Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 3 of 979 (351363 posts in 14685 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 979 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse On the Arkenstone... and other ramblings from the teapot dormouse 1164 61 May 16, 11:00am Jump to last post in thread (by Brethil)
       Alternate Scene. Otaku-sempai 973 0 May 16, 1:02pm
       Collapse I will be surprised if the Arkenstone is not buried with Thorin Voronwë_the_Faithful 937 2 May 16, 2:45pm
           GREAT POST dmouse... Bombadil 913 0 May 16, 3:31pm
           Yes... dormouse 653 0 May 17, 8:15am
       Great Post DM Michelle Johnston 887 0 May 16, 4:41pm
     Collapse Thoughts - LOL lots of them Avandel 816 3 May 16, 7:56pm
           Collapse Dain No I won't/Yes I will. Michelle Johnston 770 1 May 16, 10:01pm
               And Dain does continue to grow as leader oliphaunt 753 0 May 16, 10:52pm
           Agree! Glassary 472 0 May 17, 9:22pm
       Collapse Here's a simple answer Kilidoescartwheels 700 8 May 17, 3:48am
           Collapse There's another factor that makes Thorin's position ambiguous.... dormouse 648 2 May 17, 8:35am
               ABSOLUTELY Correctomundo..dm Bombadil 590 0 May 17, 11:47am
               Although Avandel 555 0 May 17, 3:59pm
           Collapse Either the Arkenstone drives the plot or it doesn't. Michelle Johnston 530 4 May 17, 6:22pm
               Collapse I'm intrigued.... dormouse 516 2 May 17, 7:38pm
                   Collapse Clarification Michelle Johnston 418 1 May 18, 6:29am
                       What? Dain was at AZANULBIZAR? Bombadil 373 0 May 18, 9:27am
               It can still drive the plot Kilidoescartwheels 154 0 May 18, 9:39pm
       Collapse Why I see no loose ends in the Arkenstone plot, and what really bothers me about it greenbalrog 483 31 May 17, 9:34pm
           Collapse The Arkenstone Otaku-sempai 433 3 May 18, 5:11am
               Well said Michelle Johnston 411 0 May 18, 6:47am
               Collapse Elves "pay homage" to the Dwarfs because they are afraid of them? greenbalrog 368 1 May 18, 10:12am
                   Well... Otaku-sempai 255 0 May 18, 2:28pm
           Collapse Great Post Michelle Johnston 411 16 May 18, 6:54am
               Collapse Yes, the Arkenstone plot seems complete, but the stone's own significance isn't well explained greenbalrog 287 1 May 18, 11:10am
                   Just to quickly clarify Michelle Johnston 246 0 May 18, 3:23pm
               Collapse Ring-like and Silmaril-like..... dormouse 264 13 May 18, 1:42pm
                   Collapse "Like" not "Is" Michelle Johnston 243 6 May 18, 3:04pm
                       Collapse Thanks for the reply, Michelle, but you've misunderstood me... dormouse 227 5 May 18, 3:52pm
                           Collapse "I have the Power!" Otaku-sempai 225 4 May 18, 4:05pm
                               Collapse No, not necessarily.... dormouse 214 3 May 18, 6:08pm
                                   Collapse Well, it was worth a shot. Otaku-sempai 205 2 May 18, 6:34pm
                                       Collapse Don't know, but if they did.... dormouse 200 1 May 18, 6:39pm
                                           That makes me wonder Otaku-sempai 198 0 May 18, 6:44pm
                   Collapse "The Jewels, the Stone, and the Ring, and the Making of Meaning" Voronwë_the_Faithful 199 5 May 18, 7:03pm
                       Collapse Thanks for this, Voronwe... dormouse 192 3 May 18, 7:13pm
                           Collapse It is, indeed Voronwë_the_Faithful 188 2 May 18, 7:30pm
                               Collapse Straight to my wishlist! dormouse 182 1 May 18, 8:00pm
                                   Coincidentally Voronwë_the_Faithful 168 0 May 18, 8:40pm
                       "It's chief function seems to be to reveal character". I'm cool with that. greenbalrog 161 0 May 18, 9:28pm
           Collapse Your question about the Elvenking's homage is a good one.... dormouse 400 9 May 18, 8:42am
               Thanks for the reply. However, Arkenstone's disproportionate significance remains unexplained greenbalrog 364 0 May 18, 10:42am
               Collapse But Avandel 229 5 May 18, 4:08pm
                   Collapse Ah, but the line is..... dormouse 211 4 May 18, 6:26pm
                       Collapse Hmmm- I stand corrected... Avandel 119 3 May 19, 7:22am
                           Collapse If you compare the TE version of that scene with the EE.... dormouse 113 2 May 19, 7:43am
                               Well, yes, plus Bumblingidiot 179 0 May 19, 2:17pm
                               Re Thranduil - oh yes! Avandel 140 0 May 20, 7:36am
               Collapse The Great Seal Hamfast Gamgee 144 1 May 18, 11:52pm
                   Nice one! dormouse 116 0 May 19, 7:22am
       The Arkenstone is the heart of the mountain and we have seen Mountainous Rock Giants come to life squiggle 285 0 May 18, 11:10am
       Collapse I'm enjoying this conversation! Riven Delve 134 9 May 20, 11:49am
           Collapse Yes. After all... Silverlode 131 2 May 20, 12:17pm
               Collapse This also hadn't occurred to me.... dormouse 104 1 May 20, 1:50pm
                   Yep, I think "state visit" is it exactly. Silverlode 78 0 May 20, 11:44pm
           Collapse Narrative bias - excellent point Brethil 122 4 May 20, 12:49pm
               Collapse "All great Stories deserve SOME embellishment.." Bombadil 112 1 May 20, 1:30pm
                   A really good point there, Bom. Brethil 70 0 May 21, 1:14am
               Collapse Yes - I like your idea of... dormouse 105 1 May 20, 1:54pm
                 Yes - I think it changed Bilbo forever. As it was meant to. Brethil 71 0 May 21, 1:16am
           Oh - good point.... dormouse 110 0 May 20, 1:39pm

  Collapse DAIN IRONFOOT (Soundtrack Disc 2. Track 10) grimbeorn15 630 7 May 15, 11:04pm Jump to last post in thread (by Roheryn1)
       Collapse I think you may have a point... dormouse 479 1 May 16, 9:03am
           Ironfoot Roheryn1 74 0 May 20, 5:18pm
       It was most likely intended as a credits suite Shagrat 475 0 May 16, 9:10am
       The Dain theme sounds way too fast for a funeral, the whole of it... Bofur01 469 0 May 16, 9:16am
       I'm not so sure SafeUnderHill 464 0 May 16, 9:35am
       Collapse I love Dain but I was dissapointed that he didnt have an actually Iron foot Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 198 1 May 18, 8:00am
           Isaac...IRON HILLS might imply something? Bombadil 180 0 May 18, 10:09am

  Collapse There is something about Bilbo´s farewell at Erebor that I dont totally buy Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 948 11 May 15, 8:25pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elarie)
       Collapse funeral Mooseboy018 899 6 May 15, 8:27pm
           Collapse Iin the movie? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 897 2 May 15, 8:30pm
               Collapse Gandalf's speech Mooseboy018 834 1 May 15, 9:27pm
                   Good :) Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 827 0 May 15, 9:33pm
           Collapse AGREED...this Goodbye is AFTER... Bombadil 890 2 May 15, 8:34pm
               Collapse 10 minutes? grimbeorn15 787 1 May 15, 10:55pm
                   ESTIMATE w/ the 30-40 minutes YET to Come.. Bombadil 778 0 May 15, 11:09pm
       there will be amazing things happening in the movie mirkwoodwanderer 705 0 May 16, 3:46am
       I doubt that it is Spring. Otaku-sempai 574 0 May 16, 1:10pm
       Collapse You can't go by movie time Kilidoescartwheels 433 1 May 17, 2:47am
           Agree Elarie 348 0 May 17, 11:46am

  Collapse PJ Competing with Himself? Bombadil 1295 38 May 15, 1:21pm Jump to last post in thread (by glor)
       Disagreements are inevitable Otaku-sempai 1153 0 May 15, 2:04pm
       Collapse PJ tried to make The Hobbit something that it wasn't... Morthoron 1148 18 May 15, 2:25pm
           Collapse Tell me Smaug the iron 1140 2 May 15, 2:32pm
               Indeed Shagrat 1127 0 May 15, 2:41pm
               Actually Bishop 1106 0 May 15, 3:06pm
           Collapse Well that is incorrect Kilidoescartwheels 1099 13 May 15, 3:14pm
               Collapse I believe you are missing the point... Morthoron 999 12 May 15, 5:26pm
                   only in bag end is Gandalf in Green screen. Smaug the iron 984 0 May 15, 5:36pm
                   Collapse I can't agree with that Kilidoescartwheels 916 10 May 15, 7:14pm
                       Collapse Agree glor 790 9 May 15, 11:08pm
                           Collapse Disagree Goldeneye 348 7 May 17, 3:17am
                               Collapse WETA said themselves... Bofur01 321 6 May 17, 8:32am
                                   Like Bofur01, Bomby will "side" with WETA Bombadil 298 0 May 17, 11:18am
                                   Collapse Link? Goldeneye 259 4 May 17, 3:16pm
                                       Collapse I'm interested to know redgiraffe 209 3 May 17, 11:12pm
                                           Collapse 3D/48fps Goldeneye 196 1 May 18, 12:14am
                                               If you want to call it a "Grand Experiment" Bombadil 157 0 May 18, 9:59am
                                           Also glor 100 0 May 19, 6:26pm
                           expenses redgiraffe 209 0 May 17, 10:58pm
           CGI or not Dipling 778 0 May 15, 11:28pm
       Collapse my opinion... nymmerod 1079 5 May 15, 3:29pm
           Collapse How come when people don't like the film Bishop 1064 4 May 15, 3:51pm
               Collapse Yes and no Kilidoescartwheels 891 3 May 15, 7:34pm
                   Collapse Ok, you're not a huge fan of the book... Salmacis81 827 2 May 15, 9:22pm
                       Collapse Not trying to pick a fight here, but Kilidoescartwheels 588 1 May 16, 1:27pm
                           Gollum>Vision>Azog>Bolg>Ultron for me. Bofur01 416 0 May 16, 1:48pm
       Collapse Well Thrain II 1026 9 May 15, 4:43pm
           Collapse good post Bishop 977 3 May 15, 5:48pm
               HERE is a Question about the November RELEASE? Bombadil 940 0 May 15, 6:25pm
               Collapse And in addition to PJ trying to capture a similar scope for The Hobbit... Salmacis81 928 1 May 15, 6:45pm
                   One of my main gripes redgiraffe 213 0 May 17, 10:41pm
           Collapse PJ as director had to make prequels to his own films but Michelle Johnston 690 4 May 16, 6:29am
               ALWAYS VERY, THOUGHTFUL Posts..MJ Bombadil 651 0 May 16, 7:55am
               Collapse Seriously? You'd cut them to NINE??? Kilidoescartwheels 428 2 May 16, 1:36pm
                 Collapse Maybe there is another Angle to SIT BACK Bombadil 410 1 May 16, 2:45pm
                     EXTRA CREDIT goes ALL around TO.. Bombadil 360 0 May 17, 1:36am
       Collapse I agree! Hobbity Hobbit 753 1 May 16, 1:18am
         VERY Thoughtful Response..Important points. Bombadil 693 0 May 16, 6:00am

  Collapse When Thorin is saying Smaug the iron 634 9 May 15, 12:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse Fili // BlackFox 550 5 May 15, 12:24pm
           Who?? AshNazg 551 0 May 15, 12:42pm
           Collapse Thank you Smaug the iron 544 3 May 15, 12:59pm
               I'm sure it's Fili... dormouse 506 0 May 15, 2:07pm
               Collapse Pretty sure it's Fili Kilidoescartwheels 387 1 May 15, 7:51pm
                   Ditto Avandel 312 0 May 16, 2:35am
       Collapse so sad Mooseboy018 446 2 May 15, 5:22pm
           Collapse What do you mean? Smaug the iron 437 1 May 15, 5:27pm
               The same thing I meant with "who??" AshNazg 416 0 May 15, 6:31pm

  Collapse The ringwraith battle NoelGallagher 1021 17 May 14, 6:37pm Jump to last post in thread (by Radagast-Aiwendil)
       I like it. Smaug the iron 943 0 May 14, 6:41pm
       I liked it a lot! Arthael 922 0 May 14, 7:00pm
       Collapse For me... Thrain II 923 3 May 14, 7:02pm
         Collapse Here is a Question about Elrond.. Bombadil 869 2 May 14, 8:00pm
               Collapse But surely...... dormouse 762 1 May 14, 10:53pm
                   LOOK closely..SHE Bombadil 760 0 May 14, 11:00pm
       Was great! The only problem for me ... greenbalrog 843 0 May 14, 8:51pm
       Well, since you asked... Elarie 837 0 May 14, 8:56pm
       Collapse Oposite for me CathrineB 833 1 May 14, 9:00pm
           It's funny because it felt very real to me greenbalrog 828 0 May 14, 9:10pm
       Loved it! Avnar 774 0 May 14, 10:28pm
       Loved the whole scene! Silmaril 633 0 May 15, 7:36am
       Really? I heard mostly positive reviews of the Dol Guldur scenes.... adt100 535 0 May 15, 2:22pm
       Collapse I only wish that it was longer. Imladris18 462 1 May 15, 7:59pm
           everybody was possitive mirkwoodwanderer 399 0 May 16, 3:51am
       what i think redgiraffe 224 0 May 17, 10:19pm
       For the most part I loved it Radagast-Aiwendil 174 0 May 18, 3:05pm

  Collapse Weapeons Smaug the iron 430 5 May 14, 6:19pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Mine is Thrain II 376 0 May 14, 6:58pm
       Orchrist will be hard to beat Kilidoescartwheels 339 0 May 14, 8:20pm
       for me.. grinman 308 0 May 14, 9:59pm
       Does Smaug count? lionoferebor 254 0 May 15, 3:49am
       I'm... arithmancer 45 0 May 19, 4:59pm

  Collapse Been Thinking about this Period of Editing? Bombadil 564 1 May 14, 11:16am Jump to last post in thread (by jschomburg)
       Hope they have a nice tribute to Andrew on the Extras. jschomburg 472 0 May 14, 2:06pm

  Collapse Physics of The Hobbit: Legolas "Defying Gravity" DwellerInDale 1008 30 May 14, 6:45am Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Collapse Well... CathrineB 925 1 May 14, 7:19am
           My opinion priell3 746 0 May 14, 2:09pm
       Collapse Thanks for this, DwellerInDale.... dormouse 885 3 May 14, 8:55am
           Collapse D.I.D Rules! Bombadil 881 2 May 14, 9:10am
               Collapse elvish superhuman qualities Fimbulfambi 837 1 May 14, 11:06am
                 Well, have you EVER watched Gymnastics? Bombadil 826 0 May 14, 11:47am
       Collapse Interesting post, thanks! Thrain II 806 1 May 14, 12:23pm
           I'd argue that the over-the-top scenes are why he seems to have an over-the-top "presence," Imladris18 718 0 May 14, 2:47pm
       Collapse Actually, the falling tower presents a big issue as well. Eruonen 756 1 May 14, 2:04pm
           I agree priell3 741 0 May 14, 2:13pm
       I agree with it technically being *physically* feasible: Imladris18 711 0 May 14, 3:06pm
       Collapse Oh boy Goldeneye 687 6 May 14, 3:26pm
           Collapse No no no no no, do you know how bridges work? Bofur01 668 4 May 14, 3:57pm
               Collapse Rather that STEEP POSTS with Opinions? Bombadil 647 1 May 14, 4:09pm
                 "Physics BE DARNED...FULL SPEED AHEAD..Captain PJ"// Bombadil 633 0 May 14, 4:18pm
               There is no suspension with the tower. It should have crumbled....then again, Eruonen 631 0 May 14, 4:29pm
               no Goldeneye 615 0 May 14, 4:43pm
           As a huge Legolas fan, I tend to agree. Imladris18 655 0 May 14, 4:06pm
       Collapse Thanks for this. Arannir 613 9 May 14, 4:51pm
           Collapse The way I judge these moments was based on my feeling in the theater Eruonen 599 4 May 14, 4:59pm
               Collapse Me too CathrineB 580 2 May 14, 5:23pm
                   Collapse They don´t forget it Smaug the iron 575 1 May 14, 5:32pm
                       lol CathrineB 566 0 May 14, 5:34pm
               agree sevilodorf 228 0 May 15, 1:43am
           Collapse This is a common problem for directors Bishop 485 3 May 14, 9:35pm
               Collapse Great definition ;) Ilmatar 261 1 May 14, 11:00pm
                   Thanks! Bishop 253 0 May 14, 11:08pm
               Exactly Goldeneye 249 0 May 14, 11:31pm
       Collapse Felt Like a Video Game Terrible Tony 144 1 May 15, 7:19pm
           Nice Eruonen 115 0 May 15, 11:05pm

  Collapse Billy Boyd-The Last Goodbye (Live) at a Barnes and Noble Hobbity Hobbit 565 10 May 14, 1:28am Jump to last post in thread (by Silmaril)
       Great! Thrain II 495 0 May 14, 2:00am
       Collapse A great song that IMO transcends the film (and trilogy) that it was written for... Aragorn the Elfstone 491 2 May 14, 2:29am
           Collapse Agreed - it's beautiful. // dormouse 416 1 May 14, 9:02am
               Some Singers go though Life Bombadil 418 0 May 14, 9:18am
       Bless... Greenwood Hobbit 394 0 May 14, 11:02am
       Thanks for this Brethil 377 0 May 14, 12:22pm
       Thanks for sharing // priell3 341 0 May 14, 2:11pm
       His voice is like the streams and woodlands he sings about Loresilme 287 0 May 14, 8:39pm
       Beautiful greenbalrog 277 0 May 14, 9:05pm
       Thank you! Best song! Silmaril 215 0 May 15, 7:39am

Collapse Legolas SAVED Thorin ? Bombadil 729 8 May 12, 10:58am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Yes he did.... dormouse 551 2 May 12, 7:28pm
           YOU are Correct! Forgot about that ONE!/// Bombadil 535 0 May 12, 7:31pm
           Nice one greenbalrog 518 0 May 12, 8:49pm
       Collapse Also... arithmancer 479 4 May 12, 11:16pm
           Collapse THAT was REALLY CUTE..Leggyzzz Bombadil 432 3 May 13, 5:01am
               Collapse One of my favorite Leggy/arrows moments... Elarie 363 2 May 13, 1:55pm
                 Collapse Didn't Leggy need to Kill.. Bombadil 195 1 May 15, 7:29am
                       WHY didn't Thranndy say "Namarie" to his son.?// Bombadil 159 0 May 15, 8:37pm

  Collapse A comparison of Peter Jackson's approach between LOTR and The Hobbit Eruonen 1536 30 May 12, 3:25am Jump to last post in thread (by elostirion74)
       Collapse He also said with each LOTR draft they got closer and closer to JRRT...... Eruonen 1421 10 May 12, 3:29am
           Collapse PJ also says his speech to the design crew for the LOTR was to think they Eruonen 1411 1 May 12, 3:48am
             Lots of VALID Questions there...& Bombadil 1316 0 May 12, 8:12am
           Collapse Well, I don't think you have to look very far to explain.... dormouse 1299 7 May 12, 9:28am
               Collapse Yes, I agree, the task of shooting the central tale Eruonen 1190 6 May 12, 1:56pm
                   Collapse Bom izzzz Personally REALLY excited to Explore Bombadil 1155 3 May 12, 2:41pm
                       Collapse At some point, you are looking for something "soft" be it a chair, bed, etc. Eruonen 1154 2 May 12, 2:49pm
                           Collapse That was my reaction to Erebor... dormouse 1055 1 May 12, 6:34pm
                               Dwarf culture must be survival of the fittest! Eruonen 1011 0 May 12, 7:48pm
                   Collapse There's also the medium to consider Kilidoescartwheels 958 1 May 12, 10:03pm
                       Oh, I don't disagree at all. I was curious as to how PJ mentally handled both Eruonen 923 0 May 13, 12:03am
       Collapse Congratulations For Raising The Bonus Material Michelle Johnston 846 17 May 13, 6:58am
           Very well said! .... adt100 740 0 May 13, 4:35pm
           Collapse If this is true... Thrain II 653 1 May 13, 9:07pm
               Yeah really... Salmacis81 414 0 May 14, 8:43pm
         Collapse GREAT SUMMARY, MJ! Bombadil 643 13 May 13, 9:32pm
               Collapse Not true. Bumblingidiot 602 12 May 13, 11:00pm
                   Collapse Only to the "core". Pandallo 580 11 May 14, 12:23am
                       Um, no... Thrain II 563 0 May 14, 2:03am
                       Collapse AUJ reviews Goldeneye 471 9 May 14, 3:32pm
                           Collapse My memory thinking back... moreorless 341 8 May 15, 6:17am
                             Collapse Agreed & many reviewers DIDN"T know the Book Bombadil 327 7 May 15, 7:38am
                                   Collapse To be fair, these are movies. Otaku-sempai 295 6 May 15, 2:12pm
                                       Collapse Well, "failure" is a bit strong and depends on what aspect you are referring too. Eruonen 284 5 May 15, 2:22pm
                                           Collapse I thought that I was fairly clear. Otaku-sempai 138 4 May 15, 2:28pm
                                               Collapse But is that the case? Many who saw the films never the read the book. Eruonen 135 3 May 15, 2:33pm
                                                   Collapse That is why my statement is (deliberately) debatable. Otaku-sempai 130 2 May 15, 2:47pm
                                                       Collapse Agree, at the least, showing the crowning of the new King would have been fitting.. Eruonen 126 1 May 15, 3:01pm
                                                           King Dain Otaku-sempai 119 0 May 15, 3:35pm
       interesting questions! elostirion74 43 0 May 18, 8:37pm

  Collapse Was Bofur Left in Lake-town On Purpose? News from Bree 619 8 May 11, 9:01pm Jump to last post in thread (by marary)
       Fun theory Bishop 564 0 May 12, 3:37am
       I suspected an additional DOS EE scene Legolas_Shoehorn 503 0 May 12, 7:54am
       Collapse This was... CathrineB 492 2 May 12, 8:41am
           This Shagrat 487 0 May 12, 8:59am
           Bom agrees w/ CB.. Bombadil 485 0 May 12, 9:09am
       yup lonelymountainhermit 326 0 May 13, 8:55am
       Collapse I would have to say, "no". Otaku-sempai 286 1 May 13, 2:08pm
           Straightforward Thorin marary 231 0 May 13, 9:58pm

  Collapse my problem with the battle Mooseboy018 1612 45 May 10, 11:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Michelle Johnston)
       YES! CathrineB 1445 0 May 11, 12:43am
       Collapse There are a lot of expectations hanging on the EE // AshNazg 1423 3 May 11, 1:31am
           Collapse Yes, there is a lot hanging on the EE... lionoferebor 1420 2 May 11, 1:54am
               Collapse Unfortunately, it cannot cover all of our wishes, but hopefully it will Eruonen 1415 1 May 11, 2:08am
                   expectations Mooseboy018 1404 0 May 11, 2:43am
       Yeah, me too! Thrain II 1225 0 May 11, 12:59pm
       Hm...not really Kilidoescartwheels 1186 0 May 11, 2:01pm
       I don't think they did abandon the momentum..... dormouse 1159 0 May 11, 3:02pm
       Collapse The Problematic Climax of 'The Battle of the Five Armies' Arandir 1111 36 May 11, 5:21pm
           Great stuff! Thrain II 1057 0 May 11, 6:20pm
           Oh wow! CathrineB 1040 0 May 11, 6:49pm
           Nice writing Avandel 955 0 May 11, 9:13pm
           Collapse Agree with so many points// sevilodorf 826 1 May 12, 12:34pm
               SSOoo..Time & work went into your BLOG Bombadil 794 0 May 12, 2:50pm
           Collapse Yes, yes, and YES!! RosieLass 796 28 May 12, 3:36pm
               Collapse Indeed CathrineB 699 27 May 12, 8:38pm
                   Collapse Exactly.... the whole the DVD and the extra scenes sevilodorf 633 26 May 13, 4:15am
                       Collapse Rip off? dormouse 603 24 May 13, 8:33am
                           Collapse I can't blame people for feeling this way Bishop 452 23 May 14, 2:43am
                               Collapse I think you're making two very big assumptions there... dormouse 419 22 May 14, 8:38am
                                 Bomby agrees with dormouse... Bombadil 407 0 May 14, 8:59am
                                   Collapse There is a subjective element here. Otaku-sempai 395 18 May 14, 1:04pm
                                       Collapse Oh yes, it's certainly subjective ... dormouse 373 13 May 14, 2:06pm
                                           Collapse Loose Ends Otaku-sempai 333 3 May 14, 3:49pm
                                               Collapse Well, once again... dormouse 317 2 May 14, 4:12pm
                                                   Collapse Okay Otaku-sempai 315 1 May 14, 4:32pm
                                                       Sir Peter's vision and priorities now. Michelle Johnston 301 0 May 14, 5:30pm
                                           Collapse Nice post (again) Avandel 265 7 May 14, 11:40pm
                                               Collapse I know Thrain II 254 6 May 15, 1:07am
                                                 Collapse LOL I can't help it Avandel 224 5 May 15, 5:35am
                                                       Collapse Fili Mooseboy018 213 1 May 15, 6:23am
                                                         Think you may be right though hard to say re Fili Avandel 144 0 May 15, 4:37pm
                                                       Collapse Dieing and Whinging though not in that order ! Michelle Johnston 202 2 May 15, 10:20am
                                                           Collapse Ah, but what an acorn it was! dormouse 171 1 May 15, 2:06pm
                                                               Coherence Within the Film Is Just Fine By Me. Michelle Johnston 128 0 May 15, 6:15pm
                                           Well we can certainly agree to disagree Bishop 240 0 May 15, 3:22am
                                       Collapse Ther are many loose ends in The Lord of the Rings Smaug the iron 334 3 May 14, 3:40pm
                                           Collapse All resolved in the book. Otaku-sempai 326 2 May 14, 3:59pm
                                               Collapse Yes but Smaug the iron 318 1 May 14, 4:31pm
                                                   Yes, all that would have been nice. Otaku-sempai 312 0 May 14, 4:34pm
                                   Collapse Personal Verses Geo Political Michelle Johnston 392 1 May 14, 1:28pm
                                       Yes... dormouse 354 0 May 14, 2:22pm
                       Director's Cut? Otaku-sempai 550 0 May 13, 2:17pm
           Collapse Glad I'm not the only one! Arandir 742 1 May 12, 5:38pm
               Would you BET on a MARATHON? Bombadil 682 0 May 12, 10:18pm

  Collapse Why did Thorin tell Fili that someday Fili would be king? Lio 1052 21 May 10, 7:01pm Jump to last post in thread (by Ilmatar)
       Dwarves! marary 978 0 May 10, 7:15pm
       book/science answer [:)] DisDwarfWoman 922 0 May 10, 8:28pm
       Because he is a friendly guy mirkwoodwanderer 869 0 May 10, 9:38pm
       Collapse Book Thorin was probably too old Kilidoescartwheels 642 10 May 11, 7:11pm
           Collapse dwarf women marary 628 9 May 11, 7:52pm
               Collapse Fluctuations Otaku-sempai 616 6 May 11, 7:57pm
                   Collapse Good point! But where did the women go? marary 612 4 May 11, 8:00pm
                       A seeming contradiction. Otaku-sempai 591 0 May 11, 8:35pm
                       Collapse There was another thread recently Kilidoescartwheels 575 2 May 11, 9:07pm
                           Collapse That would make sense marary 569 1 May 11, 9:21pm
                               Dain's family Otaku-sempai 553 0 May 11, 10:02pm
                   Exactly! Kilidoescartwheels 579 0 May 11, 9:00pm
               Collapse Thoughts from the Dwarrow Scholar Ilmatar 488 1 May 12, 7:20am
                 Well, Bombur was a Father..What? 13 times!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!// Bombadil 458 0 May 12, 9:53am
       Collapse Or it could just be.... dormouse 464 3 May 12, 10:29am
           Collapse AT the Time...No ONE knew what Bombadil 451 2 May 12, 11:17am
               Collapse When Gandalf does INDEED show up? Bombadil 443 1 May 12, 11:38am
                   Taking sides... and heirs apparent/presumptive Ilmatar 432 0 May 12, 12:59pm
       Collapse How would Fili have reacted if Thorin had a son? Elarie 447 2 May 12, 11:35am
           Collapse Yes! CathrineB 447 1 May 12, 11:49am
               Perhaps Balin had similar issues for going to Moria Elarie 429 0 May 12, 12:55pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 979 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.