Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 4 of 967 (347777 posts in 14496 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 967 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Kili and Tauriel: An 'almost-love-story' Otaku-sempai 2604 147 Mar 15, 3:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by Milieuterrien)
       Collapse Yes.... dormouse 2251 33 Mar 15, 4:34pm
           Collapse In theory, I agree Voronwë_the_Faithful 2227 32 Mar 15, 4:57pm
               Collapse But it was real... marary 2222 1 Mar 15, 5:03pm
                   Bom Votes Yes! to Bombadil 2188 0 Mar 15, 5:32pm
               Collapse Well yes..... dormouse 1964 27 Mar 16, 12:02am
                   Collapse I'm not so different Voronwë_the_Faithful 1945 26 Mar 16, 12:26am
                       Collapse Yes, and I was thinking last night.... dormouse 772 25 Mar 16, 8:54am
                           Collapse I agree, but there's also more to it for me. Silverlode 738 23 Mar 16, 10:45am
                               Collapse Yes, that's a very good point.... dormouse 704 20 Mar 16, 12:22pm
                                   Collapse ages of ME races marary 694 2 Mar 16, 12:35pm
                                       Very puzzling dormouse 693 0 Mar 16, 12:38pm
                                       Tauriel isn't really all that young. Otaku-sempai 641 0 Mar 16, 3:09pm
                                   Collapse I definitely agree that there is a refection of the Athrabeth Voronwë_the_Faithful 673 16 Mar 16, 2:10pm
                                       Collapse Yes, so do I.... dormouse 663 15 Mar 16, 2:29pm
                                           Collapse Indeed! Voronwë_the_Faithful 619 14 Mar 16, 3:42pm
                                               Pray Tell Michelle Johnston 602 0 Mar 16, 4:24pm
                                               Collapse Appendix 10 Voronwë_the_Faithful 594 12 Mar 16, 4:54pm
                                                   Collapse Many Thanks Michelle Johnston 415 11 Mar 17, 6:16pm
                                                       Collapse My pleasure Voronwë_the_Faithful 409 10 Mar 17, 6:33pm
                                                           Collapse I hope you don't mind if I adopt this term for myself as well BlackFox 371 7 Mar 17, 7:25pm
                                                               Collapse Please do! Voronwë_the_Faithful 363 1 Mar 17, 7:27pm
                                                                   Like me - I'm one... // dormouse 610 0 Mar 17, 7:43pm
                                                               Collapse It transcends its flaws... Milieuterrien 365 4 Mar 17, 7:28pm
                                                                   Nicely put! // BlackFox 620 0 Mar 17, 7:36pm
                                                                   Nice! // dormouse 608 0 Mar 17, 7:44pm
                                                                   Collapse *slow clap* marary 600 1 Mar 17, 8:07pm
                                                                       Yikes, it's absolutely the good Pace for applause Milieuterrien 578 0 Mar 17, 9:04pm
                                                           Collapse I am a great Shippey fan Michelle Johnston 601 1 Mar 17, 8:20pm
                                                               I figured you were a fan of Shippey's Voronwë_the_Faithful 558 0 Mar 17, 10:37pm
                               Well said, indeed Voronwë_the_Faithful 672 0 Mar 16, 2:07pm
                               Beautifully Put Michelle Johnston 618 0 Mar 16, 3:39pm
                           Tauriel was a more relatable elf marary 707 0 Mar 16, 12:07pm
               Collapse Agreed. Arannir 725 1 Mar 16, 10:50am
                   Tauriel had to re-connect with Thranduil Milieuterrien 687 0 Mar 16, 12:40pm
       Collapse now that's very interesting! Kili/Tauriel more interesting than love at first sight marary 2224 39 Mar 15, 4:57pm
           Collapse When Tauriel is hurt... Otaku-sempai 2164 38 Mar 15, 6:09pm
               Collapse The effect on Kili Michelle Johnston 781 37 Mar 16, 8:05am
                   Collapse Kili (and Fili) Otaku-sempai 642 36 Mar 16, 3:00pm
                       Collapse One can hope- Durin family moments are the best marary 641 35 Mar 16, 3:08pm
                           Collapse 'Agreed Otaku-sempai 631 1 Mar 16, 3:13pm
                               maybe marary 620 0 Mar 16, 3:28pm
                           Collapse Er - Tauriel characteristics Avandel 602 32 Mar 16, 4:51pm
                               Collapse Eh marary 586 30 Mar 16, 5:12pm
                                   Agree Starling 580 0 Mar 16, 5:17pm
                                   Collapse So fine and specific statement ! Milieuterrien 569 22 Mar 16, 5:32pm
                                       Collapse Everyone has a bit of "Sue" in them marary 554 21 Mar 16, 5:51pm
                                           Be careful Starling 538 0 Mar 16, 6:01pm
                                           Collapse but alas Cirashala 527 19 Mar 16, 6:22pm
                                               Collapse Wow! Impressive analysis marary 481 3 Mar 16, 7:46pm
                                                   Collapse Thorin Cirashala 607 2 Mar 17, 3:36am
                                                       Where was Dwalin? Combing his beard?? marary 570 0 Mar 17, 7:43am
                                                       Agree with your points Avandel 425 0 Mar 17, 5:38pm
                                               Maybe a Mary-Sue but... Milieuterrien 475 0 Mar 16, 8:12pm
                                               Collapse And about Tauriel disturbing the canon plot, Milieuterrien 471 12 Mar 16, 8:38pm
                                                   Collapse Disturb or Distract and Whats Canon Michelle Johnston 421 11 Mar 16, 10:10pm
                                                       Collapse Following the book-canon would have been a mess. Milieuterrien 394 10 Mar 16, 11:26pm
                                                           Collapse The Battle of Five Armies. Otaku-sempai 387 4 Mar 16, 11:59pm
                                                               Collapse More a mess in the book than in the movie Milieuterrien 628 3 Mar 17, 1:01am
                                                                   Collapse It isn't as bad as you think. Otaku-sempai 596 2 Mar 17, 3:39am
                                                                       Collapse Tolkien stated the battle was a mess Milieuterrien 533 1 Mar 17, 10:24am
                                                                           Jackson may have improved on the battle in some ways... Otaku-sempai 487 0 Mar 17, 1:47pm
                                                           Collapse Story Telling Not Battle Strategy Michelle Johnston 566 4 Mar 17, 8:01am
                                                               Collapse One thing which has been satisfactory nailed is the toxicity of greed Milieuterrien 551 3 Mar 17, 9:10am
                                                                   Yes to all of this, Milieuterrien marary 508 0 Mar 17, 12:04pm
                                                                   Collapse Ravenhill Occupants Michelle Johnston 452 1 Mar 17, 4:09pm
                                                                       Ravenhill scene Milieuterrien 430 0 Mar 17, 5:26pm
                                               Beautifully summarized IMO - agree Avandel 642 0 Mar 17, 12:34am
                                   You make an interesting point. Otaku-sempai 524 0 Mar 16, 6:20pm
                                   Well here's a thing..... dormouse 505 0 Mar 16, 6:51pm
                                   Collapse Thank you Avandel 381 3 Mar 17, 12:12am
                                       Collapse I wouldn't underestimate the importance of appealing to 11-year old girls marary 582 2 Mar 17, 7:09am
                                           Collapse *Bows* IMO you make very good points, well-spoken! (: Avandel 443 1 Mar 17, 5:14pm
                                               cheers! marary 418 0 Mar 17, 5:50pm
                               I just took the Mary Sue Litmus Test for Tauriel Cirashala 566 0 Mar 16, 5:42pm
       Collapse dosnt make sense balbo biggins 2201 1 Mar 15, 5:20pm
           He's not in love when they first meet marary 2198 0 Mar 15, 5:24pm
       Collapse Sounds good on paper but... Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 2170 1 Mar 15, 6:04pm
           The relationship always felt contrived to me... Otaku-sempai 2147 0 Mar 15, 6:22pm
       Collapse Well CathrineB 2148 6 Mar 15, 6:19pm
           Collapse Agree lionoferebor 530 5 Mar 18, 2:09am
               Collapse subject marillaraina 524 4 Mar 18, 3:42am
                   Collapse POV lionoferebor 506 1 Mar 18, 6:00am
                       PJ's POV on Kili/Tauriel lionoferebor 433 0 Mar 18, 3:43pm
                   Collapse What Kili and Tauriel represented marary 507 1 Mar 18, 6:01am
                       Out-of-love with everything else. Otaku-sempai 445 0 Mar 18, 2:22pm
       Collapse John nails it but …... Michelle Johnston 2128 8 Mar 15, 7:00pm
           Collapse On this particular point, I largely agree with you Voronwë_the_Faithful 2060 2 Mar 15, 8:40pm
               Collapse such a shame marary 2040 1 Mar 15, 8:55pm
                   Marary Nicely Put Michelle Johnston 2021 0 Mar 15, 9:24pm
           Collapse I agree that working the relationship off Legolas is the point Milieuterrien 2026 4 Mar 15, 9:20pm
               Collapse Nice Michelle Johnston 1996 3 Mar 15, 10:28pm
                   Collapse The core of this enigma is 'what was intended to be done with the 'bridge movie'" ? Milieuterrien 1893 1 Mar 16, 2:13am
                       Digression: The 'bridge movie'. Otaku-sempai 1843 0 Mar 16, 4:24am
                   the token female dilemma marary 1776 0 Mar 16, 7:13am
       Collapse I like their scenes in the woodelve Dungeons squiggle 1876 1 Mar 16, 2:36am
           The Mirkwood Dungeon scene had a lot going for it marary 788 0 Mar 16, 7:24am
     Collapse Almost love would have been nice Avandel 1781 15 Mar 16, 7:09am
         Collapse Much of this Dangling, Un-Resolved PlotLine Bombadil 788 12 Mar 16, 8:10am
               I'm getting excited for the EE! marary 768 0 Mar 16, 8:35am
               Collapse I am sorry Bomby but enough, IMO, re Tauriel and EE Avandel 604 10 Mar 16, 4:37pm
                   Collapse You should be careful about telling other people "enough" Voronwë_the_Faithful 596 5 Mar 16, 5:08pm
                       Except that the post to which Avandel replied... RosieLass 507 0 Mar 16, 7:10pm
                       Collapse Was meant generically but OK Avandel 404 3 Mar 16, 11:17pm
                           Collapse "all have, by default, a right to their perceptions and opinions" Voronwë_the_Faithful 651 2 Mar 17, 12:30am
                               Collapse ??? Avandel 648 1 Mar 17, 12:38am
                                   No Voronwë_the_Faithful 632 0 Mar 17, 1:11am
                   Collapse Thank you Cirashala 590 1 Mar 16, 5:10pm
                       You are welcome and re the image Avandel 639 0 Mar 17, 12:46am
                   Collapse Thranduils triangulation & Disappearing Dwarves Michelle Johnston 500 1 Mar 16, 7:10pm
                       The dwarves did not disappear in the movie Milieuterrien 427 0 Mar 16, 10:03pm
           Collapse Tauriel's character-arc. Otaku-sempai 654 1 Mar 16, 2:46pm
               I like that a lot! RosieLass 494 0 Mar 16, 7:16pm
       Collapse That may have been the original plan Kilidoescartwheels 369 33 Mar 19, 9:18pm
           Collapse I think he was partly thinking about Legolas Voronwë_the_Faithful 358 32 Mar 19, 9:31pm
               Collapse subject marillaraina 327 31 Mar 19, 11:58pm
                   Collapse I'm glad it works for you! Voronwë_the_Faithful 314 30 Mar 20, 3:53am
                       Collapse subject marillaraina 309 29 Mar 20, 4:30am
                           Collapse Evidence based Love v Philosophical View Point Michelle Johnston 298 28 Mar 20, 11:15am
                               Collapse The Wood-elves of Mirkwood were Teleri. Otaku-sempai 266 27 Mar 20, 1:52pm
                                   Collapse Avari or Teleri Michelle Johnston 250 24 Mar 20, 4:29pm
                                       Well... Otaku-sempai 241 0 Mar 20, 4:42pm
                                       Collapse To me the more fundamental point is one that you alluded to earlier Voronwë_the_Faithful 205 22 Mar 20, 8:37pm
                                           Collapse subject marillaraina 477 4 Mar 20, 9:08pm
                                               Collapse Personally... Darkstone 477 1 Mar 20, 9:19pm
                                                   Still Children of Eru Voronwë_the_Faithful 441 0 Mar 20, 11:09pm
                                               Collapse Accepted, but only so far Voronwë_the_Faithful 432 1 Mar 20, 11:21pm
                                                   subject marillaraina 422 0 Mar 20, 11:58pm
                                           Collapse Perfect Michelle Johnston 416 16 Mar 21, 12:20am
                                               Collapse On the other hand Voronwë_the_Faithful 409 1 Mar 21, 1:22am
                                                   Indeed :) Michelle Johnston 394 0 Mar 21, 6:55am
                                               Is it not just a one step seperation of Destiny that squiggle 347 0 Mar 21, 2:53pm
                                               Collapse subject marillaraina 328 12 Mar 21, 7:36pm
                                                   Collapse puppies marary 296 11 Mar 22, 2:51am
                                                       Collapse Roaming thoughts Milieuterrien 240 10 Mar 22, 8:52pm
                                                           Collapse Tauriel's fate marary 234 9 Mar 22, 9:08pm
                                                               His mother lionoferebor 222 0 Mar 22, 10:23pm
                                                               Collapse Kili's cheesy stance Milieuterrien 221 6 Mar 22, 10:51pm
                                                                   Collapse Kili isn't cheesy :) marillaraina 213 5 Mar 23, 12:03am
                                                                       Collapse Tauriel really needs a road trip marary 196 4 Mar 23, 5:38am
                                                                           Kili's death scene marary 165 0 Mar 23, 5:29pm
                                                                           Collapse Mirkwood is a very large forest Milieuterrien 136 2 Mar 23, 10:52pm
                                                                               Collapse cool theory! marary 127 1 Tue, 4:07am
  Seeing Galadriel and Tauriel interact Milieuterrien 90 0 Tue, 11:17pm
                                                               Why Legolas left arithmancer 208 0 Mar 23, 2:08am
                                   Inconceivable lionoferebor 238 0 Mar 20, 5:28pm
                                   subject marillaraina 211 0 Mar 20, 8:25pm
       Excellent responses all 'round! Otaku-sempai 150 0 Mar 23, 7:19pm

Moved: For Those of YOU who Loved Gwahir Bombadil - - Mar 15, 3:05pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)

  Collapse What if the dwarves and Gandalf had been lying? Cirashala 883 4 Mar 15, 4:25am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       It depends on the lie, it would seem... MyWeeLadGimli 801 0 Mar 15, 5:50am
       Collapse Perhaps if he'd thought one of his animal-friends had been harmed. Otaku-sempai 625 2 Mar 15, 3:10pm
           Collapse That seems fair Cirashala 520 1 Mar 15, 11:17pm
               They hang horse thieves, don't they? Otaku-sempai 475 0 Mar 16, 3:52am

  Collapse When we are presumed to have news of the EE, and, wich parts of the book are yet to be covered? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1383 8 Mar 14, 5:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Collapse Don't know about the 'when' (October or November 2015?) Otaku-sempai 1226 6 Mar 14, 8:31pm
           Collapse ????? He is a wizard, you know! 1143 5 Mar 14, 10:32pm
               Collapse Look at Sting in 'LotR' Otaku-sempai 1101 4 Mar 14, 11:21pm
                   Collapse Bom for one, is REally Glad there was No Funeral Bombadil 836 3 Mar 15, 12:09pm
                       Collapse I think that we really need that closure. Otaku-sempai 770 2 Mar 15, 2:47pm
                           Collapse Dain Mooseboy018 655 1 Mar 15, 9:13pm
                               I don't think so... arithmancer 568 0 Mar 16, 2:32am
       So far.... TheHutt 1104 0 Mar 14, 11:20pm

Collapse The Finest Things come in Three..? Bombadil 1062 15 Mar 14, 10:54am Jump to last post in thread (by Eleniel)
       Collapse three really bad decisions... Crunchable Birdses 942 5 Mar 14, 12:20pm
           Collapse The others, maybe... Bofur01 868 2 Mar 14, 2:49pm
               Agree about the HFR The Grey Wanderer 847 0 Mar 14, 3:16pm
               Yes, much to my surprise I found HFR beautiful too... dormouse 806 0 Mar 14, 4:48pm
           late is the key word here Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 817 0 Mar 14, 4:24pm
           I can't agree about HFR Otaku-sempai 731 0 Mar 14, 8:32pm
       3 times Bilbo must use his wits against a deadly enemy marary 707 0 Mar 14, 9:47pm
       Collapse And three formats to view the Hobbit movies in... Queen of Erebor 690 7 Mar 14, 10:23pm
         Collapse GREAT Replies, Guys! Bombadil 563 6 Mar 15, 11:56am
               Collapse Given, not loaned. Otaku-sempai 533 5 Mar 15, 3:22pm
                   Collapse Both Vilya and Narya were, at first.... Bofur01 516 1 Mar 15, 5:09pm
                       Thrice Thank you for Clearing that up// Bombadil 509 0 Mar 15, 5:35pm
                   Collapse Elrond was Noldor on his father's side... Eleniel 419 2 Mar 16, 7:45am
                       Collapse Of course, thanks! Otaku-sempai 367 1 Mar 16, 2:50pm
                           Certainly is! Eleniel 352 0 Mar 16, 5:35pm

  Collapse Best Fili pic EVER!!! Kilidoescartwheels 1506 10 Mar 13, 7:39pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       That's my favorite too CathrineB 1259 0 Mar 13, 10:44pm
       Collapse Great pic! Is it part of the film or behind the scenes or ? /// Kirly 1141 3 Mar 14, 2:43am
         Likely ONE of the Finest Thingies about Fili..? Bombadil 1032 0 Mar 14, 10:27am
           I'm not sure Kilidoescartwheels 962 0 Mar 14, 12:59pm
           It's from this Banner Poster PryftanAW 944 0 Mar 14, 1:28pm
       Collapse Fili was the dark horse to Legolas's unicorn marary 892 4 Mar 14, 4:18pm
         Collapse A Thought about the Funeral..? Bombadil 684 3 Mar 15, 12:18pm
               Collapse I'm nost sure that the curse can be lifted. Otaku-sempai 617 2 Mar 15, 3:29pm
                   Collapse O-s it would Look COOL Bombadil 570 1 Mar 15, 6:50pm
                       I don't know... Otaku-sempai 558 0 Mar 15, 7:59pm

  Collapse TBOTFA - Full Movie Transcript (better late than never) IncredibleSmaug 1751 18 Mar 12, 4:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Collapse question Kagemusha 1617 5 Mar 12, 5:21pm
           dramatic effect Lindele 1592 0 Mar 12, 5:39pm
           Collapse Does anyone know why anything in Dol Guldur? // AshNazg 1567 2 Mar 12, 5:58pm
               Collapse Magic Skaan 1570 1 Mar 12, 6:06pm
                   *snort snort* bungobaggins 1446 0 Mar 12, 8:15pm
           Very much in line with magic in the texts Spriggan 586 0 Mar 15, 11:26am
       Yay! BlackFox 1497 0 Mar 12, 7:23pm
       Filling in the gaps BlackFox 1453 0 Mar 12, 8:16pm
       Awesome! Legomir 1350 0 Mar 12, 10:42pm
       Collapse Error JamesPaganini 1064 7 Mar 13, 4:12pm
           Collapse The Witchking's voice?! NoelGallagher 958 6 Mar 13, 9:49pm
               Collapse Agreed BlackFox 938 5 Mar 13, 10:39pm
                   Collapse Sauron's lines... Timdalf 821 4 Mar 14, 12:17pm
                       Collapse Do you mean the Orkish, or the rest of the poem? // Bofur01 769 3 Mar 14, 2:48pm
                           Collapse I mean Timdalf 764 2 Mar 14, 3:21pm
                               Collapse David Salo made an Orkish language... Bofur01 744 1 Mar 14, 4:46pm
                                   And that too... Timdalf 724 0 Mar 14, 6:13pm
       Thanks & correction Ilmatar 193 0 Mar 19, 8:28pm

  Collapse What if... Erethen 1189 5 Mar 12, 4:36am Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       Very dangerous idea... Dcole4 1125 0 Mar 12, 5:02am
       Hmmmm..... dormouse 1056 0 Mar 12, 8:10am
       Hm Arannir 1039 0 Mar 12, 8:37am
       My opinion arithmancer 954 0 Mar 12, 12:21pm
       Well glor 768 0 Mar 12, 5:31pm

  Collapse Next Hobbit Chronicles Book? Silmaril 1334 13 Mar 11, 2:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Nice! Elessar 1245 0 Mar 11, 3:06pm
       Collapse Hmm... Dcole4 1172 9 Mar 11, 5:02pm
           Collapse A Chronicles book focused on GDT's designs/ideas Shagrat 1099 8 Mar 11, 6:54pm
               Or better still, make his version of the movie! sycorax82 1023 0 Mar 11, 8:55pm
               Collapse Talking of which... Eleniel 1009 6 Mar 11, 9:19pm
                   Collapse I do remember it being discussed in one of the Thranduil Appreciation Threads BlackFox 991 5 Mar 11, 9:24pm
                       Collapse Thanks... Eleniel 976 4 Mar 11, 9:32pm
                           Collapse Neither have I BlackFox 953 1 Mar 11, 9:48pm
                               Ah right... Eleniel 931 0 Mar 11, 10:11pm
                           Collapse And, yes, it's the from the DOS EE Appendices BlackFox 910 1 Mar 11, 10:40pm
                               Thanks, BF! // Eleniel 774 0 Mar 12, 7:12am
       Collapse More importantly... Timdalf 428 1 Mar 15, 8:36am
           FAR-OUT IDEA!// Bombadil 356 0 Mar 15, 3:22pm

  Collapse How does BOFA opening compare to other Middle Earth openings Bofur's Hat 1397 19 Mar 9, 10:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by AshNazg)
       For me, I think Foundations of Stone Brethil 1293 0 Mar 9, 11:08pm
       It definitely the best opening of the Hobbit films, IMO. tsmith675 1284 0 Mar 9, 11:22pm
       For me I think.... dormouse 1267 0 Mar 9, 11:42pm
       My list Arannir 1133 0 Mar 10, 8:30am
       Hm, tough call Kilidoescartwheels 1055 0 Mar 10, 1:28pm
       It's at the end Elessar 1023 0 Mar 10, 2:25pm
       I don't like the BoFA opening AshNazg 1019 0 Mar 10, 2:33pm
       Collapse I love it Skaan 985 1 Mar 10, 4:03pm
           I think it is perfect as an opening to this film Voronwë_the_Faithful 964 0 Mar 10, 4:35pm
       In a league all its own... banaili 697 0 Mar 11, 10:41pm
       Collapse openings and prologues balbo biggins 665 8 Mar 12, 2:11am
           Collapse All the prologues use footage from the previous films... AshNazg 653 7 Mar 12, 4:33am
               Collapse Completely agree. Arannir 629 3 Mar 12, 8:41am
                   Collapse I quite liked the idea of a White Council prologue... AshNazg 583 2 Mar 12, 12:54pm
                       Collapse The perfect tie in. Michelle Johnston 556 1 Mar 12, 2:57pm
                           What if Gandalf's vision and Pippin's vision are the same?! AshNazg 545 0 Mar 12, 3:20pm
               Collapse My sympathies lie with Sir Peter on this. Michelle Johnston 623 2 Mar 12, 9:41am
                   Collapse Yeah... Arannir 610 1 Mar 12, 10:01am
                       It's not a climax though Elessar 581 0 Mar 12, 12:48pm

Collapse some final thoughts after seeing the third film architecthis 2488 59 Mar 9, 4:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Collapse re: Goldeneye 2159 14 Mar 9, 6:14pm
           Collapse pretty much agree with you on all your points architecthis 2134 13 Mar 9, 6:29pm
               Collapse ugh. Goldeneye 2112 10 Mar 9, 6:45pm
                   YUP architecthis 2096 0 Mar 9, 6:51pm
                   Collapse Peter Jackson has spoken several times..... dormouse 2094 8 Mar 9, 7:06pm
                       Collapse to dormouse Goldeneye 2059 6 Mar 9, 7:26pm
                           Collapse because this is ALL about ART: URGENCY FOR DELIVERING A MESSAGE (or say something) AND TRANSCENDENCE OF THAT MESSAGE Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1868 5 Mar 9, 10:34pm
                               Collapse The scriptwriters forgot the message, or corrupted it like elves into orcs... Brandybuckled 1855 4 Mar 9, 10:52pm
                                   I think they used home to resume all that but I get your point yeah Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1830 0 Mar 9, 11:11pm
                                   home Mooseboy018 1736 0 Mar 10, 2:31am
                                   WHERE did you get Nationalism from that??? Kilidoescartwheels 1717 0 Mar 10, 3:02am
                                   'Home' meaning where you live - where you belong.... dormouse 1640 0 Mar 10, 8:50am
                       Huh... sauget.diblosio 41 0 Tue, 11:08pm
               Collapse 2nd team of writers? Kilidoescartwheels 2097 1 Mar 9, 6:56pm
                   Was Damon Lindelof sighted in New Zealand at any time? Brandybuckled 2042 0 Mar 9, 7:25pm
       Thanks for this.... dormouse 2083 0 Mar 9, 7:10pm
       Everyone has their likes and dislikes Kilidoescartwheels 2026 0 Mar 9, 7:51pm
       agree balbo biggins 1941 0 Mar 9, 8:59pm
       Collapse "Over produced" Bishop 1701 38 Mar 10, 4:21am
           Collapse well put Goldeneye 1546 9 Mar 10, 12:50pm
               Collapse Or perhaps they DID need to be CGI because the live action character.... dormouse 1508 8 Mar 10, 2:08pm
                   I agree with you to an extent architecthis 1464 0 Mar 10, 2:48pm
                   Collapse to dormouse Goldeneye 1391 5 Mar 10, 5:13pm
                       Collapse Aren't they a little different though? Elessar 759 2 Mar 10, 5:17pm
                           Collapse No one ever confirmed health issues Bishop 733 1 Mar 10, 5:47pm
                               It hasn't been denied either Elessar 720 0 Mar 10, 6:04pm
                       One other thing Elessar 735 0 Mar 10, 5:40pm
                       Completley Agree Bofur's Hat 563 0 Mar 11, 1:20am
                   the Rohirrim Kilidoescartwheels 707 0 Mar 10, 6:50pm
           Overproduced architecthis 1470 0 Mar 10, 2:44pm
           Collapse Did he really say that about CGI Nazgul? burrahobbit 723 26 Mar 10, 6:35pm
               Collapse He did Bishop 689 25 Mar 10, 7:27pm
                   Collapse Prequel Sickness Goldeneye 656 7 Mar 10, 8:49pm
                       Collapse It is difficult to not draw comparisons to Lucas Bishop 611 6 Mar 10, 11:08pm
                           Collapse I've heard the compairisons Elessar 466 5 Mar 11, 1:18pm
                               Collapse The comparison is dead on Bishop 450 4 Mar 11, 1:37pm
                                   Agreed. Arannir 444 0 Mar 11, 1:47pm
                                   Collapse It's dead on if Elessar 446 2 Mar 11, 1:48pm
                                       Collapse I think there's more to it than that burrahobbit 658 1 Mar 11, 5:40pm
                                           Of course there is probably a bit more Elessar 632 0 Mar 11, 6:52pm
                   Collapse It doesn't take place on a 100% CGI landscape.... dormouse 609 13 Mar 10, 11:21pm
                       Collapse Sorry, to clarify Bishop 603 12 Mar 10, 11:24pm
                           Collapse Well, that's a very long way.... dormouse 528 11 Mar 11, 8:17am
                               Collapse Once again I agree with dormouse Noria 491 10 Mar 11, 12:05pm
                                   Collapse I don't believe for a second... Arannir 480 6 Mar 11, 1:11pm
                                       Collapse Who said you could't? Elessar 452 4 Mar 11, 1:46pm
                                           Collapse I didn't say that someone said that. Arannir 443 3 Mar 11, 1:49pm
                                               Collapse That's not how that last part reads though. Elessar 441 2 Mar 11, 1:58pm
                                                   Collapse I am sorry if I didn't express myself clear enough. Arannir 694 1 Mar 11, 2:54pm
                                                       Fair enough Elessar 694 0 Mar 11, 3:07pm
                                       Thats it Arannir Michelle Johnston 502 0 Mar 13, 10:26am
                                   re: Goldeneye 457 0 Mar 11, 1:21pm
                                   Collapse I agree shadowdog 458 1 Mar 13, 3:08pm
                                       Who says that? Arannir 433 0 Mar 13, 4:40pm
                   Cheaper, quicker, easier and safer AshNazg 588 0 Mar 10, 11:54pm
                   Collapse Can you compare across two different media? Bumblingidiot 364 1 Mar 14, 4:29am
                       Err - slight repeat there.. Bumblingidiot 359 0 Mar 14, 5:18am
       Agree with a lot of this. Arannir 1635 0 Mar 10, 8:52am
       Yes good summary burrahobbit 716 0 Mar 10, 6:19pm

  Collapse Where did this poster come from? Lindele 1690 17 Mar 9, 3:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by Magpie)
       Collapse I haven't dormouse 1492 2 Mar 9, 3:35pm
           Collapse Google images says it hit 4/5 days ago... QuackingTroll 1478 1 Mar 9, 3:49pm
               Possibly, but Lindele 810 0 Mar 11, 3:33am
       Collapse I think it's from this site Magpie 1462 3 Mar 9, 4:08pm
           Collapse I might point out, the site I linked to has a "ask me anything" link Magpie 1227 2 Mar 9, 8:21pm
               Collapse Answer... Lindele 721 1 Mar 11, 3:59pm
                   fantastic Magpie 689 0 Mar 11, 6:30pm
       I don't know but I like it. Elessar 1446 0 Mar 9, 4:12pm
       Looks to me like a mashup of some older posters // Gianna 1317 0 Mar 9, 6:25pm
       Collapse I would have preferred this for the 2D Bluray tsmith675 1297 2 Mar 9, 7:10pm
           Collapse On the EE it would look a little like this: AshNazg 988 1 Mar 10, 1:27pm
               Purple could be... TheHutt 915 0 Mar 10, 5:49pm
     Collapse OT on a humorous note, I think the Modar must think this phrase a lot...! Brethil 1292 3 Mar 9, 7:15pm
           Collapse I had exactly the same thought :D // Ilmatar 1256 1 Mar 9, 7:36pm
               Me too! dernwyn 1108 0 Mar 10, 12:48am
         Thorin and Bilbo in this.... Avandel 1241 0 Mar 9, 8:11pm
       Ugh CathrineB 1255 0 Mar 9, 7:46pm

  Collapse Dwalin's relationship to the heirs of Durin marary 1263 16 Mar 9, 11:51am Jump to last post in thread (by Nuradar)
       I love Dwalin CathrineB 1142 0 Mar 9, 12:54pm
       Collapse And in my fanfics, too Kilidoescartwheels 1105 8 Mar 9, 2:06pm
           Collapse Dwalin is a headcanon rockstar marary 1100 7 Mar 9, 2:18pm
               Collapse I wrote a fanfic about that Kilidoescartwheels 1045 6 Mar 9, 4:34pm
                   Terrific! marary 1013 0 Mar 9, 5:21pm
                   Collapse For those who have not yet read it, it's very entertaining. I loved it! /// Kirly 983 2 Mar 9, 6:32pm
                       Collapse Thank you! Kilidoescartwheels 974 1 Mar 9, 6:49pm
                         I look forward to reading it! Kirly 858 0 Mar 10, 3:08am
                   Collapse subject marillaraina 841 1 Mar 10, 4:30am
                       Yes Kilidoescartwheels 782 0 Mar 10, 1:33pm
       Well, Dwalin and Balin are of Durin's Line Otaku-sempai 1061 0 Mar 9, 4:00pm
       I love Dwalin!!! lionoferebor 898 0 Mar 9, 11:32pm
       Dwalin's father Fundin Elanor of Rohan 744 0 Mar 10, 4:44pm
       Collapse I would like to have seen a bit more Dwalin and Kili/Fili interplay... moreorless 662 1 Mar 11, 10:46am
           I like this interpretation! marary 657 0 Mar 11, 10:57am
       What a great list Nuradar 531 0 Mar 12, 1:30pm

Collapse Can we talk about Bolg's design? AshNazg 1307 66 Mar 9, 12:33am Jump to last post in thread (by squiggle)
       Collapse Didn't like it Crunchable Birdses 1169 1 Mar 9, 12:51am
           Interesting. So here are a few thoughts... AshNazg 902 0 Mar 9, 1:04pm
       Battle of the Five Armies Chronicles Book Pandallo 1078 0 Mar 9, 5:20am
       Collapse The reason for the armor plates marary 1039 1 Mar 9, 7:52am
           Or just do what Thorin did to Azog... AshNazg 875 0 Mar 9, 1:44pm
       Collapse Design would have been totally okay... Arannir 1022 58 Mar 9, 8:47am
           Collapse Oh - but surely Bolg is the one who should be there, isn't he? dormouse 1012 3 Mar 9, 9:14am
               Collapse When speaking about Tolkien and canon, yes, Arannir 1006 2 Mar 9, 9:18am
                   Collapse In terms of the films.... dormouse 981 1 Mar 9, 9:59am
                       I know this is one of the reasons... Arannir 976 0 Mar 9, 10:04am
           Collapse Does there have to be a reason? Estel78 1000 45 Mar 9, 9:41am
               Collapse Not the same, imho. Arannir 991 44 Mar 9, 9:51am
                   Collapse Agree to disagree Estel78 968 6 Mar 9, 10:13am
                       I would be okay with this. Arannir 961 0 Mar 9, 10:21am
                       Bolg Mooseboy018 760 0 Mar 9, 5:49pm
                       Collapse In my opinion redgiraffe 568 3 Mar 11, 5:37am
                           Collapse Is a Stylistic Esthetic of Linearity that is in play i'd say squiggle 330 2 Mar 14, 12:35am
                               Collapse A great and thoughtful post Michelle Johnston 278 1 Mar 14, 5:31pm
                                 That's nice of you to say Michelle squiggle 177 0 Mar 16, 1:52am
                   Collapse Well Put Michelle Johnston 545 36 Mar 11, 9:06am
                       Collapse Agree with both Michelle and redgiraffe. Arannir 537 35 Mar 11, 9:22am
                           Collapse some posts are not giving Azog his full due as a character here squiggle 528 16 Mar 11, 10:00am
                               Collapse All what you say is true. Arannir 511 15 Mar 11, 1:39pm
                                   Collapse Your posts are breath of fresh air to me, Arannir Voronwë_the_Faithful 504 12 Mar 11, 2:21pm
                                       Collapse This is great. Arannir 494 4 Mar 11, 2:56pm
                                           Collapse A thought Elessar 485 1 Mar 11, 3:08pm
                                               That's the issue for me as well... dormouse 428 0 Mar 11, 6:27pm
                                           I'm with Voronwe BlackFox 475 0 Mar 11, 3:19pm
                                           I agree with Voronwe, Arannir.... dormouse 453 0 Mar 11, 4:32pm
                                       Collapse Feeling defensive Elessar 488 5 Mar 11, 3:05pm
                                           Collapse Individual Films now its the Trilogy. Michelle Johnston 434 4 Mar 11, 6:03pm
                                               Collapse Be it each film or its trilogy Elessar 419 2 Mar 11, 6:45pm
                                                   Collapse and thats great Michelle Johnston 410 1 Mar 11, 6:59pm
                                                       No problem Elessar 405 0 Mar 11, 7:10pm
                                               That says it all pretty well :) I agree! Arannir 324 0 Mar 12, 8:29am
                                       Point Taken Michelle Johnston 464 0 Mar 11, 4:19pm
                                 Collapse Thanks for your reply squiggle 354 1 Mar 12, 12:05am
                                       First of all: thanks to all for their kind words. Arannir 326 0 Mar 12, 8:26am
                           And Again Michelle Johnston 462 0 Mar 11, 4:13pm
                           Collapse switch redgiraffe 271 16 Mar 13, 5:40am
                               Collapse Organic neat twist or …... Michelle Johnston 256 15 Mar 13, 8:10am
                                   Collapse Who is to say that isn't there though? Elessar 203 14 Mar 13, 1:09pm
                                       Collapse No. I have to agree with Michelle on this. Otaku-sempai 464 7 Mar 13, 1:43pm
                                           Collapse You're welcomed to agree of course Elessar 459 3 Mar 13, 1:57pm
                                               Collapse Yes and no. Otaku-sempai 456 2 Mar 13, 2:07pm
                                                   Collapse The narrative Elessar 451 1 Mar 13, 2:16pm
                                                       Which is exactly what I posted above. Otaku-sempai 446 0 Mar 13, 2:27pm
                                           Collapse I'm inclined to agree with Elessar.... dormouse 441 2 Mar 13, 2:50pm
                                               Collapse Nahh... Arannir 417 1 Mar 13, 4:59pm
                                                   That's fair enough... dormouse 408 0 Mar 13, 5:12pm
                                       Collapse Creative Tension and Logic Michelle Johnston 446 3 Mar 13, 2:28pm
                                           How it works for me. Elessar 439 0 Mar 13, 3:00pm
                                           Collapse Or possibly dramatic irony? dormouse 430 1 Mar 13, 4:01pm
                                               My apologies Michelle Johnston 388 0 Mar 13, 7:09pm
                                       Collapse Welcome redgiraffe 340 1 Mar 14, 12:03am
                                           Thanks! Elessar 331 0 Mar 14, 12:23am
           Collapse Kill Azog in flashback tattooed_dwarf 978 6 Mar 9, 10:09am
               Exactly. Arannir 970 0 Mar 9, 10:12am
               Collapse Thorin. arithmancer 935 2 Mar 9, 11:24am
                   well.. tattooed_dwarf 839 0 Mar 9, 3:00pm
                   But Azog's beef isn't because he lost his hand... QuackingTroll 836 0 Mar 9, 3:16pm
               The argument is that the two armies need two leaders... AshNazg 874 0 Mar 9, 1:52pm
               Yes redgiraffe 565 0 Mar 11, 5:31am
           Bolg's purpose in the films. Otaku-sempai 811 0 Mar 9, 4:03pm
       I Grew to like Bolg alot squiggle 914 0 Mar 9, 12:10pm
       My thoughts. Elessar 488 0 Mar 11, 2:59pm

Collapse War/battle horns, doubtful any exist PWOKristy 780 3 Mar 8, 10:26pm Jump to last post in thread (by PWOKristy)
       Collapse Ha! Otaku-sempai 553 2 Mar 9, 4:18pm
           Re,: PWOKristy 525 0 Mar 9, 5:51pm
           Re.: PWOKristy 475 0 Mar 9, 9:51pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 967 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.