Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 4 of 979 (351383 posts in 14685 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 979 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Rońc Smaug the iron 1102 23 May 10, 11:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       Collapse I thought it was nicely done Elarie 918 1 May 10, 1:29pm
           Is there more to see? Shagrat 905 0 May 10, 1:42pm
       Re: Rońc Otaku-sempai 903 0 May 10, 1:47pm
       Collapse Surprised CathrineB 807 1 May 10, 6:48pm
           Birds are one of very few types of animal capable of physical human sounding speech. Bumblingidiot 233 0 May 13, 11:27pm
       Loved seeing the raven... dormouse 802 0 May 10, 7:02pm
       Collapse Honestly ... DanielLB 681 16 May 11, 7:44am
           Collapse *Rolls eyes*..... dormouse 613 10 May 11, 2:47pm
               Collapse Is he? Otaku-sempai 587 3 May 11, 3:43pm
                   Collapse Greenscreening a real raven... Bofur01 577 1 May 11, 3:59pm
                       Possibly... Otaku-sempai 566 0 May 11, 4:05pm
                   I'm teasing Daniel, Otaku, just teasing.... dormouse 529 0 May 11, 6:37pm
               Collapse Picky, but true. DanielLB 463 5 May 12, 6:18am
                   Collapse New Zealand law Eruwestial37 369 4 May 13, 4:40am
                       Collapse They have rooks though, don't they? DanielLB 351 2 May 13, 6:13am
                           We have rooks Starling 341 0 May 13, 7:46am
                           Reading your post... dormouse 334 0 May 13, 8:37am
                       But? Otaku-sempai 300 0 May 13, 2:21pm
           Collapse I'm glad it was CG! AshNazg 568 1 May 11, 4:09pm
               Markings? DanielLB 463 0 May 12, 6:15am
           Collapse You should do something about that growing bitterness Starling 520 2 May 11, 7:06pm
             Collapse "The Talking Animals" Motif in Literature? Bombadil 363 1 May 13, 5:08am
                   Disagaree Otaku-sempai 305 0 May 13, 2:24pm

  Collapse Has anything "official" ever been said about Gandalf and Galadriel in the films? Radagast-Aiwendil 1069 25 May 9, 7:20pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse not that I know of! marary 1006 22 May 9, 7:51pm
           Collapse Indeed! Radagast-Aiwendil 994 21 May 9, 7:57pm
               nothing canon to imply romance! marary 981 0 May 9, 8:07pm
               Collapse though he loved the Elves Bracegirdle 930 6 May 9, 9:11pm
                   Collapse question! marary 921 4 May 9, 9:17pm
                       Collapse The FULL quote is given by Radagast-Aiwendil Bracegirdle 832 3 May 10, 2:15am
                           Collapse "Useen" as in a disembodied spirit. // Elizabeth 794 2 May 10, 4:24am
                               Gandalf disguises! marary 783 0 May 10, 5:22am
                               I wonder? Bracegirdle 687 0 May 10, 1:08pm
                   Olorin did, in fact, take the form of an elf Radagast-Aiwendil 902 0 May 9, 9:55pm
               Collapse the book still exists... but Elthir 690 12 May 10, 1:18pm
                   Collapse And so we must hope none of our readers think new thoughts? Spriggan 644 11 May 10, 3:13pm
                       Collapse Bad fan-fiction is bad fan-fiction... Morthoron 609 7 May 10, 5:13pm
                           Did you mean to reply to me? Spriggan 586 0 May 10, 6:19pm
                           Collapse I don't think for a minute they intended to imply anything of the sort in the film.... dormouse 571 5 May 10, 6:58pm
                               Collapse Well... Morthoron 567 3 May 10, 7:16pm
                                   Collapse OK, fair enough... dormouse 557 2 May 10, 7:46pm
                                       Collapse Although we are diametrically opposed in most cases.... Morthoron 501 1 May 10, 9:06pm
                                           As it happens it isn't Mother's Day here.... dormouse 166 0 May 10, 10:14pm
                               young and old Elthir 511 0 May 10, 8:44pm
                       Collapse good points... Elthir 536 2 May 10, 8:17pm
                           fanfiction marary 525 0 May 10, 8:26pm
                           Well, that is a useful clarification. Spriggan 496 0 May 10, 9:08pm
       I'm pretty sure that the filmmakers scotched that rumor. Otaku-sempai 988 0 May 9, 8:06pm
       Rumors swirled following that first teaser trailer... Aragorn the Elfstone 951 0 May 9, 8:52pm

  Collapse Potential EE Snippet from William Kircher (spoilers) Shagrat 1650 14 May 9, 11:17am Jump to last post in thread (by TheSexyBeard)
       Yeah CathrineB 1576 0 May 9, 11:51am
       Collapse Thanks! Thrain II 1561 3 May 9, 12:06pm
           Well, ultimately, it is the problem of having 13 dwarves plus the other story arc Eruonen 1344 0 May 9, 5:18pm
           Collapse I feel the same tattooed_dwarf 1263 1 May 9, 7:20pm
               well, the dwarves were evidently supposed to.... Avandel 531 0 May 11, 8:34pm
       I really hope so... AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 1448 0 May 9, 3:06pm
       Collapse I think this is a part of it. Smaug the iron 1436 2 May 9, 3:28pm
           GREAT EYE...yes Bombadil 1407 0 May 9, 3:46pm
           That would be so awesome! DisDwarfWoman 1348 0 May 9, 5:16pm
       Collapse Kircher has hinted at this since 2012: DanielLB 1195 3 May 9, 8:46pm
           Collapse Or head-butt it into the orc's head AshNazg 1182 2 May 9, 8:53pm
               Collapse Here Smaug the iron 1168 1 May 9, 9:09pm
                   Wow, nice one! AshNazg 1069 0 May 10, 12:34am
       Games-Workshop strategy game TheSexyBeard 503 0 May 11, 10:09pm

Collapse ABOUT the Ravenhill Fights..? Bombadil 885 15 May 8, 9:12pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse Oh dear.... Avandel 791 13 May 8, 10:30pm
           Collapse EXCELLENT Points! Bombadil 673 1 May 9, 8:33am
             Great point! Avandel 564 0 May 9, 5:58pm
           Collapse Aye CathrineB 666 10 May 9, 9:00am
               Bom's main reason for bringing this up is the Three Settings... Bombadil 643 0 May 9, 12:08pm
               Collapse Aidan! Avandel 556 8 May 9, 6:04pm
                   Collapse exhausting Ilmatar 549 7 May 9, 6:36pm
                     Collapse Bom is Thinking that they LEAVE Ravenhill alone.. Bombadil 499 6 May 10, 1:44am
                           well... DisDwarfWoman 428 0 May 10, 4:41pm
                           Collapse where was Dwalin Kilidoescartwheels 333 4 May 11, 2:13pm
                               Collapse But something doesn't add up... CathrineB 328 1 May 11, 2:30pm
                                   I suppose we can only surmise Dwalin is busy fignting a horde of orcs single Eruonen 316 0 May 11, 3:36pm
                               Dwalin the berserker holding off orcs coming up the hill Eruonen 293 0 May 11, 6:35pm
                             *grins* come back the the River Avandel 227 0 May 12, 3:27pm
       I agree, Hobbity Hobbit 246 0 May 12, 11:51am

  Collapse Did Azog and Bolg switch roles just to give Legolas something to do? AshNazg 892 17 May 8, 6:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by moreorless)
       Yes Dcole4 823 0 May 8, 6:38pm
       Collapse I suspect it was PJ's decision Kilidoescartwheels 801 2 May 8, 7:13pm
           Collapse I don┤t understand Smaug the iron 796 1 May 8, 7:19pm
               Well nothing Kilidoescartwheels 657 0 May 9, 1:49am
       Yes Thrain II 770 0 May 8, 7:59pm
       Collapse I'm probably forgetting something Spriggan 741 3 May 8, 9:16pm
           Collapse A single night of travel... AshNazg 725 2 May 8, 9:37pm
               Collapse I don't think I would take it in that light /night myself. Spriggan 714 1 May 8, 9:47pm
                   That is my issue though. Arannir 334 0 May 11, 8:50am
       Collapse A Single Night? Otaku-sempai 551 4 May 9, 12:24pm
           Collapse well LordGawain 546 3 May 9, 12:30pm
               Collapse I think we should ignore appearances in this sequence. Otaku-sempai 537 2 May 9, 1:08pm
                   Collapse Beorn says "Your hunters are not far behind" AshNazg 446 1 May 10, 1:45am
                       Okay. Otaku-sempai 434 0 May 10, 5:02am
       Collapse Well... it certainly comes across to me like it. Arannir 338 2 May 11, 8:44am
           I felt that many of the transitions felt very awkward in the films. Otaku-sempai 255 0 May 11, 3:50pm
           I would guess a mix... moreorless 89 0 May 15, 6:37am

  Collapse Tauriel switching costumes Legolas_Shoehorn 686 3 May 8, 2:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by AshNazg)
       That's always bugged me. Mooseboy018 593 0 May 8, 4:49pm
       I'll have to check - didn't notice! Avandel 503 0 May 8, 8:19pm
       It's strange, I never notice costume changes.... AshNazg 453 0 May 8, 10:09pm

  Collapse Top 10 scenes from the book in the film. Smaug the iron 804 7 May 7, 6:53pm Jump to last post in thread (by Spriggan)
       Collapse Hm, I love the singing Kilidoescartwheels 702 1 May 7, 7:38pm
           The funeral Smaug the iron 690 0 May 7, 7:56pm
       Collapse Hmmm... Avnar 618 1 May 7, 11:59pm
           If there wasn't 10 Spriggan 338 0 May 8, 9:33pm
       Mine lionoferebor 562 0 May 8, 3:10am
       Only ten? Here are my choices for today thenů Noria 482 0 May 8, 12:06pm
       Only 10? dormouse 449 0 May 8, 1:23pm

Collapse How about jus' for Fun..? A Moria & Erebor Debate... Bombadil 527 11 May 7, 7:45am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse We knew much about the other Races, yet? Bombadil 436 3 May 7, 1:54pm
           Collapse More Erebor? Otaku-sempai 418 2 May 7, 2:45pm
             Collapse Will we have RAVENs..? Bombadil 405 1 May 7, 3:02pm
                   Ravens would be nice. Otaku-sempai 394 0 May 7, 3:33pm
       Collapse Moria Trivia Otaku-sempai 431 6 May 7, 2:31pm
           Collapse Moria @ it's Height..? Bombadil 311 5 May 7, 10:43pm
               Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 302 1 May 7, 11:04pm
                   As a Couple of "Half-Elev-ens" on TOOkRn Bombadil 301 0 May 7, 11:32pm
               Collapse I've always wondered about that Kim 284 2 May 8, 3:04am
                   Collapse SAME Here, Kim...What a Mystery Moria is.. Bombadil 270 1 May 8, 6:35am
                       A Moria movie Otaku-sempai 232 0 May 8, 2:25pm

  Collapse New Yahoo interview: RA on The Hobbit and BotFA EE *Spoilers* dernwyn 2489 40 May 6, 8:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse Interesting reading his opinion on Tauriel. He doesn't seem too keen... AshNazg 2255 3 May 6, 10:04pm
           Collapse It's an honest view, isn't it? dormouse 2248 1 May 6, 10:10pm
               dmouse, ONCE again for the WIN!... Bombadil 2107 0 May 7, 12:28am
           Tauriel & female characters in general Kilidoescartwheels 255 0 May 11, 5:36pm
       Collapse I relate more to the male characters than the female ones... Queen of Erebor 2216 13 May 6, 10:30pm
           Collapse It's interesting that you say that. Ataahua 2190 12 May 6, 10:58pm
               Collapse There is an argument that states.. glor 2109 10 May 7, 12:32am
                   Collapse Applauds lionoferebor 2021 9 May 7, 3:36am
                       Collapse Why these characters are added in the first place... dormouse 1895 8 May 7, 7:55am
                           Funny you should say this... lionoferebor 1648 0 May 7, 2:41pm
                           Collapse In any other story, I would have loved Tauriel. RosieLass 1364 3 May 7, 9:04pm
                               Collapse This! Eowyn of Penns Woods 1243 2 May 8, 2:14am
                                   Collapse Except.... dormouse 704 1 May 8, 2:50pm
                                       This! :-) // Kim 566 0 May 9, 3:23am
                           Collapse They are there to attract a female audience, is just a Hollywood smokescreen glor 1190 2 May 8, 5:00am
                               Collapse To be fair... Aragorn the Elfstone 1166 1 May 8, 5:44am
                                   Yep! Otaku-sempai 1009 0 May 8, 2:26pm
               There's a similar effect with race... AshNazg 2083 0 May 7, 1:04am
       "Weĺre going to see... Kim 2059 0 May 7, 2:02am
       Thanks for posting that Elarie 1752 0 May 7, 12:03pm
       Collapse Hmmmmmm CathrineB 1737 2 May 7, 12:33pm
           Collapse Perhaps during the interview Richard wasn't thinking along those lines Avandel 1644 1 May 7, 2:53pm
               Tauriel lines Mooseboy018 1526 0 May 7, 5:23pm
       Collapse Waiting for the Extended Cut and thoughts on Tauriel... Aragorn the Elfstone 1448 14 May 7, 7:08pm
           Collapse The problem with Tauriel... Dcole4 1275 13 May 8, 1:10am
               No, THAT is the misconception... Aragorn the Elfstone 1263 0 May 8, 1:35am
               Collapse And... Avandel 608 11 May 8, 10:02pm
                   Collapse On the question of Legolas, two points... dormouse 545 10 May 9, 8:43am
                       Collapse All excellent points Milieuterrien 525 7 May 9, 10:17am
                           Collapse Yes, I think it is Thranduil who first realises... dormouse 500 6 May 9, 1:13pm
                               Thranduil's deductions Milieuterrien 438 0 May 9, 3:29pm
                               Collapse Thranduil's motive is a bit murky here. Otaku-sempai 384 4 May 9, 8:11pm
                                   Collapse not sure marary 365 3 May 9, 9:13pm
                                       Secretive Thranduil Otaku-sempai 359 0 May 9, 9:23pm
                                       Collapse Well.... Avandel 232 1 May 11, 8:07pm
                                           Oh yes.... dormouse 203 0 May 11, 11:07pm
                       seconding every point in this post! marary 462 0 May 9, 2:32pm
                       As always, beautiful writing Dormouse *smiles* Avandel 402 0 May 9, 7:27pm
       Tauriel is Cannon in the big budget smash hit movie trilogy version of The Hobbit squiggle 1265 0 May 8, 1:23am
       Thanks for this! Thrain II 633 0 May 8, 8:11pm

  Collapse The chances of seeing Beorns torture scene NoelGallagher 941 9 May 6, 5:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by MouthofSauron)
       Collapse YES! Dcole4 862 6 May 6, 6:17pm
           Collapse But NoelGallagher 844 5 May 6, 6:25pm
               Collapse Sorry Dcole4 838 4 May 6, 6:28pm
                   Collapse I think the actual quote in the WETA book... Bofur01 831 3 May 6, 6:34pm
                       Collapse I don't know Dcole4 830 2 May 6, 6:36pm
                         ARAGORN: "There is always, HOPE.."// Bombadil 797 0 May 6, 7:11pm
                           And Gandalf and Radagast's spells... Bofur01 611 0 May 7, 6:46am
       Collapse PJ and PB confirmed more Beorn in the EE... Silmaril 547 1 May 7, 12:38pm
           there really is no beorn "pay off" in the TE version, such a shame MouthofSauron 289 0 May 10, 4:05am

  Collapse Would Thranduil have jumped in and saved Thorin from Azog? boldog 540 5 May 6, 10:51am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Um...yes? Otaku-sempai 460 0 May 6, 1:18pm
       Collapse Absolutely IMO Avandel 431 1 May 6, 3:00pm
           Yeah, but would Thorin have appreciated it? Kilidoescartwheels 405 0 May 6, 4:38pm
       Collapse Thranduil would help Thorin, of course ... dormouse 362 1 May 6, 7:01pm
           True, that Kilidoescartwheels 324 0 May 6, 8:35pm

  Collapse Thread Locked Martin Freeman Joins Captain America: Civil War Orc13 436 1 May 6, 3:31am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Thread Locked Redundant is redundant. Otaku-sempai 365 0 May 6, 3:43am

  Collapse GDT still has not seen "The Hobbit" Trilogy Silmaril 1215 8 May 5, 2:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by painjoiker)
       I honestly think his Hobbit would have been wildly different sycorax82 1004 0 May 5, 6:03pm
       I can understand that... dormouse 830 0 May 5, 10:28pm
       Collapse probably because he is pretty pissed he wasn't able to direct MouthofSauron 292 5 May 10, 4:09am
         Collapse A Question? Since he got a Screen Credit.. Bombadil 269 4 May 10, 8:48am
               Collapse Residuals Otaku-sempai 246 1 May 10, 1:50pm
                   Oops! Otaku-sempai 232 0 May 10, 2:39pm
               Collapse Does he earn royalties for all and any of his contributions, or only... Milieuterrien 237 1 May 10, 2:28pm
                   He is either payed a fixed amount before the movies are done, painjoiker 115 0 May 12, 9:02pm

  Collapse How would the story have shaped out if Azog was replaced by Bolg? boldog 874 25 May 5, 9:25am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Dain could have killed Azog... QuackingTroll 724 0 May 5, 12:50pm
       Collapse They would have had to invent another orc... dormouse 713 6 May 5, 1:22pm
           goblin army tattooed_dwarf 595 0 May 5, 5:40pm
           Collapse Well, the second orc army wasn't necessary and didn't make a great deal of sense AshNazg 496 4 May 5, 8:27pm
               Collapse Well, I suppose the two orc armies.... dormouse 445 1 May 5, 10:22pm
                   Agree... lionoferebor 307 0 May 6, 1:31pm
               Collapse I agree... lionoferebor 318 1 May 6, 1:09pm
                   The Orcs of Tattooine Otaku-sempai 312 0 May 6, 1:22pm
       It's got its pluses and minuses Kilidoescartwheels 690 0 May 5, 1:56pm
       If Azog had died at Azanulbizar Otaku-sempai 672 0 May 5, 2:31pm
       Collapse I would reply more fully but I am weeping Spriggan 621 14 May 5, 5:21pm
           Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 596 13 May 5, 5:49pm
               Collapse Well Bolg is a name in the book. Spriggan 573 12 May 5, 6:26pm
                   Collapse Azog/Bolg Otaku-sempai 559 11 May 5, 6:49pm
                       Collapse I think we may be at cross purposes. Spriggan 545 10 May 5, 7:10pm
                           Collapse You may be right. Otaku-sempai 516 1 May 5, 8:07pm
                               I don't think I was hoping for anything. Spriggan 488 0 May 5, 8:40pm
                           Collapse Yes and no... AshNazg 477 1 May 5, 8:59pm
                               I tend to think the former probably drives the latter. Spriggan 470 0 May 5, 9:19pm
                           Collapse Well that's exactly how I felt about it... Salmacis81 446 5 May 5, 10:43pm
                               Collapse Jolly good - it's nice to have the confirmation Spriggan 437 4 May 5, 11:01pm
                                   Collapse Sure, you could call it that... Salmacis81 431 3 May 5, 11:23pm
                                       I'm not sure I've ever said that, which would seem a slight difference. Spriggan 424 0 May 5, 11:33pm
                                       Collapse I think we all have different opinions... AshNazg 422 1 May 5, 11:45pm
                                           Thank you for saying that Kilidoescartwheels 127 0 May 6, 4:54pm

  Collapse Odd clips in DVD Bumblingidiot 1325 11 May 3, 6:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       probably Faleel 1230 0 May 3, 7:07pm
       Fellowship of the Ring received a new color grade on the Extended Edition Blu-ray... Aragorn the Elfstone 1194 0 May 3, 7:59pm
       Collapse Dark clips are from the EE Blu-ray QuackingTroll 1092 6 May 3, 10:49pm
           possible updated/fixed grade Mooseboy018 1026 0 May 4, 2:05am
           Collapse My avatar pic is from the EE Blu-ray... QuackingTroll 1020 1 May 4, 2:21am
               flesh tones Mooseboy018 1001 0 May 4, 3:10am
           Collapse I knew about the issue, Bumblingidiot 452 2 May 5, 7:31pm
               Collapse The green tinted sky is in AUJ too... Bofur01 428 1 May 5, 8:35pm
                   The tint in AUJ isn't so bad, for some reason. Bumblingidiot 239 0 May 7, 10:59pm
       Collapse Who knows what they were thinking with the green tint... sycorax82 802 1 May 4, 3:14pm
           Re-grading and changing the original trilogy... AshNazg 628 0 May 4, 11:32pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 979 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.