Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 3 of 807 (297616 posts in 12097 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 807 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Which dwarf will support Thorin? Thorins_apprentice 472 12 Wed, 4:08am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       Collapse Dwalin for sure... Elutherian 316 3 Wed, 4:13am
           Collapse Hang on isnt he on the chariot. Thorins_apprentice 305 2 Wed, 4:17am
               Unless you have some info we don't Cirashala 294 0 Wed, 4:25am
               Mutineers? Have I missed something.... // dormouse 177 0 Wed, 8:37am
       Collapse Dwalin would be my guess Cirashala 356 2 Wed, 4:18am
           Collapse Brilliant post/s as usual Cirashala. Thorins_apprentice 273 1 Wed, 4:27am
               I am no Dwarf Rickster 232 0 Wed, 5:40am
       Collapse So - how do 'we' know Kili won't support Thorin? // dormouse 188 1 Wed, 8:36am
           Maybe reluctantly lol Thorins_apprentice 167 0 Wed, 10:02am
       Fili and Kili have already plenty of reasons Elanor of Rohan 146 0 Wed, 12:24pm
       Dwalin, for one. Otaku-sempai 106 0 Wed, 3:58pm
       Difference between agreeing & following Kilidoescartwheels 45 0 Wed, 10:23pm

  Collapse The pic from the comic con banner? kbdiggity 677 10 Wed, 1:01am Jump to last post in thread (by Spalko)
       Collapse Here Sebastian the Hedgehog 356 5 Wed, 1:46am
           Collapse Here is a clickable link... Owain 411 4 Wed, 2:02am
               Collapse How do you make links clickable on here? Sebastian the Hedgehog 265 3 Wed, 2:05am
                   Collapse Sure no problem... Owain 269 2 Wed, 2:09am
                       Collapse Thanks! // Sebastian the Hedgehog 220 1 Wed, 2:38am
                           No problem, Sebastian the Hedgehog.// Owain 232 0 Wed, 2:38am
       Collapse Still blurry, but closer Spalko 222 3 Wed, 6:17am
           Collapse Is there Fleuz 187 2 Wed, 6:38am
               I believe NecromancerRising 180 0 Wed, 6:40am
               Yes, Saruman and Elrond Spalko 196 0 Wed, 6:42am

  Collapse CGI and Color Grading skylynx 762 21 Tue, 11:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ardamírë)
       I was actually relatively pleased with the overall look and tone of the recent trailer. Name 422 0 Tue, 11:48pm
       Collapse I agree Scalpy 390 3 Wed, 12:10am
           Collapse The Hobbit: Attack of the CG Sunsets Mooseboy018 395 1 Wed, 12:21am
               100% agreed Ardamírë 76 0 Wed, 3:05pm
           As mentioned by PJ and PB they wanted a slightly more innocent, colourful, 'pre-darkness' look to The Hobbit adt100 154 0 Wed, 8:51am
       Collapse I find it interesting MEIGWIT 398 3 Wed, 12:13am
           Collapse It is perfectly possible... Macfeast 339 1 Wed, 1:11am
               Indeed. Scalpy 312 0 Wed, 1:16am
           Hmm I would like to agree but Annatar598 256 0 Wed, 3:43am
       Collapse Are you not aware JamesPaganini 391 4 Wed, 12:18am
           Collapse A good point, but... Scalpy 365 3 Wed, 12:26am
               Well I'm aware JamesPaganini 350 0 Wed, 12:37am
               Collapse Personally I like the change in the colour/tonne, I think it's personal preference adt100 139 1 Wed, 8:57am
                   While I agree with you abou the Hobbit... DaoinSidhe 133 0 Wed, 9:07am
       Collapse In my mind it's pretty straightfoward. Bishop 274 1 Wed, 3:32am
           Agreed in part adt100 138 0 Wed, 9:02am
       Hm. Arannir 181 0 Wed, 7:19am
       Collapse I am profoundly grateful.... dormouse 168 1 Wed, 8:33am
           Agreed DaoinSidhe 152 0 Wed, 8:43am
       I was EXTREMELY impressed with the CGI in the teaser... adt100 170 0 Wed, 8:49am
       Explaining SafeUnderHill 150 0 Wed, 9:09am

  Collapse Something is off with the release dates of BOFA. macfalk 735 15 Tue, 10:37pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       Collapse Box Office There&ThereAgain 405 3 Tue, 10:43pm
           Collapse Speaking of China macfalk 363 1 Tue, 10:47pm
               Hmm There&ThereAgain 337 0 Tue, 10:50pm
           Agreed. Also in the past films used to routinely open weeks/months ahead of other countries. A welcome change this ;) adt100 132 0 Wed, 9:05am
       Fantasy movies generally do very well in Scandinavia compared to other countires Carne 330 0 Tue, 11:00pm
       Collapse i don't understand it either. Mooseboy018 305 1 Tue, 11:32pm
           I'm confused at your point here? adt100 132 0 Wed, 9:10am
       Yes, strange and seemingly unnecessary. Name 293 0 Tue, 11:44pm
       Collapse Honestly? Ham_Sammy 291 1 Tue, 11:59pm
           Indeed soem of us have ahd to wait until Dec 26 patrickk 180 0 Wed, 6:29am
       I could see it still getting changed at some point, couldn't it? Arannir 161 0 Wed, 7:24am
       Collapse What's the problem? DanielLB 120 2 Wed, 11:03am
           Hear hear! dormouse 82 0 Wed, 2:16pm
           I was speaking only from a business perspective Ham_Sammy 61 0 Wed, 4:19pm
       Australians have the true right to grumble Kerewyn 88 0 Wed, 2:01pm

  Collapse New WETA Homepage Arannir 476 6 Tue, 10:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Arannir)
       Great! Thanks for sharing.// Owain 171 0 Tue, 10:12pm
       The orcs on page 10 look great! // Carne 171 0 Tue, 10:26pm
       Collapse So that's what Del Toro's Hobbit would have looked like Crunchable Birdses 184 3 Tue, 11:40pm
           Collapse Which one? Arannir 84 2 Wed, 7:24am
               Collapse just generally Crunchable Birdses 69 1 Wed, 8:00am
                   The ones... Arannir 75 0 Wed, 8:07am

Collapse Thranduil in BOFA, imagery he evokes, and maybe something for the readers Avandel 468 4 Tue, 10:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse Galadriel walking barefoot through the desolation in Dol Guldur.... Bladerunner 200 1 Wed, 12:01am
           Aaah - thought that was a reference to Avandel 190 0 Wed, 12:08am
       Collapse Very interesting stuff. It seems to be a statute of a white female doe. VeArkenstone 11 1 Thu, 11:40pm
         *Waves to Ve* and I agree Avandel 10 0 12:15am

  Collapse Would You Like Multiple Endings? Boromir Stark 452 13 Tue, 9:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse I don't really buy the idea that RotK had 'multiple endings'.... dormouse 250 2 Tue, 10:11pm
           It wrapped up multiple character arcs, as it should have... Salmacis81 218 0 Tue, 10:22pm
           Agree Joe20 106 0 Wed, 4:20am
       No. One ending. bungobaggins 228 0 Tue, 10:16pm
       I never really agreed that ROTK at "multiple" endings Elarie 212 0 Tue, 10:19pm
       Collapse Balin, Gandalf, Bilbo in Bag-end. Arannir 215 1 Tue, 10:22pm
           This is exactly what I'm looking for as well. Name 160 0 Tue, 11:51pm
       No - falling action Avandel 215 0 Tue, 10:24pm
       I agree with the above who say RotK had one ending, not multiple. Noria 197 0 Tue, 10:35pm
       Collapse Alternate endings? Kilidoescartwheels 117 1 Wed, 3:41am
           Harry Potter Mooseboy018 124 0 Wed, 3:55am
       The only thing I would like - excluding Gandalf, Balin and Bilbo at Bag-End FaramirAndEowynMorningStar 68 0 Wed, 10:02am
       Well... Otaku-sempai 44 0 Wed, 4:15pm

  Collapse Two wildcard characters Sharkey 667 17 Tue, 8:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by FoFo64)
       I think we can add... Arannir 399 0 Tue, 9:04pm
       Collapse Gollum and the Master Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 364 12 Tue, 9:30pm
           Collapse I'm very curious as to what they are going to do with Dain... Salmacis81 304 9 Tue, 10:12pm
               admittedly the focus of PJ's Hobbit is different from the book interpretation. DaughterofLaketown 266 0 Tue, 11:03pm
               I had not heard the cameo-comment before. Macfeast 247 0 Tue, 11:51pm
               Collapse But that's how it was in the book... FoFo64 91 6 Wed, 7:41pm
                   Collapse In the book... Macfeast 83 3 Wed, 8:32pm
                       Collapse I knew someone would bring up Azog and Legolas as a retort lol. FoFo64 74 2 Wed, 8:44pm
                           Collapse I get what you're saying. Macfeast 72 1 Wed, 8:53pm
                               Yeah lol FoFo64 60 0 Wed, 9:03pm
                   Collapse I understand that... Salmacis81 25 1 Thu, 7:16pm
                       But that's how it feels like in the book! FoFo64 19 0 Thu, 8:05pm
           Collapse Elrond and Saruman have been confirmed HiddenSpring 228 1 Wed, 12:28am
               Connolly is also confirmed in the updated synopis on the official movie site... Eleniel 153 0 Wed, 7:54am
       Collapse I'm curious... Bladerunner 261 1 Tue, 11:34pm
           The Master and Gollum Otaku-sempai 101 0 Wed, 4:21pm
       Sometimes IdrilofGondolin 65 0 Wed, 8:57pm

  Collapse Does this trailer make you reluctant to see it end? (Spoiler?) Kilidoescartwheels 546 11 Tue, 8:24pm Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       It's definitely the end of an era. Mooseboy018 261 0 Tue, 8:43pm
       No. Arannir 258 0 Tue, 8:45pm
       I always said we must enjoy the filming journey though it will always be Eruonen 211 0 Tue, 9:21pm
       You are not the only one doing these crazy things! There are many of us. VeArkenstone 196 0 Tue, 9:35pm
       Collapse It's not so bad... Seaber 195 3 Tue, 9:39pm
           Collapse My thoughts exactly! Ham_Sammy 110 1 Wed, 12:29am
               Perhaps Rickster 68 0 Wed, 5:37am
           Thank you so much for this quote I love...// mae govannen 48 0 Wed, 10:06am
       Collapse I think I understand the sentiment... Owain 186 1 Tue, 9:40pm
           I'm not looking forward to the death scenes, either... Queen of Erebor 171 0 Tue, 10:13pm
       I'll say that I enjoyed the trailer... Salmacis81 148 0 Tue, 10:49pm

  Collapse fundamental audience misunderstanding GiantMushroomBear 1115 42 Tue, 8:16pm Jump to last post in thread (by Imladris18)
       Just can't please everyone Kilidoescartwheels 508 0 Tue, 8:30pm
       Yeah.. tsmith675 488 0 Tue, 8:32pm
       Hm... Arannir 473 0 Tue, 8:41pm
       Collapse Are people not allowed to have opinions? Joe20 496 6 Tue, 8:45pm
           I don't think that is what this poster is talking about. tsmith675 470 0 Tue, 8:50pm
           Collapse The OP NecromancerRising 465 1 Tue, 8:54pm
               I'm more using this thread Joe20 434 0 Tue, 9:16pm
           Collapse Opinions are allowed... bungobaggins 361 2 Tue, 10:12pm
               Collapse I would have loved two movies GiantMushroomBear 231 1 Wed, 1:55am
                   Signs Bishop 187 0 Wed, 4:51am
       Collapse Gandalf and Green screen TheSexyBeard 419 1 Tue, 9:29pm
           I made a point of this... Aragorn the Elfstone 400 0 Tue, 9:36pm
       Collapse I propose a re-edit to see what is more entertaining MEIGWIT 416 24 Tue, 9:54pm
         Bravo!!!!!! Avandel 321 0 Tue, 10:49pm
           Collapse But not everyone wanted to be "wowed"... Salmacis81 327 19 Tue, 10:54pm
               Collapse I understand MEIGWIT 286 1 Wed, 12:04am
                   It was more a reply to your comment... Salmacis81 258 0 Wed, 12:38am
               Collapse Salmacis, your point is valid of course. Noria 269 5 Wed, 12:22am
                   About a more "grown-up" version... Salmacis81 258 0 Wed, 12:51am
                   Collapse The crux of the problem... Eleniel 171 3 Wed, 8:20am
                       I'm thinking 'poor od Peter Jackson' - Hanzkaz 149 0 Wed, 9:32am
                       Collapse That could be why these movies may not be quite as popular as the LotR movies. Noria 116 1 Wed, 12:34pm
                           The Hobbit Trilogy is meant for the (paying) fans of the LOTR Trilogy. Hanzkaz 101 0 Wed, 1:52pm
               Collapse A very fair point NecromancerRising 206 10 Wed, 6:21am
                   Collapse Sorry. Arannir 182 9 Wed, 7:35am
                       Collapse No. Avnar 171 1 Wed, 7:55am
                           Well, a lot of people disagree on that one. Arannir 166 0 Wed, 8:11am
                       Collapse No no, you missed my point Arannir. NecromancerRising 162 6 Wed, 8:35am
                           Surely there are those... Arannir 153 0 Wed, 8:46am
                           Collapse Sadly, this is true.. DaoinSidhe 139 4 Wed, 9:39am
                               There was. Arannir 136 0 Wed, 9:42am
                               Collapse People don't seem to understand that picture quality is at an all-time high. Imladris18 72 2 Wed, 5:02pm
                                   Collapse Such stuff was always noticeable to me... Aragorn the Elfstone 60 1 Wed, 5:44pm
                                       I don't personally mind. Imladris18 63 0 Wed, 5:52pm
           A passionate post, Meigwit! Kendalf 273 0 Tue, 11:49pm
           Collapse Let me point this out redgiraffe 189 1 Wed, 5:24am
               Damn good post. My thoughts exactly Joe20 209 0 Wed, 5:41am
       Collapse l'm not going to just blindly agree with you... Avnar 299 3 Wed, 12:00am
           How about you do it MEIGWIT 285 0 Wed, 12:09am
           ... Anubis 162 0 Wed, 8:32am
           Okay, but can we focus on what IS shown? Kilidoescartwheels 89 0 Wed, 4:35pm
       It's weird - Hanzkaz 215 0 Wed, 3:49am

  Collapse The Value of The Hobbit Trilogy Lindele 677 12 Tue, 6:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elessar)
       You know, it's not perfect but Kilidoescartwheels 292 0 Tue, 8:00pm
       Collapse I've come to greatly respect what Peter has set out to do... Aragorn the Elfstone 274 7 Tue, 8:16pm
           Collapse I think that's where critics and audiences may have misunderstood... Owain 219 6 Tue, 9:52pm
               Collapse That is definitely something I struggled with. Aragorn the Elfstone 205 4 Tue, 10:01pm
                   Collapse Sure, I understand what you are saying... Owain 201 2 Tue, 10:11pm
                       Well said and thank you Loresilme 150 0 Tue, 11:37pm
                       Great posts guys, beautifully said Owain Noria 149 0 Tue, 11:44pm
                   I totally agree with this Ardamírë 51 0 Wed, 3:03pm
               Thanks for both your posts, Owain dormouse 80 0 Wed, 8:19am
       Peter Jackson's Hobbit Trilogy - Hanzkaz 115 0 Wed, 4:53am
       Lovely post, and I agree... dormouse 83 0 Wed, 8:18am
       Fantastic post Elessar 37 0 Wed, 11:09pm

  Collapse Coffins in the trailer DaoinSidhe 944 14 Tue, 6:09pm Jump to last post in thread (by Owain)
       Collapse are those coffins? Cirashala 474 8 Tue, 6:22pm
           Collapse Maybe not a coffin.. DaoinSidhe 444 5 Tue, 6:23pm
               Collapse I can almost see what you mean Cirashala 426 2 Tue, 6:30pm
                   I'm not sure Aitieuriskon 351 0 Tue, 6:59pm
                   Hmmm... I kinda see it. That very well could be.// Owain 125 0 Tue, 10:15pm
               Collapse Yes, wrapped bodies laid out, as if on a bier... // Eleniel 383 1 Tue, 6:37pm
                   Meh. I don't see it. Eruvandi 224 0 Tue, 8:10pm
           Collapse I was shadowdog 351 1 Tue, 7:04pm
               3 bodies? (Spoiler) Kilidoescartwheels 276 0 Tue, 7:57pm
       Collapse These aren't coffins... TheHutt 295 3 Tue, 7:47pm
           Collapse Where is this clip from? adt100 202 1 Tue, 8:50pm
               WELL? there has to be SOME Exploration..of Erebor Bombadil 173 0 Tue, 9:27pm
           The clips from the trailer shadowdog 193 0 Tue, 9:14pm
       I mentioned it. Rickster 147 0 Tue, 10:03pm

  Collapse Too soon to ask but will you avoid all of review before showing? Wordofmask 392 16 Tue, 5:29pm Jump to last post in thread (by cats16)
       I probably will Ardamírë 235 0 Tue, 5:32pm
       For LOTR I devoured everything I could find, totally spoiled myself.... adt100 212 0 Tue, 5:46pm
       Collapse Yes, definitely dormouse 199 2 Tue, 6:03pm
           I agree with Dormouse! FoFo64 176 0 Tue, 6:08pm
           Ditto Avandel 114 0 Tue, 7:23pm
       Collapse I always try and always fail... Estel78 175 3 Tue, 6:10pm
           ^ This tsmith675 147 0 Tue, 6:29pm
           Avoiding these stuff is very hard thing to do these days Wordofmask 143 0 Tue, 6:37pm
           Dito. Arannir 89 0 Tue, 7:46pm
       I don't read reviews Name 118 0 Tue, 7:19pm
       Not only reviews Ham_Sammy 90 0 Tue, 7:52pm
       Collapse I did last time. I will this time too. Eruvandi 81 1 Tue, 8:04pm
         Watch out for premiers, tho Avandel 43 0 Tue, 10:55pm
       Collapse I'll do my best to avoid any spoilers Elarie 51 1 Tue, 10:13pm
           No... Queen of Erebor 45 0 Tue, 10:56pm
       I will, for sure. cats16 27 0 Wed, 5:09am

  Collapse Trailer screencaps Eruvandi 913 24 Tue, 5:06pm Jump to last post in thread (by sauget.diblosio)
       Ooh, nice! BlackFox 396 0 Tue, 5:13pm
       Collapse Ooh La La KeenObserver 382 1 Tue, 5:30pm
         *applause* Eruvandi 264 0 Tue, 7:09pm
       Thank you! Voronwë_the_Faithful 349 0 Tue, 5:59pm
       Collapse Nice! dormouse 346 6 Tue, 6:11pm
           Collapse Bard in the cart Ardamírë 337 5 Tue, 6:27pm
               Collapse Yes, apparently Eruvandi 297 2 Tue, 7:03pm
                   Collapse I'm sure it's something like that. Ardamírë 265 1 Tue, 7:14pm
                       Hard to say Eruvandi 216 0 Tue, 7:50pm
               Collapse At least his older daughter but... Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 187 1 Tue, 8:50pm
                   Nah Aitieuriskon 170 0 Tue, 9:06pm
       Collapse Thank you - one thing I noticed from these Loresilme 375 2 Tue, 6:27pm
           Yes, they are Elanor of Rohan 305 0 Tue, 7:00pm
           Good observation! Eruvandi 278 0 Tue, 7:10pm
       Thank you Anubis 294 0 Tue, 6:59pm
       Much obliged. Retro315 227 0 Tue, 7:44pm
       One nice symbol I noticed concerning Thranduil Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 209 0 Tue, 8:55pm
       Thanks, very nice! VeArkenstone 153 0 Tue, 9:53pm
     Collapse My monitor just spontaneously combusted Avandel 126 4 Wed, 12:57am
         Collapse *grabs fire extinguisher* Eruvandi 113 3 Wed, 1:59am
               Collapse The end of all things Avandel 82 2 Wed, 5:11am
                   Collapse Talking animals Eruvandi 43 1 Wed, 2:34pm
                       Smaug is a miracle re speech! Avandel 31 0 Wed, 4:04pm
       I love that shot of Gandalf riding the horse. sauget.diblosio 11 0 Thu, 6:39pm

  Collapse The REAL question now... Timdalf 772 10 Tue, 4:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by sycorax82)
       Collapse Interesting questions KeenObserver 401 1 Tue, 4:55pm
           I agree Eruvandi 219 0 Tue, 6:58pm
       Collapse Personally Glorfindela 318 1 Tue, 5:46pm
           I sincerely hope (and believe) PJ will not go all 'George Lucas' on us. // adt100 285 0 Tue, 5:49pm
       On the contrary Lindele 300 0 Tue, 5:52pm
       Collapse There are only two things I would change.. DaoinSidhe 311 2 Tue, 6:22pm
           Agreed! Lindele 225 0 Tue, 6:55pm
           Agree, bit I Aldo thought about "upgrading" the obviously bad CGI... xxxyyy 141 0 Tue, 9:09pm
       I hope that PJ changes nothing about LotR Noria 92 0 Tue, 10:50pm
       I would change lots about TTT and ROTK but I doubt this will happen sycorax82 65 0 Wed, 12:59am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 807 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.