Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 4 of 928 (331996 posts in 13906 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 928 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Is DOS the best of the three? demnation 780 28 Tue, 5:03am Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       Collapse DOS was the best out of the three, PJ said that last year when DOS came out MouthofSauron 409 7 Tue, 5:07am
           Collapse It's interesting the PJ thinks so demnation 396 3 Tue, 5:09am
               Collapse ACTUALLY ... MouthofSauron 401 1 Tue, 5:11am
                   He does seem to change his mind quite a bit demnation 380 0 Tue, 5:14am
               Funnily enough Glorfindela 188 0 Tue, 10:48am
           Collapse No he didn't Faramir5 340 1 Tue, 5:42am
               The source was Ian McKellen. Silverlode 320 0 Tue, 6:08am
           PJ says every new film is his favourite... elvish.mafia 18 0 Wed, 11:16am
       Collapse Of the Theatricals - Not in my opinion. Aragorn the Elfstone 396 3 Tue, 5:08am
           Collapse yes, the DOS EE breathes life into the rushed DOS TE MouthofSauron 378 2 Tue, 5:09am
               Collapse The DOS EE is my favorite so far Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 233 1 Tue, 9:27am
                   the AUJ TE ... MouthofSauron 217 0 Tue, 9:45am
       Far from it dubulous 338 0 Tue, 6:14am
       I think BOT5A is the most consistant, the other two were better for one half. moreorless 290 0 Tue, 7:25am
       DoS should have been the best... tsmith675 296 0 Tue, 7:27am
       I agree JTurner82 263 0 Tue, 7:54am
       Not in my opinion Angharad73 272 0 Tue, 7:57am
       Collapse On the subject of each film's quality... Aragorn the Elfstone 287 2 Tue, 8:03am
           Collapse Completely MEIGWIT 131 1 Tue, 1:09pm
             One director has done it before KingTurgon 60 0 Tue, 4:41pm
       I think BOFA is the most well rounded, but not necessarilly the best jtarkey 221 0 Tue, 9:42am
       Collapse I think DOS is the best. Spriggan 205 1 Tue, 9:48am
         Bom does NOT think it is Anywhere? Near the Time to pronounce Bombadil 185 0 Tue, 10:29am
       No – DoS is definitely not the best of the three, for me Glorfindela 199 0 Tue, 10:47am
       I am not sure. NecromancerRising 169 0 Tue, 11:04am
       I don't care about critics Ham_Sammy 109 0 Tue, 2:55pm
       Re: Is TDoS the best of the three? DigificWriter 55 0 Tue, 5:11pm
       they are all good in their own way, but Bot5A is my favorite mirkwoodwanderer 15 0 Wed, 4:28pm

  Collapse Missed opportunity …. MouthofSauron 624 8 Tue, 3:33am Jump to last post in thread (by swordwhale)
       Collapse You have a point there Ham_Sammy 290 3 Tue, 3:35am
           Collapse Perhaps they are not dead Glorfindela 213 2 Tue, 4:52am
               The boar definitely died, you can see it put its head down and close its eyes MouthofSauron 208 0 Tue, 4:59am
               perhaps Ham_Sammy 161 0 Tue, 6:57am
       Collapse LOL!!! lionoferebor 246 3 Tue, 4:10am
           Collapse We never see Daisy after the tunnels, do we? Silverlode 226 2 Tue, 4:28am
               I think Beorn killed Daisy in DoS... QuackingTroll 126 0 Tue, 10:34am
               so much for... swordwhale 29 0 Wed, 2:59am

Collapse BOT5A Bolg Observations/Nitpicks... NateGate 441 4 Tue, 2:41am Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Congratulations... ecthelionsbeard 227 0 Tue, 3:04am
       Love this post! lol! elentari3018 162 0 Tue, 4:03am
       well deskp 148 0 Tue, 4:44am
       Re: Tauriel... arithmancer 13 0 Wed, 8:17pm

Collapse Was Dain CGI or Motion Capture? delius82 745 26 Tue, 2:35am Jump to last post in thread (by DigificWriter)
       IMO He looked fine on the battlefield with Thorin... Aragorn the Elfstone 422 0 Tue, 2:39am
       I was actually surprised... Misty Mountain Hop 411 0 Tue, 2:50am
       Collapse He looked perfectly fine to me. Scorchster 382 1 Tue, 2:52am
           I agree – I thought he looked perfectly fine Glorfindela 273 0 Tue, 4:50am
       LMAO. Really?? MouthofSauron 363 0 Tue, 3:27am
       I couldn't tell Ham_Sammy 325 0 Tue, 3:39am
       Something I noticed upon the 2nd viewing tarasaurus 359 0 Tue, 3:47am
       Collapse Dain was CGI/Motion Capture in every shot besides one... jtarkey 361 14 Tue, 4:39am
           Collapse but why?? MouthofSauron 316 13 Tue, 4:41am
               Its not. jtarkey 310 0 Tue, 4:46am
               Collapse The speculation is Silverlode 322 11 Tue, 4:48am
                   its telling that they spent time on it to make it look convincing, and even cause speculation jtarkey 288 0 Tue, 4:52am
                   Collapse Not health related... Aragorn the Elfstone 299 9 Tue, 5:15am
                       Collapse Thank God jtarkey 264 5 Tue, 5:25am
                           Collapse Agreed. Aragorn the Elfstone 247 4 Tue, 5:28am
                               Collapse did you by chance notice the OTS shot where its him in costume? jtarkey 254 3 Tue, 5:33am
                                   I didn't, but... Aragorn the Elfstone 235 0 Tue, 5:37am
                                   I know which one you mean. cats16 225 0 Tue, 6:00am
                                   cg Gandy 217 0 Tue, 6:03am
                       I know this is the 'official' line, but I'm sill not entirely convinced by it... adt100 159 0 Tue, 9:56am
                       Collapse Ehhh redgiraffe 28 1 Wed, 2:48am
                           I have a feeling... DigificWriter 24 0 Wed, 3:29am
       CGI/Motion capture = same thing adt100 153 0 Tue, 9:50am
       Collapse It was cg, the movement gave it away. Scourge of the Stoors 156 1 Tue, 9:52am
           ... yet the movement will have been entirely motion captured surely... adt100 143 0 Tue, 9:58am
       Whatever he was he was... adu 114 0 Tue, 2:15pm

  Collapse Ram ranching Or where did the sheep come from? Aranarth 367 4 Tue, 1:36am Jump to last post in thread (by Aranarth)
       I would guess shadowdog 208 0 Tue, 1:39am
       In Dain's army... NateGate 209 0 Tue, 1:40am
       Collapse Will probably make more sense after the EE MechaGodzilla 202 1 Tue, 1:40am
           I hope so Aranarth 184 0 Tue, 1:52am

  Collapse Two different films? LeglessLegolas 863 5 Mon, 11:51pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse Yes, agreed Glorfindela 407 2 Tue, 12:12am
           Collapse I agree... ecthelionsbeard 315 1 Tue, 12:56am
               I think it's one of those MasterOrc 279 0 Tue, 1:47am
       I think many don't really know how to comprehend it MEIGWIT 92 0 Tue, 1:32pm
       When it comes to the net alot of predesposition exists.. moreorless 43 0 Tue, 8:18pm

  Collapse $89,131,544 priell3 739 3 Mon, 8:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Collapse Tally Glorfindela 319 1 Mon, 10:17pm
           It doesn't BlackFox 290 0 Mon, 10:36pm
       It is quite interesting how blockbusters seem to be "spilt" these days... moreorless 123 0 Tue, 5:17am

  Collapse Jackson, the man who went up against the trends he helped create? moreorless 720 6 Mon, 8:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by cartermoulton)
       BUT who'se tone is larger than life and somewhat cartoonish... patrickk 299 0 Mon, 9:10pm
       Collapse Definitely disagree Lindele 301 3 Mon, 9:10pm
           7 haarp 190 0 Mon, 11:00pm
           When I say "tamed CGI".. moreorless 83 0 Tue, 7:41am
           i think people need to focus more.... cartermoulton 70 0 Tue, 9:27am
       LOTR pushed CGI to the limits available at the time. glor 186 0 Mon, 11:15pm

  Collapse Why no Warg Riders? If they were present I missed them. Eruonen 850 42 Mon, 7:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bladerunner)
       They were fed to the worms and trolls. Brandybuckled 442 0 Mon, 7:59pm
       Collapse The complaint about the Bagend dinner scene is getting on my nerves. Azaghâl 482 1 Mon, 8:01pm
           Are you referring to critics of AUJ? Wrong thread. Eruonen 416 0 Mon, 8:02pm
       Collapse Long shot but dubulous 422 1 Mon, 8:08pm
           Well, PJ is fond of repeating other things so I think it had to do more Eruonen 380 0 Mon, 8:21pm
       I thought they were unnecessary Glorfindela 354 0 Mon, 8:35pm
       Collapse What was their key part? Spriggan 330 18 Mon, 9:05pm
           Collapse Refer to The Hobbit Eruonen 317 17 Mon, 9:14pm
               Collapse Sorry, yes I'm aware they were in the book. Spriggan 283 16 Mon, 9:40pm
                   Collapse Visual and audio impact plus ferocity. Eruonen 278 15 Mon, 9:41pm
                       Collapse In the book? Spriggan 275 14 Mon, 9:47pm
                           LOL!// arithmancer 248 0 Mon, 10:06pm
                           Collapse The thread title is "Why no warg riders" Eruonen 248 12 Mon, 10:13pm
                               Collapse Apologies. I'm not trying to be obtuse. Spriggan 234 11 Mon, 10:33pm
                                   Collapse Ok, then it is the Battle of 4 Armies.... Eruonen 207 10 Mon, 10:53pm
                                       Collapse Warg riders, or more precisely wolf riders Spriggan 193 9 Mon, 11:05pm
                                           Collapse Really? Perhaps you should tell John Rateliff... Eleniel 171 1 Mon, 11:20pm
                                               Alas I don't know him but he is incorrect, slightly. Spriggan 128 0 Tue, 12:07am
                                           Collapse This is what I said "They were a key part of the book battle." Eruonen 153 6 Mon, 11:46pm
                                               Collapse "key" arithmancer 128 5 Mon, 11:57pm
                                                   Collapse How many angels can dance on the head of a pin? Eruonen 126 2 Tue, 12:03am
                                                       Collapse Oh, OK arithmancer 118 1 Tue, 12:08am
                                                           Possibly, but orcs/goblins, coming from various places were Eruonen 97 0 Tue, 1:13am
                                                   Collapse I'm afraid it seems rude of me to persevere but Spriggan 122 1 Tue, 12:09am
                                                       The think... ecthelionsbeard 107 0 Tue, 12:40am
       Collapse Darn! Now I know what was missing from this film... Elarie 237 9 Mon, 10:46pm
           Collapse Can you imagine Beorn covered in wargs? QuackingTroll 221 1 Mon, 10:50pm
               Yes! Beorn flinging wargs around would have been impressive! Eruonen 206 0 Mon, 10:54pm
         Fingers crossed! // BlackFox 210 0 Mon, 10:52pm
           Collapse Imagine Dain on Boris meeting Azog or Bolg on Daisy Eruonen 209 5 Mon, 10:56pm
               Collapse We know what happened to Boris BlackFox 209 4 Mon, 11:04pm
                   Collapse Poor Daisy Elarie 108 3 Tue, 1:16am
                       Collapse He would probably shack up with her as he is used to living with a pig. Eruonen 100 1 Tue, 1:41am
                         Hehehe! // BlackFox 35 0 Tue, 10:26am
                     That goes straight to the top of my EE wishlist! BlackFox 39 0 Tue, 10:26am
       Collapse All I can think of reading through this thread Silverlode 92 1 Tue, 2:56am
           True, but we already have whole cgi armies of goblins, dwarves, elves. Eruonen 77 0 Tue, 3:12am
       THANK GOD MouthofSauron 82 0 Tue, 3:29am
       Collapse Second, and more serious thoughts on this... Silverlode 80 3 Tue, 4:26am
           Collapse Good points and I won't ask you the meaning of "serious" ;) Eruonen 67 1 Tue, 5:01am
               Or what the meaning of "is" is...? Silverlode 62 0 Tue, 5:32am
           yes, I would have preferred a classical interpretation of the fifth army. Bladerunner 36 0 Tue, 12:40pm

  Collapse Today's experience at the cinema Glorfindela 875 7 Mon, 7:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Almost everyone stayed through the credits in my viewing too... AshNazg 358 0 Mon, 7:40pm
       Ironfoot CathrineB 374 0 Mon, 7:42pm
       My first experience with HFR... tsmith675 282 0 Mon, 8:54pm
       Collapse 3rd viewing for me too today, 3D this time Loresilme 257 3 Mon, 9:13pm
           Collapse mhm CathrineB 206 2 Mon, 10:00pm
               Collapse Yep, exactly Loresilme 174 1 Mon, 10:35pm
                   TODAY? Bomby saw it TWICE for Free? Bombadil 132 0 Tue, 2:22am

  Collapse PJ says the industry has lost its way by focusing on franchises and technology AshNazg 1318 18 Mon, 6:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       In spite of the fact Ham_Sammy 737 0 Mon, 6:52pm
       Collapse Wow! R11 602 8 Mon, 8:12pm
           Wha? Brandybuckled 529 0 Mon, 8:20pm
           Collapse There's a difference Ataahua 508 4 Mon, 8:41pm
               that was my take as well Ataahua Ham_Sammy 439 0 Mon, 8:51pm
               Collapse Me thinks you're splitting hairs R11 213 1 Tue, 1:09am
                   ron... patrickk 185 0 Tue, 2:10am
               If he was so concerned about the oversaturation of franchises... Morthoron 160 0 Tue, 2:59am
           If you are into reading one thing Lindele 386 0 Mon, 9:23pm
           This whole thing about Franchises... patrickk 372 0 Mon, 9:31pm
       Thank you Ashnazg - would also like to post this link Loresilme 467 0 Mon, 8:28pm
       What I sort of got from this article was... Misty Mountain Hop 422 0 Mon, 9:14pm
       Collapse PJ doesn't hate franchises, he just says there are too many QuackingTroll 329 3 Mon, 10:43pm
           Ding ding ding ding ding Ham_Sammy 291 0 Mon, 11:10pm
           Collapse The studios or, the audiences ? glor 271 1 Mon, 11:27pm
               I think its "the industry"... moreorless 89 0 Tue, 9:02am
       Look, PJ seems like a cool guy demnation 143 0 Tue, 5:06am
       Define "franchise" Silverlode 118 0 Tue, 6:37am

  Collapse The Butchering of Howard Shore Gandy 1165 21 Mon, 6:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by Aragorn the Elfstone)
       Collapse I find it hard to believe Lindele 606 1 Mon, 6:47pm
           Again... smtfhw 458 0 Mon, 7:02pm
       Collapse Poor Howard. Did they find enough body parts for a burial? Spriggan 519 2 Mon, 6:48pm
           LOL! Ham_Sammy 454 0 Mon, 6:53pm
         *mods up* // BlackFox 409 0 Mon, 7:12pm
       About the score [STARS}TyranT 475 0 Mon, 6:58pm
       Sorry you feel that way Glorfindela 436 0 Mon, 7:06pm
       After the first few moments... priell3 433 0 Mon, 7:10pm
       There are some great documentaries that explain the power of quiet, minimalist soundtracks QuackingTroll 426 0 Mon, 7:10pm
       Kind of agree CathrineB 375 0 Mon, 7:45pm
       Collapse The score is now the musical expression of a story over 6 movies, not 3 Loresilme 401 2 Mon, 8:02pm
           Perfect Lindele 342 0 Mon, 8:19pm
           Excellently put! BlackFox 303 0 Mon, 9:03pm
       Collapse I agree Dipling 337 1 Mon, 8:29pm
           I definitely noticed that the music was hard to hear too hobbitylass 270 0 Mon, 9:48pm
       Collapse hyperbole nymmerod 276 2 Mon, 10:03pm
           I agree with this Glorfindela 246 0 Mon, 10:22pm
           This. So much. Aragorn the Elfstone 95 0 Tue, 7:46am
       Collapse Mostly agree with your points Skaan 221 1 Mon, 11:24pm
           Yes... Dipling 95 0 Tue, 7:31am
       Great post-- elentari3018 129 0 Tue, 4:14am

  Collapse It's 2.5 days later and I still can't decide how I feel about this movie KingTurgon 1025 27 Mon, 6:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Lurker in the Mirk)
       Collapse In some ways yes, that is why I hope the EE evens out some scenes. Eruonen 526 1 Mon, 6:19pm
           Just watched the RA/LP Apple interview Avandel 255 0 Mon, 11:21pm
       Collapse It is unfortunate Lindele 523 5 Mon, 6:28pm
           Collapse I think Alfrid provided some important light comic break from Eruonen 391 4 Mon, 7:19pm
               Collapse That was a role that would have been better left to the "other" dwarves. n/m Brandybuckled 368 1 Mon, 7:24pm
                   But, he was tied in to the Laketown governance and the Master so Eruonen 361 0 Mon, 7:27pm
               About Alfrid Kilidoescartwheels 366 0 Mon, 7:34pm
               I liked the way he didnt come to a sticky end... moreorless 317 0 Mon, 8:18pm
       I get it... Brandybuckled 464 0 Mon, 6:34pm
       Collapse What I Found Interesting smtfhw 492 6 Mon, 6:35pm
           Collapse I often think Lindele 445 5 Mon, 6:38pm
               Yep... smtfhw 413 0 Mon, 6:41pm
               Collapse Really? I tend to manage. Spriggan 420 1 Mon, 6:46pm
                   Well it depends on the film Lindele 401 0 Mon, 6:54pm
               Collapse Perhaps moreso with fans... moreorless 307 1 Mon, 8:22pm
                   Very true Ham_Sammy 291 0 Mon, 8:31pm
       I can see why Belegdir 391 0 Mon, 7:11pm
       Collapse I agree with the OP priell3 377 2 Mon, 7:28pm
           Collapse Totally immersed in.. patrickk 284 1 Mon, 9:36pm
               Agree, I have no issue with turning this into 3 movies by Eruonen 225 0 Mon, 11:09pm
       Collapse Very much so Avandel 267 3 Mon, 10:40pm
           Collapse Avandel the... patrickk 164 1 Tue, 2:17am
               Thank you Avandel 142 0 Tue, 2:59am
           It seems Dipling 54 0 Tue, 7:34am
       The good stuff they did really well elentari3018 133 0 Tue, 4:28am
       All I can say is lionoferebor 86 0 Tue, 4:41am
       I think I can understand your feelings. Lurker in the Mirk 55 0 Tue, 9:09am

  Collapse Your favourite 'Hobbit Rumour' from the last few years BornOutOfTheWest 927 25 Mon, 5:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruvandi)
       Collapse zombie Smaug brought back from the dead by the necromancer fighting in the battle LoremIpsum 469 1 Mon, 5:54pm
           And when he dies he explodes into a fireball and becomes the Eye // AshNazg 410 0 Mon, 6:07pm
       Collapse Galadriel/Gandalf romance Ataahua 470 3 Mon, 5:57pm
           But Gandalf's dialogue in BotFA still vaguely suggests this // AshNazg 430 0 Mon, 6:08pm
           LOL! // Loresilme 245 0 Mon, 9:18pm
         ROTFL.. re. Celeborn's quote!!! mae govannen 55 0 Tue, 12:46pm
       Whilst... DjU 463 0 Mon, 5:58pm
       A couple Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 445 0 Mon, 6:04pm
       Collapse Necromancer subplot Danielos 462 3 Mon, 6:05pm
           Collapse The Necromancer stuff was an area that PJ could really have expanded and made his own AshNazg 426 2 Mon, 6:15pm
               Collapse The funny thing is... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 410 1 Mon, 6:33pm
                   Everything else was completely made up... patrickk 239 0 Mon, 9:39pm
       Collapse That one or more of the dwarves would be female Loresilme 286 6 Mon, 9:20pm
           Collapse That was really bad Ham_Sammy 268 5 Mon, 9:28pm
               Collapse A casting one glor 204 4 Mon, 11:32pm
                   Collapse I remember that one Ham_Sammy 174 3 Mon, 11:54pm
                       Collapse Ian Mcshane Mcoull 170 2 Tue, 12:21am
                           Oh absolutely Ham_Sammy 151 0 Tue, 12:23am
                           Well I think shadowdog 126 0 Tue, 1:34am
       Rumor about Thorin's death. Holly Hobbit 226 0 Mon, 11:37pm
       Sauron/Annatar and Rings flashback // xxxyyy 127 0 Tue, 1:39am
       Collapse the ones I thought were absurd/humourous Cirashala 159 1 Tue, 1:44am
           Just no... Ham_Sammy 119 0 Tue, 1:51am
       That Thorin would survive BlackFox 57 0 Tue, 12:51pm
       That Thranduil and Tauriel were lovers Eruvandi 16 0 Wed, 4:49pm

  Collapse Sting Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 375 4 Mon, 5:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse In Rivendell on the way home // AshNazg 172 1 Mon, 5:51pm
           I like that idea // Loresilme 85 0 Mon, 8:31pm
       Collapse IF this were to be in the film Lindele 156 1 Mon, 6:29pm
           As I said... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 136 0 Mon, 6:37pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 928 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.