Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 3 of 1057 (374426 posts in 15855 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1057 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
Collapse Caption Contest the XI-th - funny bones at the ready.... dormouse 629 17 Jun 6, 9:56pm Jump to last post in thread (by Lissuin)
       After retiring from his years as Magneto, OldestDaughter 579 0 Jun 6, 10:40pm
       "You can find the others if you are brave..." Otaku-sempai 572 0 Jun 6, 10:53pm
       Collapse Here's lookin' at you, kid. // cats16 543 1 Jun 7, 5:31am
           "You know... you really are quite attractive in the moonlight... TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 540 0 Jun 7, 7:48am
       Collapse caption LSF 541 2 Jun 7, 9:09am
           Collapse sorry about that LSF 477 1 Jun 7, 8:25pm
               I was wondering if that was the problem. dernwyn 466 0 Jun 7, 10:20pm
       Collapse Gandalf is trying to kiss the moth on the mouth and hopes that it will turn in to a beautiful princess. Smaug the iron 529 2 Jun 7, 10:47am
           Collapse Instead, it just became an eagle TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 512 1 Jun 7, 2:15pm
               And Gandalf and the eagle lived happily ever after. Smaug the iron 476 0 Jun 7, 8:21pm
       "Just whistle while you work..."// Dame Ioreth 500 0 Jun 7, 3:10pm
       Pssst - the Lord of the Rings coloring book is coming! Pass it on! Kilidoescartwheels 465 0 Jun 7, 10:12pm
       Moths Gandalf, who lives in a cave and eats 10,000 moths a day, is an outlier adn should not have been counted. Fereth 451 0 Jun 8, 2:04am
       Caption 2 LSF 378 0 Jun 10, 9:27am
       Collapse Gandalf, the guys asked me to ask you to ask the other guys Lissuin 367 2 Jun 10, 8:16pm
           Collapse The winner! dormouse 327 1 Jun 12, 9:26am
               Thanks, dormouse! Toum for everybody! // Lissuin 313 0 Jun 12, 11:42am

  Collapse Food for thought for Hobbit bookfans Kilidoescartwheels 1390 146 Jun 6, 2:45pm Jump to last post in thread (by KW)
       Collapse agreeing with the article LSF 1155 81 Jun 6, 6:02pm
           Collapse Nice post KDC Avandel 1143 1 Jun 6, 6:49pm
               About China Kilidoescartwheels 1103 0 Jun 6, 9:58pm
           Collapse I didn't know PJ stated that he wasn't making this for fans of the book wizzardly 1076 33 Jun 6, 11:43pm
               Collapse For the record Kilidoescartwheels 289 32 Jun 7, 5:29pm
                   Collapse I wish he did say that he didn't make these for fans of the book wizzardly 215 31 Jun 7, 8:56pm
                       Collapse seriously, wizzardly? weathertop 507 30 Jun 8, 3:11pm
                           Collapse Know thine enemy? N.E. Brigand 460 24 Jun 8, 6:16pm
                               Collapse And I applaud you for that Kilidoescartwheels 412 21 Jun 8, 10:32pm
                                   Collapse Woah, there horsey! Morthoron 372 20 Jun 9, 1:49am
                                       Collapse And then there are some thorny issues like ange1e4e5 361 1 Jun 9, 1:56am
                                           Or the tried and true fallback for every apologist: It's a different medium than the book! Morthoron 354 0 Jun 9, 2:20am
                                       Collapse I think this deserves a response Kilidoescartwheels 343 6 Jun 9, 3:53am
                                           Collapse Nice response Avandel 390 5 Jun 9, 4:16pm
                                               Collapse What's the deal with all the beard complaints, anyway? ange1e4e5 373 4 Jun 9, 5:21pm
                                                   Collapse Canon Avandel 353 3 Jun 9, 6:41pm
                                                       Collapse Didn't get the pun? ange1e4e5 335 2 Jun 9, 7:05pm
                                                           Collapse Don't know about Avandel... Otaku-sempai 303 1 Jun 9, 7:53pm
                                                               I need chocolate.... Avandel 497 0 Jun 10, 1:05am
                                       Collapse Bullet points TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 341 10 Jun 9, 4:48am
                                           Good points, TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense. Noria 398 0 Jun 9, 3:48pm
                                           Collapse Well said... Anubis 389 1 Jun 9, 4:24pm
                                               That "the book was not flawless" is usually not worth mentioning. N.E. Brigand 274 0 Jun 9, 8:54pm
                                           Collapse I started out a couple of lengthy responses but I won't bother. KW 321 1 Jun 9, 7:19pm
                                               Good thing it wasn't the longer version TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 314 0 Jun 9, 7:31pm
                                           Collapse Confutatio... Morthoron 524 4 Jun 10, 12:37am
                                               Did you read my reply??? Kilidoescartwheels 463 0 Jun 10, 4:11am
                                               ... Anubis 411 0 Jun 10, 4:12pm
                                               Collapse Ah jeez, okay let me clear this up a bit TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 380 1 Jun 10, 8:45pm
                                                   Just fyi as concerns use of caps. N.E. Brigand 360 0 Jun 10, 9:42pm
                               i fully appreciate this line of thought weathertop 412 0 Jun 9, 3:10pm
                               agreed - geordie 408 0 Jun 9, 3:21pm
                           Collapse Yes, I seriously despise PJ's Hobbit... wizzardly 397 4 Jun 8, 11:01pm
                               Collapse yeah, i apologize weathertop 409 3 Jun 9, 3:16pm
                                   Collapse My reasons for my hatred of this adaptation are many... wizzardly 551 2 Jun 10, 12:00am
                                       Collapse It probably has made a better Warcraft movie than the one in theaters right now. ange1e4e5 523 1 Jun 10, 12:32am
                                           Warcraft vs. Tolkien Otaku-sempai 486 0 Jun 10, 1:41am
           Collapse another medium Elthir 941 44 Jun 7, 2:15pm
               Collapse But Avandel 925 42 Jun 7, 2:54pm
                   Collapse Tolkien didn't approve of PJ... Eldorion 907 40 Jun 7, 3:47pm
                       Collapse The films are all the better for it TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 897 39 Jun 7, 4:10pm
                           And still, every chapter's accounted for TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 893 0 Jun 7, 4:14pm
                           Collapse Sure, if your expectations of The Hobbit were for it to be LOTR Lite // Eldorion 282 37 Jun 7, 5:25pm
                               Collapse Desires or expectations? Silverlode 263 36 Jun 7, 10:34pm
                                   Collapse Yep, squire was referring to "The Hobbit" films as "fan fiction" as far back as 2008. N.E. Brigand 253 33 Jun 7, 10:59pm
                                       Collapse 'Hobbit' Sequel Otaku-sempai 217 32 Jun 8, 12:59am
                                           Collapse Good point, however . . . N.E. Brigand 214 31 Jun 8, 1:05am
                                               Collapse Elevating Thorin MedwedtoBeorn 568 30 Jun 8, 2:05am
                                                   Collapse IMO that's interesting too re elevating Thorin Avandel 486 29 Jun 8, 3:55pm
                                                       Collapse ... LSF 477 4 Jun 8, 4:58pm
                                                           Collapse Nuance MedwedtoBeorn 456 1 Jun 8, 6:03pm
                                                               *Sigh* - agree Avandel 424 0 Jun 8, 8:02pm
                                                           Agreed TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 441 0 Jun 8, 7:02pm
                                                           Thank you for clarifying re Serkis Avandel 431 0 Jun 8, 7:47pm
                                                       Collapse That's how I felt about book Thorin, hehe Kilidoescartwheels 332 23 Jun 9, 4:02am
                                                           Collapse Thorin MedwedtoBeorn 416 22 Jun 9, 3:05pm
                                                               Collapse Well.... dormouse 387 19 Jun 9, 4:24pm
                                                                   Collapse I'm sure some are MedwedtoBeorn 335 18 Jun 9, 7:02pm
                                                                       Collapse Well, no, it isn't obvious - that's the point I'm trying to make.... dormouse 304 17 Jun 9, 7:40pm
                                                                           Collapse Younger MedwedtoBeorn 270 16 Jun 9, 8:57pm
                                                                               Collapse Actually, there's another reason Kilidoescartwheels 253 6 Jun 9, 10:03pm
  Collapse agree LSF 247 5 Jun 9, 10:12pm
       Collapse story arc MedwedtoBeorn 219 4 Jun 9, 11:31pm
           Collapse Doesn't Tolkien himself "rob" Beorn of impact? N.E. Brigand 214 3 Jun 9, 11:37pm
               Collapse He still MedwedtoBeorn 539 2 Jun 10, 12:13am
                   Collapse It would be pretty bold not to show the end of the battle. N.E. Brigand 349 1 Jun 10, 9:49pm
                       I like that kind of bold. KW 256 0 Jun 11, 2:15pm
                                                                               Collapse Who said anything about an organic decision? dormouse 250 8 Jun 9, 10:12pm
  Collapse Younger Thorin MedwedtoBeorn 230 7 Jun 9, 11:09pm
       Collapse And I disagree with that Kilidoescartwheels 534 2 Jun 10, 12:19am
           Collapse As pointed out MedwedtoBeorn 513 1 Jun 10, 12:43am
               The younger Thorin may ultimately have been a somewhat prosaic decison.. Avandel 482 0 Jun 10, 2:04am
       Collapse Thorin was not the first... No One in Particular 472 1 Jun 10, 3:17am
           Agree with Avandel 409 0 Jun 10, 4:17pm
       Collapse The source material tells us.... dormouse 451 1 Jun 10, 11:35am
           LOL - well, IMO, that does sum things up... Avandel 416 0 Jun 10, 3:54pm
                                                               Collapse Regarding Thorin & Dain Kilidoescartwheels 242 1 Jun 9, 10:30pm
                                                                   Maybe like was the wrong wording MedwedtoBeorn 544 0 Jun 10, 12:06am
                                   Collapse Poor phrasing on my part Eldorion 250 1 Jun 7, 11:05pm
                                       Thanks for the clarification. Silverlode 205 0 Jun 8, 1:55am
                   in general waters Elthir 461 0 Jun 8, 5:54pm
               "I don't know anyone who wanted 'every detail and word included.'" N.E. Brigand 295 0 Jun 7, 4:52pm
       yum! balbo biggins 1104 0 Jun 6, 9:52pm
       Collapse I watched a few minutes of AUJ last night... Morthoron 1096 30 Jun 6, 10:40pm
           You've got to be joking! wizzardly 1076 0 Jun 6, 11:46pm
           Collapse Well I agree that wasn't one of the better scenes Kilidoescartwheels 1059 28 Jun 7, 12:37am
               Collapse But you see, that's the issue, KDC... Morthoron 1029 25 Jun 7, 2:28am
                   Collapse Like I said, Kilidoescartwheels 1018 2 Jun 7, 3:23am
                       Collapse not to some people... LSF 1006 1 Jun 7, 4:30am
                           Well that's crazy! Kilidoescartwheels 957 0 Jun 7, 1:45pm
                   Collapse Well, it's true that Peter Jackson likes heightened tension... dormouse 962 3 Jun 7, 1:36pm
                       Collapse Yep TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 949 2 Jun 7, 1:57pm
                           Collapse Also, to reiterate kilidoescartwheels TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 945 1 Jun 7, 2:06pm
                               "A lot in this story . . . is flexible". N.E. Brigand 293 0 Jun 7, 4:58pm
                   Collapse Director's choice tho.... Avandel 934 17 Jun 7, 2:31pm
                       Collapse "Tolkien's material IMO doesn't lend itself . . . to having folks at a dinner table staring at each other" N.E. Brigand 283 16 Jun 7, 5:36pm
                         Collapse Yes, IMO restraint can be very effective Avandel 261 4 Jun 7, 6:51pm
                               Collapse There's a good 45-minute film hiding in Jackson's 474-minute trilogy. N.E. Brigand 236 3 Jun 7, 11:28pm
                                   Well, I nominate you to start that! Kilidoescartwheels 222 0 Jun 8, 12:24am
                                   Collapse Interesting! (: Avandel 475 1 Jun 8, 4:38pm
                                       Japanese critics picked it as the best film of the year. N.E. Brigand 401 0 Jun 10, 5:08pm
                           Collapse And THAT is one of the difficulties Kilidoescartwheels 245 10 Jun 7, 7:38pm
                               Collapse "they provided that background info that I, at least, wanted to know" N.E. Brigand 233 9 Jun 7, 8:07pm
                                   Collapse How does it not fit with the story? LSF 228 7 Jun 7, 8:24pm
                                       Collapse As you say: "The movie changed the details of some of it". N.E. Brigand 221 6 Jun 7, 8:42pm
                                           Collapse but... LSF 212 4 Jun 7, 8:50pm
                                               Collapse KDC wanted to be told more about the background story from the book. N.E. Brigand 284 3 Jun 7, 9:12pm
                                                   Collapse About the Chance Meeting Kilidoescartwheels 274 2 Jun 7, 9:32pm
                                                       Collapse Have you ever seen the 1960 documentary "Frames of Reference"? N.E. Brigand 251 1 Jun 7, 10:46pm
                                                           The documentary "Frames of Reference" Kilidoescartwheels 225 0 Jun 8, 12:23am
                                           Let me be clear Kilidoescartwheels 282 0 Jun 7, 9:18pm
                                   What conflict? Kilidoescartwheels 221 0 Jun 7, 8:41pm
               Collapse hmm... LSF 1006 1 Jun 7, 4:23am
                   So true Kilidoescartwheels 952 0 Jun 7, 1:47pm
       Collapse "I imagine most [writers] would like nothing better than to see their work on the big (or even small) screen" N.E. Brigand 881 25 Jun 7, 4:41pm
           Collapse Couldn't hurt their own work either way TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 292 2 Jun 7, 4:52pm
               Collapse Is any novel made from a film considered special? N.E. Brigand 290 1 Jun 7, 5:03pm
                   The Writer's Paradox Otaku-sempai 278 0 Jun 7, 5:38pm
           Collapse Don't know why it's strange Kilidoescartwheels 287 21 Jun 7, 5:24pm
               Collapse I thought perhaps it implied that movies are more important or better than books. N.E. Brigand 274 20 Jun 7, 5:50pm
                   Collapse Well for the authors I'm sure it's about money, Kilidoescartwheels 233 19 Jun 7, 7:57pm
                       Collapse "That would make a great book!" Have you ever said that about a movie? N.E. Brigand 230 15 Jun 7, 8:04pm
                           Collapse Are you just playing Devil's Advocate? Kilidoescartwheels 292 14 Jun 7, 9:00pm
                               Collapse yeah... LSF 287 10 Jun 7, 9:05pm
                                   Collapse Try to write the most famous scene in "Psycho" as if it were in a novel. N.E. Brigand 247 9 Jun 7, 11:01pm
                                       Collapse Haven't seen that movie... LSF 239 1 Jun 7, 11:17pm
                                           Yes, that's the scene. N.E. Brigand 229 0 Jun 7, 11:47pm
                                       Collapse Not the best example... Otaku-sempai 214 6 Jun 8, 1:02am
                                           Hoist by my own petard! N.E. Brigand 568 0 Jun 8, 2:25am
                                           Collapse Fortunately, I do! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 554 4 Jun 8, 3:13am
                                               Collapse And, of course, I believe TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 548 1 Jun 8, 3:19am
                                                   Last post, promise TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 542 0 Jun 8, 3:24am
                                               Collapse Thanks for checking. Otaku-sempai 534 1 Jun 8, 3:31am
                                                   True, but being a primarily visual and auditory (well mostly... after the 1920's) medium, that's a given TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 532 0 Jun 8, 3:45am
                               Collapse Not at all. N.E. Brigand 262 2 Jun 7, 10:11pm
                                   Collapse Tough question to answer Kilidoescartwheels 221 1 Jun 8, 12:31am
                                       Maybe Shatner should read a computer manual as an audio book. // N.E. Brigand 214 0 Jun 8, 12:36am
                       Collapse Film-to-book and books spun from films Otaku-sempai 212 2 Jun 7, 8:52pm
                           Collapse I read the "Star Wars" novelization. N.E. Brigand 282 1 Jun 7, 9:20pm
                               I won't argue with that. Otaku-sempai 271 0 Jun 7, 9:35pm
       Collapse Plus ça change. N.E. Brigand 283 3 Jun 7, 5:58pm
           Collapse That's an interesting thought.... dormouse 265 2 Jun 7, 6:44pm
               Collapse Of course, Tolkien had doubts about "The Return of the King". N.E. Brigand 239 1 Jun 7, 7:58pm
                   title changing LSF 230 0 Jun 7, 8:17pm
       Boy, can I start something or can I start something??? Kilidoescartwheels 225 0 Jun 8, 12:38am
     Posts deleted from this thread for personal remarks. Silverlode 309 0 Jun 11, 1:34am

  Collapse A blog link...Durins, colours, and honey pots, or Why Fili was pushed aside by WETA Avandel 826 13 Jun 2, 7:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse Fili was pushed aside by the script Kilidoescartwheels 755 6 Jun 2, 9:09pm
           Collapse Besides IMO Avandel 743 5 Jun 2, 10:03pm
               Collapse RE: Kazinsky Kilidoescartwheels 733 2 Jun 2, 10:25pm
                   Collapse Well, I don't agree with that re the costume.... Avandel 724 1 Jun 2, 10:41pm
                       Well, maybe I'll write you a fanfic! Kilidoescartwheels 708 0 Jun 2, 11:36pm
               Collapse Sounds like it LSF 709 1 Jun 2, 11:47pm
                   me too! Avandel 610 0 Jun 3, 2:44pm
       Collapse Interesting subject Elarie 636 1 Jun 3, 11:37am
         I never tire of the costumes either... Avandel 598 0 Jun 3, 3:22pm
       Collapse It's not the color of the costume that bothered me Riven Delve 563 1 Jun 3, 10:58pm
           LOL Avandel 488 0 Jun 4, 7:04pm
       Collapse character colour themes LSF 398 1 Jun 6, 1:57am
         LOL Avandel 350 0 Jun 6, 3:18pm

  Collapse Do you think Del Toro's Hobbit would've been better? HOBBITFAN13 1284 57 May 31, 6:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by KingTurgon)
       Collapse Considering that PJ's The Hobbit's Lindele 1151 1 May 31, 6:21pm
           not necessary... LSF 1076 0 May 31, 9:08pm
       Not really Kilidoescartwheels 1139 0 May 31, 6:38pm
       Collapse Possibly in one respect Darkstone 1125 5 May 31, 7:28pm
           Collapse Possibly in another respect or two, too... Brandybuckled 1114 4 May 31, 7:45pm
               Collapse Erm... Silverlode 1060 1 May 31, 10:33pm
                   Good point... Brandybuckled 866 0 Jun 1, 3:18pm
               Collapse Possibly in a third way... malickfan 607 1 Jun 1, 8:35pm
                   Despite that, he made the move to include Silverlode 576 0 Jun 1, 11:15pm
       Collapse hard to judge a movie that does not exist... LSF 1081 1 May 31, 8:55pm
           Ditto more or less Avandel 1068 0 May 31, 9:34pm
       Collapse Did he plan to give all the dwarves beards? wizzardly 1039 13 May 31, 11:22pm
           Collapse Because that, of course, is the MOST important thing Kilidoescartwheels 1019 12 Jun 1, 12:24am
               Collapse hirsuteness and the lack thereof.... Avandel 1003 11 Jun 1, 1:42am
                   Collapse Now that's a beard! wizzardly 985 2 Jun 1, 2:40am
                       Collapse Saw this in world chat on Lord of the Rings Online Omnigeek 978 1 Jun 1, 3:14am
                           But that statement says a lot IMO Avandel 844 0 Jun 1, 4:23pm
                   Collapse These images are along the lines of how I picture Thorin: malickfan 606 7 Jun 1, 8:46pm
                       Very nice post IMO (: Avandel 590 0 Jun 1, 9:36pm
                       Collapse Still not a GdT fan Omnigeek 543 5 Jun 2, 4:17am
                           Collapse Telling the Dwarves apart Noria 519 1 Jun 2, 12:36pm
                               Yes, they say exactly that about the silhouettes... dormouse 503 0 Jun 2, 2:43pm
                           Collapse but re Avandel 484 2 Jun 2, 4:13pm
                               Collapse 13 Hairy Squares glor 447 1 Jun 2, 11:07pm
                                   I'm willing to trust the filmmakers re dwarf looks.... Avandel 397 0 Jun 3, 4:51pm
       Collapse No, I don't Omnigeek 1007 1 Jun 1, 1:08am
           I've seen most of GDT's work TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 951 0 Jun 1, 7:30am
       I think it would have been different... dormouse 936 0 Jun 1, 8:49am
       Guillermo del Toro’s Hobbit would have been very different, certainly visually. Noria 906 0 Jun 1, 11:45am
       Collapse Different, certainly... Otaku-sempai 883 5 Jun 1, 1:36pm
           Collapse I'm still relieved re Smaug tho.... Avandel 857 4 Jun 1, 3:46pm
               Collapse My own idea of Smaug... Otaku-sempai 849 3 Jun 1, 3:57pm
                   Collapse I liked the bigness.... Avandel 847 2 Jun 1, 4:29pm
                       Collapse Yes, absolutely.... dormouse 823 1 Jun 1, 6:40pm
                           Thank you - beautifully said IMO Avandel 600 0 Jun 1, 9:00pm
       Collapse Guillermo in his own words. Silverlode 583 1 Jun 1, 11:23pm
           Nice - thank you (: Avandel 562 0 Jun 2, 1:29am
       Impossible to judge really.... adt100 513 0 Jun 2, 1:43pm
       Collapse Better? MedwedtoBeorn 363 15 Jun 4, 3:03pm
           Collapse you bring up a couple interesting points weathertop 343 14 Jun 4, 6:30pm
               dwarves designs LSF 336 0 Jun 4, 6:53pm
               Collapse Design differences MedwedtoBeorn 322 11 Jun 4, 9:34pm
                   Collapse addition MedwedtoBeorn 317 10 Jun 4, 10:02pm
                       Collapse It definitely included the White Council.... dormouse 313 9 Jun 4, 10:43pm
                           Collapse Better Idea MedwedtoBeorn 307 6 Jun 4, 11:06pm
                               Collapse Better not, I think dormouse 275 5 Jun 5, 10:12am
                                   Collapse Mean to say MedwedtoBeorn 257 4 Jun 5, 1:18pm
                                       Collapse Well, yes, they probably did document it.... dormouse 243 2 Jun 5, 6:04pm
                                           I would like it released myself. glor 360 0 Jun 5, 6:22pm
                                           It's most certainly owned and held by WB/MGM MedwedtoBeorn 342 0 Jun 5, 8:42pm
                                       Gotta agree with Dormouse LSF 352 0 Jun 5, 6:49pm
                           Collapse GDT glor 237 1 Jun 5, 6:19pm
                               Rumors MedwedtoBeorn 271 0 Jun 7, 11:39pm
               Definitely different MedwedtoBeorn 194 0 Jun 10, 11:26pm
       Graham McTavish mentions Brian Cox as Thorin Lissuin 265 0 Jun 8, 4:01am
       Not really much for Del Toro myself, to be honest. ange1e4e5 230 0 Jun 9, 1:58am
       No KingTurgon 127 0 Jun 16, 3:51pm

  Collapse Del Toro designs MedwedtoBeorn 692 4 May 31, 1:21am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Old Smithsonian article? Otaku-sempai 683 3 May 31, 1:45am
           Collapse was that the one weathertop 673 1 May 31, 1:50am
               Descriptions Otaku-sempai 671 0 May 31, 1:57am
           Alan Lee MedwedtoBeorn 676 0 May 31, 1:53am

  Collapse Being the Tenth Hobbit Caption Contest: X Marks the Spot Meneldor 623 17 May 30, 7:42pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       "That last M&M was MINE!" / Ataahua 551 0 May 30, 8:42pm
       What do you mean, some people don't like my beard? Omnigeek 544 0 May 30, 9:29pm
       Thorin gets a sharp reminder to not walk around barefoot after Ori's been playing with Lego. / Ataahua 536 0 May 30, 10:11pm
       "It's FAKE fur, I swear!" // cats16 528 0 May 30, 10:57pm
       Thorin to Enterprise! One to beam up, no sign of intelligent life down here! Fereth 525 0 May 30, 11:20pm
       It's MY computer and I'll update the OS when I want to!!! Avandel 517 0 May 30, 11:36pm
       And this is my QUEST - Lissuin 520 0 May 30, 11:43pm
       "Kili did what!!?" OldestDaughter 501 0 May 31, 1:37am
       Collapse "But more, much more than this... dormouse 493 3 May 31, 8:10am
         *Snigger* Avandel 449 0 May 31, 4:31pm
           Collapse Forgive me, Dormouse, Meneldor 239 1 Jun 5, 4:30pm
               The mouse pops out and makes a quick curtsey on the lid..... dormouse 204 0 Jun 6, 1:36pm
       Collapse Thorin checks out the acoustics at Mirkwood Hall prior to opening his all-dwarf opera, Out of Business in which Seville's barber moves to Erebor.// Dame Ioreth 461 1 May 31, 12:39pm
           *Spews coffee* If Dame I is THAT clever I ain’t gonna play no more – no more! Bracegirdle 461 0 May 31, 1:14pm
       "Stella!!" / Darkstone 434 0 May 31, 5:43pm
       Ori's belch is NUTHIN' - just listen to THIS! Kilidoescartwheels 428 0 May 31, 6:44pm
       My beard is short for a REASON! weathertop 288 0 Jun 4, 4:24am

  Moved: Howard Shore's Hobbit Symphony in Four Movements CONFIRMED - Premiere soon gkgyver - - May 29, 12:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by gkgyver)

  Collapse Petty-Dwarves Hamfast Gamgee 518 7 May 27, 11:02pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       Collapse I don't recall that. Otaku-sempai 497 5 May 27, 11:11pm
           Collapse Maybe he called them petty dwarves, not petty-dwarves. Meneldor 474 4 May 28, 2:11am
               Collapse Are we sure it wasn't Eleniel 449 3 May 28, 7:12am
                   Yes. Otaku-sempai 443 0 May 28, 7:25am
                   Collapse Now I'm picturing Thorin singing Meneldor 348 1 May 29, 12:40am
                       Where's the favourite button when you need it! // dormouse 318 0 May 29, 1:52pm
       No, Smaug does not say petty-Dwarves. Smaug the iron 433 0 May 28, 8:08am

  Collapse In The End Erethen 1541 116 May 27, 6:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by LittleHobbit)
       Slightly disappointed Otaku-sempai 1366 0 May 27, 6:52pm
       Collapse Sadness wizzardly 1338 88 May 27, 8:59pm
           Collapse Wow. LittleHobbit 1273 87 May 28, 1:10am
               Collapse Speaking of disrespectful wizzardly 1159 85 May 28, 2:23pm
                   Collapse Pesky thing about artists, eh? TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1081 84 May 28, 7:57pm
                       Collapse And no, it is not disrespectful to adapt a work in one's own creative way TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1076 83 May 28, 8:03pm
                           Collapse Of course, the audience has to like the changes. ange1e4e5 1068 82 May 28, 8:10pm
                               Collapse Well, yeah, the changes have to work in favor of the film TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1036 81 May 28, 10:17pm
                                   Collapse Those were the ones that the changes were large negatives, in my opinion. ange1e4e5 1019 1 May 28, 10:27pm
                                       Gotcha TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 1004 0 May 28, 11:05pm
                                   Collapse Rankin/Bass didn't adhere to every line of the text, yet produced a far superior adaptation. wizzardly 403 78 May 30, 2:37pm
                                       Collapse Far superior? Otaku-sempai 398 66 May 30, 2:46pm
                                           Collapse What I appreciate about the Rankin/Bass adaptation... wizzardly 358 65 May 30, 3:47pm
                                               Collapse To me, it just looked weird. For one, wood-elves needn't look like huge frogs. ange1e4e5 356 4 May 30, 3:50pm
                                                   Collapse well wizzardly 344 3 May 30, 4:00pm
                                                       Collapse I wouldn't say that's accurate to Tolkien's story either. ange1e4e5 344 1 May 30, 4:01pm
                                                           perhaps not wizzardly 499 0 May 30, 4:06pm
                                                       I'd have to go with the frog-like elves too... lionoferebor 454 0 May 30, 5:58pm
                                               Yes... Otaku-sempai 349 0 May 30, 3:56pm
                                               Collapse I wouldn't say the beards were most important Omnigeek 480 54 May 30, 4:58pm
                                                   The Beards wizzardly 466 0 May 30, 5:36pm
                                                   I agree wizzardly 465 0 May 30, 5:41pm
                                                   Collapse Ii've still to see a beardless dwarf.... dormouse 444 50 May 30, 6:35pm
                                                       Collapse Kili Omnigeek 439 45 May 30, 6:39pm
                                                           Collapse Kili has a beard dormouse 383 44 May 30, 9:41pm
                                                               Collapse No, he doesn't Omnigeek 337 43 May 31, 2:55am
                                                                   This is Silverlode 329 0 May 31, 4:42am
                                                                   I haven't and won't avoid admitting a deviation TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 319 0 May 31, 5:04am
                                                                   This will be my final comment on the subject of hirsute dwarves.... dormouse 305 0 May 31, 8:00am
                                                                   Collapse Seriously? Still the Beards Kilidoescartwheels 585 39 Jun 1, 1:14am
                                                                       Collapse Dormouse is a woman? LittleHobbit 555 6 Jun 1, 11:21am
                                                                           Collapse Yep.... dormouse 529 5 Jun 1, 3:53pm
                                                                               Collapse It's those delicate features Starling 510 3 Jun 1, 6:20pm
  Collapse Only because.... dormouse 509 2 Jun 1, 6:23pm
       Collapse You should show your accessories off Starling 472 1 Jun 2, 5:55am
           It is rather fetching, isn't it... dormouse 463 0 Jun 2, 7:47am
                                                                               OK...... LittleHobbit 262 0 Jun 4, 4:00am
                                                                       Collapse What Kili said. Noria 542 31 Jun 1, 12:07pm
                                                                           Collapse Not to mention... LittleHobbit 534 30 Jun 1, 2:49pm
                                                                               Actually, when it comes to "what works in a visual medium" KW 516 0 Jun 1, 5:31pm
                                                                               Collapse Because I couldn't tell the difference in other movies Omnigeek 478 28 Jun 2, 4:12am
  Here we must agree to disagree Kilidoescartwheels 442 0 Jun 2, 3:34pm
  Collapse exactly wizzardly 405 26 Jun 2, 11:32pm
       In Kili's case, it was partly pragmatism, because ange1e4e5 380 0 Jun 3, 1:29am
       Collapse Disrespect? Noria 342 4 Jun 3, 1:02pm
           Collapse it still pains me that noone gives any consideration weathertop 332 3 Jun 3, 3:11pm
               Collapse According to dernwyn 317 1 Jun 3, 4:09pm
                   this! weathertop 311 0 Jun 3, 5:12pm
               Maybe they all had genetic beard growth disorders wizzardly 290 0 Jun 3, 6:11pm
       Collapse Whereas, to fans of Tolkien like myself (fifty years plus)... dormouse 340 19 Jun 3, 2:07pm
           THANK YOU TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 324 0 Jun 3, 3:04pm
           Collapse My respect and affection to Tolkien's works wizzardly 302 17 Jun 3, 6:05pm
               Collapse They're not completely beardless, you know. ange1e4e5 297 6 Jun 3, 6:06pm
                   Collapse And not all of them are beardless. ange1e4e5 380 2 Jun 3, 6:13pm
                       Collapse no but at least half of them are folically challenged wizzardly 374 1 Jun 3, 6:23pm
                           If they were.... Silverlode 291 0 Jun 3, 9:29pm
                   Collapse Wood-elves Otaku-sempai 322 2 Jun 3, 7:53pm
                       Collapse Well they looked like they were a different species. I thought High Elves and Wood Elves were physically similar, you know? ange1e4e5 311 1 Jun 3, 8:19pm
                           That is exactly my point. Otaku-sempai 301 0 Jun 3, 8:46pm
               Collapse Well Smaug the iron 370 5 Jun 3, 6:42pm
                   Collapse oh wizzardly 361 4 Jun 3, 6:49pm
                       Collapse It's better than what's shown in the book, especially Fili's, just a cold execution. ange1e4e5 354 1 Jun 3, 6:55pm
                           "Here ends your filthy bloodline!" ange1e4e5 284 0 Jun 3, 9:32pm
                       Collapse Well Smaug the iron 353 1 Jun 3, 6:59pm
                           oh ok wizzardly 344 0 Jun 3, 7:00pm
               My respect and affection for Tolkien's works dormouse 340 0 Jun 3, 7:25pm
               Collapse well then Lindele 295 2 Jun 3, 9:11pm
                   Collapse Is it possible to like both Tolkien's original work and Peter Jackson's films? ange1e4e5 283 1 Jun 3, 9:34pm
                       Yes, 'course it is, and lots of us do // dormouse 279 0 Jun 3, 9:43pm
                                                       Collapse Bombur Otaku-sempai 438 2 May 30, 6:45pm
                                                           Collapse Actually, yes.... dormouse 381 1 May 30, 9:47pm
                                                               I'm almost willing to give Bombur a pass on the fact that if you squint you can almost imagine he has a proper beard. wizzardly 369 0 May 30, 9:53pm
                                                       "O! Where are you going...With beards all a-wagging?" wizzardly 432 0 May 30, 6:53pm
                                                   I wouldn't say they are important at all Kilidoescartwheels 348 0 May 30, 11:17pm
                                               Collapse "Most importantly of all, the dwarves all have beards." TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 370 3 May 30, 9:54pm
                                                   Collapse A dwarf without a beard is like a hobbit without hair on its feet...uncharacteristic wizzardly 362 2 May 30, 10:05pm
                                                       Collapse I said before and I'll say it again Kilidoescartwheels 354 1 May 30, 11:20pm
                                                           Bingo. TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 335 0 May 31, 2:36am
                                       Collapse Two words: unscary Balrog. ange1e4e5 393 7 May 30, 3:08pm
                                           Collapse There's no Balrog in The Hobbit wizzardly 381 6 May 30, 3:19pm
                                               and there's no crying in baseball, either Kilidoescartwheels 369 0 May 30, 3:32pm
                                               Collapse Whoops, I was talking about Bahkshi's The Lord of the Rings. How much do you like that one? ange1e4e5 357 4 May 30, 3:43pm
                                                   Collapse Most people seem to hate on Bakshi's LotR wizzardly 353 3 May 30, 3:55pm
                                                       Collapse You're bringing that up again? ange1e4e5 351 1 May 30, 3:56pm
                                                           sure wizzardly 496 0 May 30, 4:03pm
                                                       I actually agree with Wizzardly Noria 412 0 May 30, 7:46pm
                                       Collapse well then, just to blow your mind Kilidoescartwheels 377 2 May 30, 3:31pm
                                           well yes wizzardly 363 0 May 30, 3:35pm
                                           Okay... Otaku-sempai 367 0 May 30, 3:35pm
               ALL opinions are welcome here. entmaiden 1047 0 May 28, 9:50pm
       In my opinion... HOBBITFAN13 1322 0 May 27, 9:15pm
       Well, since everyone has a DIFFERENT opinion... Avandel 1297 0 May 27, 10:50pm
       Really tough question Kilidoescartwheels 1263 0 May 28, 1:10am
       Collapse Mixed feelings Omnigeek 1225 1 May 28, 5:25am
           That's how I feel too HOBBITFAN13 1169 0 May 28, 12:37pm
       Collapse And now, to answer the thread... LittleHobbit 1220 15 May 28, 7:11am
           No Forgetting Gandalf the Green 982 0 May 29, 12:10am
           Collapse Some things are a matter of opinion, some aren't Omnigeek 973 13 May 29, 12:43am
               I agree...well said. lionoferebor 948 0 May 29, 1:49am
               Collapse And, for all of that TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 935 9 May 29, 3:17am
                   Telling, that being less faithful TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 574 0 May 29, 3:33am
                   Collapse Changes: Some worked, others didn't. Otaku-sempai 532 7 May 29, 3:01pm
                       Collapse I loved all of that stuff TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 463 6 May 30, 2:41am
                           Collapse Odd thing about Alfrid's death scene dormouse 448 4 May 30, 8:47am
                               Collapse I agree with both TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense and dormouse. Noria 427 3 May 30, 12:31pm
                                   Collapse Compromises and Alterations Otaku-sempai 421 2 May 30, 1:27pm
                                       Collapse If PJ had planned to direct from the start, Noria 394 1 May 30, 9:05pm
                                           Lines, crossed and uncrossed Otaku-sempai 368 0 May 30, 9:57pm
                           I don't expect universal agreement... Otaku-sempai 423 0 May 30, 12:45pm
               Well, I'd say you're on 'matter of opinion' territory even here.... dormouse 545 0 May 29, 1:52pm
               Lots of changes in the LotR adaptation too Noria 530 0 May 29, 3:04pm
       Collapse As with any special experience..... dormouse 1207 2 May 28, 9:07am
           Beautifully said, dormouse, and I feel exactly the same. Noria 1173 0 May 28, 12:42pm
           That sums it up very well Ettelewen 1124 0 May 28, 3:28pm
       Honestly... malickfan 495 0 Jun 1, 9:00pm
       Well... lionoferebor 431 0 Jun 2, 4:48pm

  Collapse Hobbit Prologue - Was it necessary? ProudFeet 988 15 May 26, 10:59am Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       I like the prologue and think it serves a valuable function. Noria 911 0 May 26, 12:27pm
       Well... Otaku-sempai 894 0 May 26, 1:41pm
       Collapse It could have worked without the prologue scenes, Meneldor 886 1 May 26, 2:16pm
           Agreed. ange1e4e5 859 0 May 26, 3:44pm
       Maybe not necessary... LSF 847 0 May 26, 4:32pm
       It served great and efficient purpose TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 771 0 May 26, 10:05pm
       Collapse I disagree with your analysis Kilidoescartwheels 741 4 May 27, 12:41am
           Collapse Yet another thing PJ got wrong Omnigeek 539 3 May 28, 3:50pm
               Collapse I think Smaug the iron 535 2 May 28, 4:16pm
                   Collapse Ring versus dragon Omnigeek 441 1 May 30, 5:02pm
                       The Ring of Thror Otaku-sempai 436 0 May 30, 5:48pm
       Wrong question Omnigeek 742 0 May 27, 1:10am
       Yes, I think it was.... dormouse 653 0 May 27, 2:36pm
       Collapse The prologue was nice, but we could go without it DainPig 587 1 May 28, 1:24am
           Hobbit Fan Edit ProudFeet 555 0 May 28, 10:50am

  Collapse 3 Questions for the Fans (and non-fans too, if they would like to participate) LittleHobbit 868 39 May 24, 11:02am Jump to last post in thread (by LittleHobbit)
       OK..... dormouse 781 0 May 24, 11:13am
       3 answers! Riven Delve 771 0 May 24, 11:50am
       Here goes! BlackFox 762 0 May 24, 11:56am
       My answers Noria 754 0 May 24, 12:24pm
       Collapse Twice each Omnigeek 745 4 May 24, 1:09pm
           Collapse Formats. LittleHobbit 329 3 Jun 4, 3:55am
               Collapse In that case Omnigeek 270 2 Jun 6, 1:47am
                   ... makingstarwars 267 0 Jun 6, 2:43am
                   Thank you... LittleHobbit 81 0 Jun 17, 3:02am
       Replies Otaku-sempai 746 0 May 24, 1:11pm
       Hard to remember Kilidoescartwheels 720 0 May 24, 2:40pm
       Mine lionoferebor 699 0 May 24, 3:56pm
       Hard to remember but.... Avandel 681 0 May 24, 4:45pm
       my answers LSF 661 0 May 24, 6:21pm
       1 & 2.) TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 659 0 May 24, 6:38pm
       My Answers: malickfan 645 0 May 24, 7:04pm
       Here's mine... Queen of Erebor 626 0 May 24, 10:06pm
       My responses ange1e4e5 617 0 May 24, 10:30pm
       3 answers from a kind-of fan :) Gianna 601 0 May 25, 12:24am
       Collapse Short answer: viewed these movies more than any other in the theater Kim 586 4 May 25, 2:50am
           Collapse "At the end of DOS, when the screen went dark and the theater was silent, one guy yelled out, 'No!' Exactly how I felt." TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 589 3 May 25, 3:04am
               Collapse The end Kim 582 2 May 25, 3:20am
                   Collapse I agree, except that I do like how "The Empire Strikes Back" handled its ending TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 571 1 May 25, 5:36am
                       Still hate that Wilhelm scream, though TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 565 0 May 25, 5:38am
       My answer Smaug the iron 563 0 May 25, 5:46am
       Collapse You had to ask... Bracegirdle 535 8 May 25, 5:09pm
           Collapse Why ''I had to ask''? LittleHobbit 332 7 Jun 4, 3:48am
               *Didn't UNDERSTAND........... (non-native speaker here) LittleHobbit 326 0 Jun 4, 4:05am
             Collapse I admire all whose 2nd language is English and they have a decent grasp Bracegirdle 312 5 Jun 4, 1:13pm
                   Collapse I got that........ LittleHobbit 218 4 Jun 14, 8:05am
                       Collapse Perhaps not? Bracegirdle 194 3 Jun 14, 2:02pm
                           Collapse Oh, I think I REALLY get it now... LittleHobbit 135 2 Jun 15, 12:35pm
                               Collapse RIGHT! And why couldn’t I have put it so simply? Bracegirdle 108 1 Jun 15, 6:21pm
                                   I am glad..... LittleHobbit 78 0 Jun 17, 3:29am
       I say bring the marathon back! EomundDaughter 519 0 May 25, 5:57pm
       Fair enough, here we go Gandalf the Green 513 0 May 25, 6:22pm
       Let's see AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 426 0 May 25, 9:21pm
       My answers Eldorion 376 0 May 30, 6:56pm
       Answers Ilmatar 288 0 Jun 5, 6:15pm

  Collapse The Hobbit Caption Contest IX Darkstone 690 24 May 23, 2:31pm Jump to last post in thread (by Meneldor)
       Collapse Actually... Otaku-sempai 630 1 May 23, 3:00pm
           I like it... Darkstone 610 0 May 23, 4:55pm
       Collapse HANS! weathertop 617 2 May 23, 3:38pm
           Collapse "Well, ange1e4e5 608 1 May 23, 4:20pm
               thank you. weathertop 587 0 May 23, 5:19pm
       Collapse I shall teach you the woodland dances of my people. Meneldor 588 4 May 23, 5:23pm
           Collapse Bwa ha ha!! Noooo Loresilme 551 1 May 23, 7:43pm
             My work here is done. Meneldor 504 0 May 24, 12:16am
           Collapse The winner! Darkstone 294 1 May 30, 4:47am
               Why, thank you kindly, DS! Meneldor 272 0 May 30, 2:28pm
       "Did you honestly think she'd want YOU, when she had someone like ME?" Kilidoescartwheels 573 0 May 23, 5:31pm
       "All right, Mr. Jackson, I'm ready for my close-up." // Bracegirdle 566 0 May 23, 5:50pm
       "My eyes are like rapiers, my hair shimmers like moonlight, my.... dormouse 566 0 May 23, 6:20pm
       Don't hate me because I'm beautiful...// Dame Ioreth 543 0 May 23, 7:56pm
       Collapse BOLG (off-screen): When an Elf with paired knives... Otaku-sempai 544 2 May 23, 8:13pm
           That's an Orc proverb. ange1e4e5 524 0 May 23, 9:36pm
           And how's that working for you, Bolg? Kilidoescartwheels 514 0 May 23, 10:10pm
       Legolas shows his hairstylist just how he wants his new 'Leia-bun' hairdo to look. / Ataahua 533 0 May 23, 8:32pm
       And that's all for now from the Woodland Realm. Nanu nanu. // Lissuin 526 0 May 23, 9:12pm
       Collapse Much to Kili's growing concern, Legolas seemed far more willing than Tauriel had been to throw daggers in his direction. Fereth 518 1 May 23, 9:59pm
           LOL! Kilidoescartwheels 513 0 May 23, 10:11pm
       "I feel pretty, oh so pretty!" // cats16 465 0 May 24, 6:31am
       "Thirty-seven and not a hair out of place. Oh yeah, me bad!" // Bracegirdle 419 0 May 24, 9:27pm
       "When the chimes end, take out your knives. Try and stab me, Legolas. Just try." ange1e4e5 413 0 May 24, 10:28pm

  Collapse ONE...only ONE lionoferebor 1043 38 May 23, 2:49am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse Omit the battle of the stone giants. Ataahua 953 3 May 23, 3:13am
           Collapse Agreed. ange1e4e5 948 1 May 23, 3:16am
               The Giants Otaku-sempai 900 0 May 23, 7:17am
           The stone giants Omnigeek 936 0 May 23, 4:03am
       Collapse Alfrid Lickspittle. Meneldor 946 3 May 23, 3:26am
           Collapse Keep: the entire attack of Smaug on Laketown TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 942 2 May 23, 3:48am
               Collapse Thrain's wilhelm scream LSF 709 1 May 23, 6:25pm
                   Exactly! TheOnlyOneAroundWithAnySense 683 0 May 23, 7:26pm
       One to wish away, one to keep forever. Lissuin 920 0 May 23, 6:29am
       Collapse Stumpy the Troll--gone. Otaku-sempai 902 4 May 23, 7:20am
           Collapse I am happy to watch Stumpy Starling 899 2 May 23, 7:49am
               Collapse ??? Otaku-sempai 805 1 May 23, 2:00pm
                   The dwarf one Starling 715 0 May 23, 6:17pm
           Good morning Omnigeek 841 0 May 23, 12:33pm
       This is tough..... dormouse 900 0 May 23, 8:06am
       Choosing the one thing I'd omit is easy... BlackFox 866 0 May 23, 11:17am
       The first one is easy... Elarie 856 0 May 23, 11:46am
       Collapse The Love Triangle AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 779 2 May 23, 4:18pm
           Collapse What would you keep? lionoferebor 772 1 May 23, 4:24pm
               Too hard for me to chose AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 477 0 May 23, 8:38pm
       Collapse Tauriel's costume Darkstone 774 5 May 23, 4:39pm
           Collapse Tauriel's costume? Kilidoescartwheels 756 2 May 23, 5:18pm
               Well of course... Darkstone 741 0 May 23, 5:37pm
               BotFA EE Mooseboy018 209 0 May 26, 9:49pm
           Collapse Tauriel's costume Mooseboy018 207 1 May 26, 9:50pm
               All of them. / Darkstone 203 0 May 26, 10:00pm
       I would keep almost everything Kilidoescartwheels 750 0 May 23, 5:22pm
       keep... LSF 725 0 May 23, 6:10pm
       Lose PJ, and keep on Tolkien... wizzardly 462 0 May 23, 10:48pm
       Collapse Just one? Noria 375 4 May 24, 12:34pm
           Collapse Sidebar Otaku-sempai 360 1 May 24, 1:15pm
               I was OK with Alfrid dying as well. Noria 259 0 May 25, 1:48pm
           No, you're not the only one dormouse 339 0 May 24, 2:50pm
           Stone Giants Kilidoescartwheels 189 0 May 27, 12:20am
       I would have no problem losing OldestDaughter 356 0 May 24, 1:29pm
       I would omit the stick insect Nuradar 344 0 May 24, 2:15pm
       I would... malickfan 307 0 May 24, 7:06pm
       Lose the stone giants Arthael 282 0 May 25, 12:03am

  Collapse 5 major story deviations in the Hobbit movies that are a bigger deal than beard length Kilidoescartwheels 1052 31 May 22, 4:40am Jump to last post in thread (by LittleHobbit)
       Collapse Yes, I'd say that each of those was a bigger deal than beard length... dormouse 960 2 May 22, 11:29am
           Collapse Dol Goldur Kilidoescartwheels 888 1 May 22, 3:25pm
               I welcomed the addition of Dol Guldur as well... dormouse 822 0 May 22, 6:24pm
       Collapse Impactful Changes Otaku-sempai 922 26 May 22, 1:19pm
           Collapse Well...... dormouse 900 5 May 22, 2:46pm
               Collapse True... Otaku-sempai 873 4 May 22, 3:48pm
                   Collapse You're right, of course, in the sense that for anyone... dormouse 806 1 May 22, 7:09pm
                       Sauron, the Nine and the White Council Otaku-sempai 797 0 May 22, 7:30pm
                   Collapse This brings back memories... Ataahua 760 1 May 22, 8:45pm
                       Sauron re-embodied? Otaku-sempai 726 0 May 22, 10:04pm
           Collapse Other changes Kilidoescartwheels 881 1 May 22, 3:36pm
               That Darned Tapestry Otaku-sempai 867 0 May 22, 3:59pm
           Collapse Lot of good points, Otaku... Morthoron 873 17 May 22, 3:50pm
               Because it was real...silly wizzardly 857 0 May 22, 4:12pm
               Collapse No, they didn't. LittleHobbit 792 13 May 22, 7:36pm
                   Collapse Hmmm... Morthoron 773 5 May 22, 8:18pm
                       Thanks to Thranduil's line wizzardly 748 0 May 22, 9:00pm
                       Collapse Poll... lionoferebor 724 3 May 22, 10:19pm
                           Collapse So there you go... LittleHobbit 700 2 May 22, 11:02pm
                               Collapse Don't get excited... lionoferebor 694 1 May 22, 11:12pm
                                   I know... LittleHobbit 663 0 May 23, 1:37am
                   Collapse True, everyone sees things differently... Avandel 578 6 May 23, 3:30pm
                       Collapse I wish... lionoferebor 243 4 May 23, 4:36pm
                           Collapse Bows deeply - thank you very much (: Avandel 212 3 May 23, 10:02pm
                               Collapse WOW! That Fili art Kilidoescartwheels 205 2 May 23, 10:07pm
                                   Collapse It certainly does! Fereth 200 1 May 23, 10:27pm
                                       I love it...(: Avandel 197 0 May 23, 10:41pm
                       Actually, Avandel... LittleHobbit 82 0 Jun 1, 2:54pm
               Collapse Didn't everyone else cringe or throw up in their mouths a little when that was said? Fereth 748 1 May 22, 9:04pm
                   Bollocks are hilarious IMO Avandel 251 0 May 23, 3:38pm
       I agree with this wizzardly 902 0 May 22, 2:41pm

Collapse Why did PJ spend so much time on elves? HOBBITFAN13 728 13 May 19, 5:43pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse A very good question, indeed, for "The place for all Hobbit news and speculation". Lissuin 661 2 May 19, 7:52pm
           Collapse Yes, it's unfortunate IMO.... Avandel 586 1 May 19, 11:58pm
               Right from the start Otaku-sempai 571 0 May 20, 1:16am
       Collapse Easy. You're not watching Thranduil and Legolas more than Bilbo... dormouse 660 2 May 19, 7:52pm
           Collapse PJ's Elves Noria 516 1 May 20, 11:48am
               Earthy elves and hobbits (: Avandel 480 0 May 20, 3:35pm
       Collapse "Oh, God! Not another #&%#$#@ Elf!" Darkstone 657 1 May 19, 8:02pm
           Bwahaha! Riven Delve 622 0 May 19, 10:17pm
       You might as well ask why Tolkien did Kilidoescartwheels 644 0 May 19, 8:36pm
       Orcs & Elves wizzardly 598 0 May 19, 11:08pm
       Collapse I'm glad that he did; it ties in to the LOTR trilogy Loresilme 487 2 May 20, 3:13pm
           Collapse a little OT but.... Avandel 478 1 May 20, 3:54pm
               Good point, it would come as a shock Loresilme 465 0 May 20, 4:54pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1057 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.