0 Jan 20, 9:19pm
       Collapse My thoughts on fan-edits WholeUnderGround 708 3 Jan 20, 9:29pm
           ... and an example involving all concerned parties WholeUnderGround 643 0 Jan 20, 9:47pm
           Collapse Creative people like to have food and housing. Bumblingidiot 525 1 Jan 21, 12:28am
               Of course WholeUnderGround 443 0 Jan 21, 3:33am
       Collapse Fan edits are being discussed more with TH because of the 3 movie split sycorax82 691 3 Jan 20, 9:32pm
           Collapse These Hobbit movies are crying for a Fan Edit Legolas_Shoehorn 623 2 Jan 20, 10:30pm
               Collapse I trimed a three hour cut of the three theatricall releases Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 529 1 Jan 21, 12:45am
                   would love to see this edit! PM me some cut info? cartermoulton 418 0 Jan 21, 5:37am
       LotR "fan edit" Mooseboy018 616 0 Jan 20, 10:58pm
       Collapse here here balbo biggins 525 1 Jan 21, 12:59am
           to add... balbo biggins 464 0 Jan 21, 2:26am
       Collapse Not interested Aragorn the Elfstone 438 5 Jan 21, 7:29am
           I'd just like to cheer this post! // dormouse 378 0 Jan 21, 8:32am
           Collapse Agreed Elessar 309 2 Jan 21, 2:04pm
               Thanks a lot for your generalisation :( // Bofur01 291 0 Jan 21, 2:18pm
               You're welcome????? Elessar 278 0 Jan 21, 2:46pm
           Ditto, thank you, Aragorn the Elfstone. mae govannen 204 0 Jan 22, 7:30am
       I would agree and disagree with elements of this... moreorless 358 0 Jan 21, 11:14am
       Collapse For those who don't like the idea of a fan edit... AshNazg 382 74 Jan 21, 1:34pm
           Collapse But if the edit you saw includes BotFA... dormouse 333 10 Jan 21, 2:19pm
               Collapse How did you manage to post my post word for word? Voronwë_the_Faithful 308 1 Jan 21, 2:20pm
                   :-) // dormouse 286 0 Jan 21, 2:24pm
               Ditto NecromancerRising 288 0 Jan 21, 2:45pm
               Collapse Quite – they are vanity projects and illegal Glorfindela 294 6 Jan 21, 2:57pm
                   Speaking as someone pettytyrant101 272 0 Jan 21, 3:17pm
                   Collapse Fan edits in general are NOT illegal, entmaiden 264 4 Jan 21, 3:32pm
                       We are not talking about 'personal use' here, or non-pirated material Glorfindela 251 0 Jan 21, 3:52pm
                       Collapse I'm not sure that it is legal in the UK, entmaiden.... dormouse 232 2 Jan 21, 4:11pm
                           Collapse Since TORN is in the US, entmaiden 434 1 Jan 21, 5:47pm
                               Sorry, yes, I wasn't arguing with you.... dormouse 393 0 Jan 21, 6:44pm
           Collapse So, it is a foregone conclusion NecromancerRising 329 52 Jan 21, 2:39pm
               Collapse Obviously not everyone's opinion is going to be the same... AshNazg 286 1 Jan 21, 3:15pm
                   Is it as many people as like the grumpy cat on YouTube? Spriggan 310 0 Jan 21, 9:39pm
               Collapse Indeed Glorfindela 266 3 Jan 21, 3:56pm
                   Collapse I did not follow closely the events NecromancerRising 240 2 Jan 21, 4:18pm
                       Yes, it came as rather a nasty surprise to me, too Glorfindela 230 0 Jan 21, 4:26pm
                       It would be a a suprise DjU 389 0 Jan 21, 7:08pm
               Collapse Sad but true... moreorless 247 45 Jan 21, 5:04pm
                   Glad to hear i am not alone on this NecromancerRising 300 0 Jan 21, 9:50pm
                   Collapse Yes, I agree Glorfindela 274 43 Jan 21, 11:56pm
                       Collapse Its not just the negative view.. moreorless 231 1 Jan 22, 5:02am
                           Just to say, wise words, again Glorfindela 208 0 Jan 22, 6:33am
                       Collapse It's almost unrecognisable ... DanielLB 218 10 Jan 22, 8:03am
                           Collapse But that's the saddest thing of all, Daniel.... dormouse 208 5 Jan 22, 8:51am
                               Well said Elessar 287 0 Jan 22, 2:41pm
                               Collapse Negativity never wears me down completely. Aragorn the Elfstone 222 1 Jan 22, 4:23pm
                                   Agreed 100% Elessar 188 0 Jan 22, 4:48pm
                               Collapse No amount of negativity or positivity ... DanielLB 113 1 Jan 22, 7:12pm
                                   Sorry - I know you're not keen on BotFA so I wasn't thinking of that.... dormouse 154 0 Jan 22, 7:53pm
                           Collapse Again I wouldnt say its just the criticism.. moreorless 187 2 Jan 22, 9:13am
                               Collapse That is also true Glorfindela 158 1 Jan 22, 11:10am
                                   I would say pettytyrant101 140 0 Jan 22, 12:47pm
                           I think it saddens me that you really didn't like it Elessar 111 0 Jan 22, 2:37pm
                       Collapse That's why I have not been around much Elessar 135 29 Jan 22, 2:19pm
                           Collapse Yes, I agree, Elessar Glorfindela 124 28 Jan 22, 2:26pm
                               Collapse There has to be a place somewhere on the internets where people who enjoy the films can congregate... Imladris18 279 27 Jan 22, 3:09pm
                                   Collapse disagree balbo biggins 266 2 Jan 22, 3:23pm
                                       Collapse Of course, I'm not saying I want an echo chamber. I'm not going to abandon TORn or anything. Imladris18 230 1 Jan 22, 4:11pm
                                           its fine balbo biggins 199 0 Jan 22, 4:38pm
                                   Collapse The trouble is, would not the haters migrate there as well? Glorfindela 262 23 Jan 22, 3:28pm
                                       Collapse That's the thing Elessar 254 21 Jan 22, 3:36pm
                                           Collapse Again this used to be the case here... moreorless 237 17 Jan 22, 4:02pm
                                               Collapse That's something I've noticed a few places. Elessar 193 14 Jan 22, 4:49pm
                                                   Here's the thing... Pandallo 174 0 Jan 22, 5:20pm
                                                   Collapse Negativity On These Boards brotherbeck 174 12 Jan 22, 5:50pm
                                                       Collapse Then wait. Pandallo 162 8 Jan 22, 5:55pm
                                                           Collapse bit harsh balbo biggins 153 7 Jan 22, 6:12pm
                                                               Collapse Yeah... no. Pandallo 144 4 Jan 22, 6:28pm
                                                                   Collapse lol balbo biggins 89 3 Jan 22, 7:46pm
                                                                       Collapse Very well. Pandallo 132 2 Jan 22, 8:28pm
                                                                           whatevs balbo biggins 117 0 Jan 22, 8:56pm
                                                                           The forges sequence... brotherbeck 117 0 Jan 22, 9:07pm
                                                               Collapse Loathing for the filmaker...? brotherbeck 143 1 Jan 22, 6:29pm
                                                                   Then that's fine. Pandallo 134 0 Jan 22, 6:33pm
                                                       Alfrid arithmancer 140 0 Jan 22, 6:22pm
                                                       I'v seen very little open hostility. moreorless 125 0 Jan 22, 6:59pm
                                                       Ok Elessar 112 0 Jan 22, 7:08pm
                                               Collapse There's the CHOW threads entmaiden 137 1 Jan 22, 8:05pm
                                                   Yes - we will have the sign-up thread up this weekend. DanielLB 95 0 Jan 22, 9:51pm
                                           Collapse Why worry - we are all completely insignificant. Spriggan 87 2 Jan 22, 10:45pm
                                               Collapse I don't worry a lot Elessar 73 1 Jan 22, 11:19pm
                                                   Negativity On The Boards brotherbeck 65 0 Jan 23, 2:27am
                                       disagree balbo biggins 246 0 Jan 22, 3:37pm
           Collapse You seem to be missing the core reasons for the objections. Aragorn the Elfstone 257 8 Jan 21, 4:45pm
               Collapse your view pettytyrant101 225 7 Jan 21, 5:04pm
                   Collapse That is not my "view". Aragorn the Elfstone 421 3 Jan 21, 6:22pm
                       Collapse The law pettytyrant101 408 2 Jan 21, 6:31pm
                           Collapse Still illegal. Aragorn the Elfstone 405 1 Jan 21, 6:38pm
                               Not all countries pettytyrant101 390 0 Jan 21, 6:47pm
                   Collapse Why nit go all the way through? tattooed_dwarf 370 2 Jan 21, 7:30pm
                       Collapse Most likely pettytyrant101 357 1 Jan 21, 7:53pm
                           fair points tattooed_dwarf 325 0 Jan 21, 9:00pm
           The studio would have never greenlit... tsmith675 233 0 Jan 21, 4:46pm
       Collapse fan edits Ham_Sammy 276 3 Jan 21, 3:03pm
           Collapse Drastic changes can be made just through editing pettytyrant101 252 2 Jan 21, 4:02pm
               Collapse But Faramir does take Frodo and Sam captive in the book... dormouse 223 1 Jan 21, 4:23pm
                   A different argument for a differen ttime perhaps pettytyrant101 235 0 Jan 21, 4:40pm
       ultimate fan service balbo biggins 368 0 Jan 21, 7:58pm
       I just recall what Tolkien himself wrote: Darkstone 148 0 Jan 22, 6:37pm

  Collapse The Nine choral theme Faramir74 486 4 Jan 20, 6:21pm Jump to last post in thread (by KingTurgon)
       Collapse No I didn't FrogmortonJustice65 270 2 Jan 20, 6:22pm
           Collapse Only on... Faramir74 265 1 Jan 20, 6:28pm
               One more I think KingTurgon 227 0 Jan 20, 7:19pm
       Yes! SafeUnderHill 228 0 Jan 20, 6:57pm

  Collapse Will more Star Wars = more Middle Earth movies? Jeffrodo 1042 25 Jan 20, 3:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by EomundDaughter)
       Collapse I doubt there will be movement towards more Tolkien films in the near future FrogmortonJustice65 591 4 Jan 20, 4:04pm
           Collapse $ Jeffrodo 544 3 Jan 20, 4:08pm
               Collapse Hm... zalmoxis 430 2 Jan 20, 5:52pm
                   Collapse "created by..." Jeffrodo 429 1 Jan 20, 5:58pm
                       This is really the key difference with rights.. moreorless 186 0 Jan 21, 10:35am
       'Star Wars' and Middle-earth don't exactly equate. Otaku-sempai 509 0 Jan 20, 4:44pm
       Collapse I can't see a correlation between Star Wars and Middle Earth dormouse 487 8 Jan 20, 5:23pm
           similarities Jeffrodo 459 0 Jan 20, 5:34pm
           Collapse well balbo biggins 408 6 Jan 20, 6:22pm
               Sort of... Otaku-sempai 305 0 Jan 20, 9:36pm
               But there's a difference.... dormouse 261 0 Jan 20, 11:22pm
               Collapse Actually... Jeffrodo 168 3 Jan 21, 11:33am
                   Collapse Not the same as Star Wars Harukalioncourt 73 2 Jan 22, 1:01pm
                       books swordwhale 51 0 Jan 22, 4:38pm
                       Silmarillion swordwhale 55 0 Jan 22, 4:40pm
       I've always been curious about a stand alone movie. Misty Mountain Hop 343 0 Jan 20, 8:37pm
       It wouldn't surprise me Scalpy 239 0 Jan 21, 1:03am
       Collapse its a simple answer MouthofSauron 228 2 Jan 21, 3:23am
           I can't see the Silmarillion being done Scalpy 225 0 Jan 21, 3:51am
           No... Jeffrodo 173 0 Jan 21, 11:21am
       Personally the main thing I would want is another shift of tone.. moreorless 155 0 Jan 21, 2:48pm
       Collapse this could get interesting........ swordwhale 132 2 Jan 21, 7:38pm
           Collapse Spin-offs and crossovers are trending... QuackingTroll 75 1 Jan 22, 1:23pm
               been there, done that.... swordwhale 54 0 Jan 22, 4:29pm
       Think PJs and crew are perfectionists....doubt if this is their final work EomundDaughter 23 0 Sat, 9:54pm

  Collapse Has Billy Connolly said anything about the "CGI" Dain? Annatar598 1364 27 Jan 20, 11:51am Jump to last post in thread (by redgiraffe)
       Collapse Er - I am LOST - what do people mean by "CGI" Dain???? Avandel 654 18 Jan 20, 5:51pm
           Collapse I was certain he was mostly real until I saw the chronicles book Annatar598 643 1 Jan 20, 6:15pm
               I'd like to read the Chronicles as per your rec :) KingTurgon 547 0 Jan 20, 6:18pm
           Collapse Its a bit old, but I had read this a while back on how Billy is doing Brethil 667 14 Jan 20, 6:17pm
               Collapse Thank you for the link, Brethill Glorfindela 508 2 Jan 20, 6:50pm
                   Most welcome Glorfindela Brethil 290 0 Jan 21, 1:53am
                   on Dain Ilmatar 212 0 Jan 21, 9:55am
               Collapse Did you watch Starling 504 1 Jan 20, 7:06pm
                   I think I have to order the DVD Brethil 288 0 Jan 21, 1:55am
             Collapse Lovely post, thank you Avandel 435 2 Jan 20, 8:19pm
                   Collapse I agree with all this Avandel Brethil 290 1 Jan 21, 2:01am
                       Thank you for posting that Avandel 250 0 Jan 21, 5:15am
               Collapse I have always liked Donry 389 1 Jan 20, 9:47pm
                   Me too Donry. Brethil 280 0 Jan 21, 2:04am
               Collapse You put that beautifully, Brethil, thanks... dormouse 342 3 Jan 20, 11:19pm
                   Collapse The only shot of Dain that actually looked real to me was... Salmacis81 351 1 Jan 21, 12:20am
                       mouth redgiraffe 63 0 Jan 22, 4:44am
                   Yes, For me too, DM! Brethil 287 0 Jan 21, 2:05am
           In the Chronicles Lindele 547 0 Jan 20, 6:53pm
       Collapse I found this from the chronicles Bishop 310 7 Jan 21, 4:44am
           Collapse I think it might be better if one didn't speculate.... dormouse 245 6 Jan 21, 8:25am
               That is sadly true. NecromancerRising 210 0 Jan 21, 10:13am
             Collapse Three Missing Voices for... These Movies Bombadil 199 3 Jan 21, 11:55am
                   Collapse In what sense are they 'missing' though? dormouse 190 2 Jan 21, 12:04pm
                       Collapse BUT, not a Single Quote from them..// Bombadil 172 1 Jan 21, 12:09pm
                           Why would there be.... dormouse 141 0 Jan 21, 12:15pm
               You must have misread my post Bishop 116 0 Jan 21, 4:30pm

  Collapse Prosthetic Bolg vs. CGI Bolg Thrain II 1038 16 Jan 20, 1:03am Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       CGI Bolg tsmith675 595 0 Jan 20, 1:19am
       CG vs prosthetic Bofur's Hat 570 0 Jan 20, 1:25am
       Collapse I loved the original prosthetics Bolg Gianna 550 1 Jan 20, 2:04am
           Im not sure... ecthelionsbeard 485 0 Jan 20, 2:47am
       Prosthetic PredatoR 420 0 Jan 20, 6:52am
       none Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 389 0 Jan 20, 7:31am
       As with Azog I think the CGI version was the correct choice... moreorless 408 0 Jan 20, 8:34am
       I love the prosthetic version lurtz2010 364 0 Jan 20, 9:05am
       Bolg CathrineB 322 0 Jan 20, 11:04am
       I think it would have to be CGI Glorfindela 323 0 Jan 20, 11:14am
       Collapse prosthetic everytime! shaundobson 295 1 Jan 20, 12:46pm
           At least you could pull his prosthetics off and make him feel rather silly! // dormouse 259 0 Jan 20, 2:01pm
       Collapse Prostethics.. Drakblod 201 3 Jan 20, 6:35pm
           Collapse Agree... Salmacis81 134 1 Jan 21, 12:17am
               yep redgiraffe 50 0 Jan 22, 4:28am
           Really though it depends what your after... moreorless 48 0 Jan 22, 8:02am

  Collapse It will never be enough: fan fic sequels/time to recast Legolas, Aragorn, Gandalf? *ducks* Avandel 1086 37 Jan 19, 7:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by burrahobbit)
       Collapse I don't see what the problem would be. Spriggan 499 2 Jan 19, 8:26pm
           Collapse Simple and elegant Avandel 388 1 Jan 19, 10:22pm
               This is what I think Glorfindela 341 0 Jan 20, 12:15am
       it would be awesome to see the badass trio: Aragorn , Legolas and Gandalf Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 455 0 Jan 19, 9:08pm
       DO WE MAKE A LIST? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 442 0 Jan 19, 9:23pm
       yes please Ilmatar 418 0 Jan 19, 9:35pm
       Think I'd be fine with it Eruvandi 376 0 Jan 19, 10:29pm
       Collapse Nah it will never happen burrahobbit 382 16 Jan 19, 11:57pm
           Collapse I disagree Glorfindela 349 2 Jan 20, 12:06am
               Collapse Well they appointed GDT to direct the films burrahobbit 158 1 Jan 20, 8:12pm
                   Not true! Otaku-sempai 135 0 Jan 20, 9:44pm
         Collapse Whoa - IMO this is a bit strong Avandel 339 3 Jan 20, 12:49am
               Collapse ... burrahobbit 153 2 Jan 20, 8:45pm
                   Collapse some good points IMO! Avandel 74 1 Jan 21, 5:41pm
                       Thanks burrahobbit 44 0 Jan 21, 10:50pm
           Collapse Peter Jackson isn't 'bored out of his mind with Middle Earth'... dormouse 254 7 Jan 20, 9:02am
               Perhaps its just me seelng things that arent there BUT... moreorless 235 0 Jan 20, 9:52am
               Collapse Cinema does have an influence burrahobbit 162 5 Jan 20, 9:12pm
                   Collapse Yes and no. Spriggan 128 4 Jan 20, 9:54pm
                       Collapse The concern was with burrahobbit 126 3 Jan 20, 10:16pm
                           I think you're under estimating the audience Elarie 102 0 Jan 20, 11:35pm
                           I'm not sure why we should be concerned about that. Spriggan 100 0 Jan 20, 11:45pm
                           But if those people have never and will never read the book.... dormouse 111 0 Jan 20, 11:49pm
           Just to be clear here. NecromancerRising 212 0 Jan 20, 10:55am
       Just want to remind everyone that del Toro toyed with the idea of a bridge movie... AshNazg 358 0 Jan 20, 12:01am
       I'm actually quite glad Bumblingidiot 312 0 Jan 20, 1:19am
       Collapse Recasting Aragorn would certainly bother me Gianna 319 2 Jan 20, 1:57am
           And IMO that is a huge compliment to the actors' work Avandel 290 0 Jan 20, 3:28am
           I agree with you on those points. // mae govannen 173 0 Jan 20, 12:24pm
       Collapse fan fic sequels are fine. FrogmortonJustice65 278 1 Jan 20, 3:45am
           but the desire for sequels is love, not greed! Avandel 168 0 Jan 20, 5:43pm
       (blunders into wild uproar, checks to see if helmet strap is tightened...) swordwhale 273 0 Jan 20, 5:07am
       Collapse It all depends on the quality Elarie 174 2 Jan 20, 1:18pm
           Collapse Exactly IMO - and a quality sequel or rebbot is possible! Avandel 128 1 Jan 20, 5:18pm
               The first Star Trek reboot Loresilme 102 0 Jan 20, 11:01pm
       Collapse Why does people seemingly think, painjoiker 190 1 Jan 20, 1:20pm
           Perhaps it's because he says now that if another film happens.... dormouse 166 0 Jan 20, 2:00pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 951 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.