Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 3 of 991 (354775 posts in 14857 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 991 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Are Tom, Bert, and William brothers? boldog 362 3 Jul 16, 10:00am Jump to last post in thread (by Gandalf the Green)
       I never had the impresison that they were brothers. Otaku-sempai 349 0 Jul 16, 10:09am
       GOOD THINKING...PJ Bombadil 315 0 Jul 16, 12:26pm
       Y Gandalf the Green 155 0 Jul 17, 7:05pm

  Collapse Guillermo still hasn't seen The Hobbit movies Junesong 1066 19 Jul 16, 4:21am Jump to last post in thread (by Kangi Ska)
       *Shrug* Avandel 976 0 Jul 16, 6:20am
       Thanks for posting this! Silmaril 955 0 Jul 16, 6:37am
       To be honest I'm very glad he didn't get involved with The Hobbit in the end emre43 950 0 Jul 16, 6:40am
       As Avandel said ... Legolas_Shoehorn 931 0 Jul 16, 7:14am
       Collapse I know... CathrineB 889 1 Jul 16, 8:48am
           Yes Avandel 755 0 Jul 16, 3:14pm
       Collapse Well.... dormouse 878 7 Jul 16, 9:31am
           Collapse Frankly... BalrogTrainer 848 6 Jul 16, 10:46am
               Well.... Avandel 754 0 Jul 16, 3:21pm
               Collapse I believe that GT left because Kangi Ska 90 4 Sun, 10:06pm
                   Collapse (psst...Kangi Ska, Lissuin 42 1 Tue, 10:49pm
                       Thanks Kangi Ska 13 0 11:45am
                   Collapse Hi, Kangi! Otaku-sempai 37 1 Tue, 11:30pm
                       I check the boards frequently and will contribute when I have something to say. Kangi Ska 14 0 11:43am
       Collapse I have my doubts... Dcole4 720 3 Jul 16, 4:32pm
           Collapse But is it helpful to voice that kind of suggestion.... dormouse 686 1 Jul 16, 6:11pm
               Exactly glor 552 0 Jul 17, 1:33am
           I'd be happy to see a GDT Hobbit - now..... Avandel 641 0 Jul 16, 7:33pm
       And probably best to keep it that way. Crunchable Birdses 406 0 Jul 17, 10:54pm

  Collapse Thorin and Thranduil...not so different after all lionoferebor 495 8 Jul 15, 8:40pm Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse It's the way of Kings? Kilidoescartwheels 461 6 Jul 15, 9:05pm
           Collapse Huh? Avandel 440 5 Jul 15, 9:56pm
               Collapse "Take me to the river... Kilidoescartwheels 423 3 Jul 15, 10:25pm
                   Collapse *grins* - and there's more! Avandel 254 2 Jul 16, 10:52pm
                       Collapse You know what's really sad? Kilidoescartwheels 247 1 Jul 16, 11:50pm
                         There, there..... Avandel 195 0 Jul 17, 4:00pm
               That is awesome! Elarie 323 0 Jul 16, 11:38am
       And the care of their people Avandel 437 0 Jul 15, 9:59pm

  Collapse Help me tie down the difference between LOTR and Hobbit HelmHammerHand 973 17 Jul 15, 8:01am Jump to last post in thread (by Bernhardina)
       Collapse Nja CathrineB 893 7 Jul 15, 9:37am
           Collapse A few things... Dcole4 681 6 Jul 15, 7:35pm
               Collapse This is IMO beautifully said.... Avandel 661 1 Jul 15, 7:55pm
                   I'm still not sure... Pandallo 640 0 Jul 15, 8:25pm
               Collapse THIS THIS THIS Mooseboy018 558 3 Jul 16, 1:33am
                   Collapse The book. Smaug the iron 496 2 Jul 16, 8:42am
                       Collapse You're missing the point. Mooseboy018 422 1 Jul 16, 7:54pm
                           I understand it from a film point of you Smaug the iron 410 0 Jul 16, 9:02pm
       Sorry, can't help you much, I get the same feeling from both of them... dormouse 795 0 Jul 15, 2:02pm
       Collapse Hmmmmm Avandel 677 1 Jul 15, 7:35pm
           "The base material of the films is different and targeted to a different audience" Elizabeth 589 0 Jul 15, 10:40pm
       Collapse I'm always so puzzled by this Kilidoescartwheels 627 1 Jul 15, 8:59pm
           There was that one moment in the Moria Milieuterrien 589 0 Jul 15, 10:36pm
       A journey like life itself simplyaven 564 0 Jul 16, 1:05am
       The difference? Avnar 400 0 Jul 16, 9:50pm
       I prefer the lighter less gritty feel of the hobbit movies... Lindelorne 128 0 Jul 21, 11:23am
       They are different in some ways Bernhardina 28 0 Tue, 1:59pm

  Collapse Aesthetic Differences from LOTR ??? Oscarilbo 798 10 Jul 14, 8:47pm Jump to last post in thread (by BalrogTrainer)
       They should've done it like LOTR, like PJ originally said... Gandalf the Green 715 0 Jul 14, 10:15pm
       Collapse For many, many years people thought there was no way to film ME, Spriggan 710 8 Jul 14, 10:27pm
           Collapse I really disagree with this Bishop 636 4 Jul 15, 1:31am
               Collapse I am burning... ecthelionsbeard 595 1 Jul 15, 4:14am
                   Right?! Bishop 591 0 Jul 15, 4:25am
               I'm not sure that would leap out to me as an example someone recreating an aesthetic Spriggan 525 0 Jul 15, 8:46am
               Agreed. BalrogTrainer 292 0 Jul 16, 10:32am
           Collapse No. Gandalf the Green 419 2 Jul 15, 5:37pm
               More mature filming on more immature book material Milieuterrien 409 0 Jul 15, 6:30pm
               I'm not sure if you mistook my point. Spriggan 354 0 Jul 15, 9:54pm

  Collapse Mysterious theme.... DainPig 946 12 Jul 14, 12:46am Jump to last post in thread (by FrogmortonJustice65)
       Collapse I love this "theme" Earl 867 1 Jul 14, 4:11am
           . SafeUnderHill 575 0 Jul 14, 5:20pm
       Collapse From what I can tell... Bofur01 748 2 Jul 14, 9:21am
           Maybe Shagrat 703 0 Jul 14, 11:47am
           what do you mean by "Map music"? FrogmortonJustice65 58 0 Jul 24, 1:56am
       From what I've gathered (mainly from what Doug Adams has said online) SafeUnderHill 574 0 Jul 14, 5:26pm
       Dwarves Doug Adams 486 0 Jul 14, 9:59pm
       Collapse Now that we're talking about mysterious themes Skaan 374 4 Jul 15, 4:57pm
           Collapse Yes! SafeUnderHill 360 2 Jul 15, 5:39pm
               Collapse Thanks! Skaan 328 1 Jul 15, 8:23pm
                   I'm afraid SafeUnderHill 309 0 Jul 15, 9:31pm
           This too sounds very Gollum's-themey to my ears Earl 293 0 Jul 16, 12:10am

  Collapse Billy Boyd as Bilbo Baggins DainPig 998 16 Jul 12, 6:24pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kelly of Water's Edge)
       if there hadnt been the Lotr trilogy before. .. NoelGallagher 925 0 Jul 12, 6:57pm
       Billy Boyd Otaku-sempai 867 0 Jul 12, 9:03pm
       I think you've answered yourself, really.... dormouse 834 0 Jul 12, 10:41pm
       No Glorfindela 819 0 Jul 12, 11:19pm
       Collapse What on earth for??? Kilidoescartwheels 778 3 Jul 13, 3:19am
           Collapse Well, don't think BillyB has the Range Bombadil 700 2 Jul 13, 11:55am
               Collapse Yes... smtfhw 364 1 Jul 15, 6:40am
                   Nose twitches ... Roheryn1 327 0 Jul 15, 6:33pm
       Bilbo is an irascible character when provoked Bumblingidiot 682 0 Jul 13, 1:44pm
       Collapse Frankly... Darkstone 606 1 Jul 13, 8:12pm
           Possibly Glorfindela 565 0 Jul 13, 10:42pm
       Collapse merry balbo biggins 553 3 Jul 13, 11:22pm
           Collapse Dominic Monaghan Otaku-sempai 545 2 Jul 14, 12:04am
               Collapse Really? Glorfindela 399 1 Jul 14, 11:41pm
                   In all fairness Kelly of Water's Edge 226 0 Jul 17, 7:26pm
       It's funny shadow0421 476 0 Jul 14, 10:37am

  Collapse A Baggins Duo? Weed 654 9 Jul 12, 3:18am Jump to last post in thread (by Bumblingidiot)
       Collapse No Mooseboy018 619 3 Jul 12, 3:49am
           Collapse Sidekick! Weed 614 2 Jul 12, 3:54am
               Bilbo don't need of a side kick DainPig 601 0 Jul 12, 4:30am
               He already has one Kilidoescartwheels 375 0 Jul 13, 3:21am
     No, simply no DainPig 605 0 Jul 12, 4:16am
       Collapse But you're talking about a completely different story... dormouse 569 2 Jul 12, 7:43am
           Collapse Obvious joke is obvious. Bofur01 537 1 Jul 12, 9:59am
               Do you mean.... dormouse 523 0 Jul 12, 10:41am
       And they should drive an Aston Martin - like James Bond. Bumblingidiot 307 0 Jul 13, 1:23pm

  Collapse Has WB/NL commented about the future of the 'franchise?' frodolives 1016 11 Jul 12, 12:01am Jump to last post in thread (by Cirashala)
       Collapse No plans that we know of... Otaku-sempai 892 5 Jul 12, 5:27am
           Collapse Considering... BalrogTrainer 279 4 Jul 16, 9:06am
               Collapse Honestly... Otaku-sempai 274 3 Jul 16, 9:28am
                   Collapse I doubt... BalrogTrainer 269 2 Jul 16, 10:43am
                       Possibly... Otaku-sempai 257 0 Jul 16, 1:53pm
                       He also said he would've reprised his role in The Hobbit if his inclusion "made sense." Imladris18 239 0 Jul 16, 4:07pm
       Collapse I would love to see Cirashala 53 4 Tue, 5:25am
           Collapse The War of the Dwarves and Orcs Otaku-sempai 40 1 Tue, 1:34pm
               I know Cirashala 33 0 Tue, 10:03pm
           Collapse Aragorn and Arwen Otaku-sempai 25 1 Tue, 10:24pm
               I like it Cirashala 20 0 Tue, 11:14pm

  Collapse Renaming the movies DainPig 1034 19 Jul 11, 12:00am Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Collapse good titles Mooseboy018 953 2 Jul 11, 12:19am
           Collapse And it can change by country DainPig 939 1 Jul 11, 12:30am
               So do the USA and Great Britain...// arithmancer 107 0 Jul 19, 5:29pm
       Collapse My choice would be Glorfindela 818 8 Jul 11, 10:21am
           Collapse Does it make sense, Precious? Glorfindela 478 7 Jul 12, 4:38pm
               Hobbit Grammar marary 457 0 Jul 12, 6:12pm
               Collapse Um... weeell.... dormouse 448 5 Jul 12, 6:47pm
                   Collapse Ah, yes, but Glorfindela 413 3 Jul 12, 11:27pm
                       Collapse Ah but I can.... dormouse 353 2 Jul 13, 11:06am
                           Collapse Well, all I can say is: Glorfindela 346 1 Jul 13, 11:20am
                               WELL, dmouse YOU got a Cameo TOO! Bombadil 340 0 Jul 13, 12:19pm
                   You're right, DM... Eleniel 379 0 Jul 13, 6:26am
       My names... Gandalf the Green 812 0 Jul 11, 10:24am
       Collapse My suggestions TheHutt 741 1 Jul 11, 2:50pm
           *Snort* marary 719 0 Jul 11, 3:36pm
       Collapse Movie? Movie? They're gonna make a movie? Goodie goodie Bracegirdle 685 1 Jul 11, 5:07pm
           Fantastic! Merovech 632 0 Jul 11, 7:57pm
     IMO titles of PRIIMARY FOCUS Avandel 596 0 Jul 11, 9:55pm
       Hmmmmm.... Darkstone 284 0 Jul 13, 8:07pm

  Collapse The Old Tapestry lionoferebor 1110 26 Jul 10, 10:57pm Jump to last post in thread (by arithmancer)
       Collapse The Old Tapestry DainPig 1028 2 Jul 10, 11:19pm
           Collapse I'd agree! Avandel 994 1 Jul 11, 12:31am
             PJ DOES, give you some of the answers Bombadil 881 0 Jul 11, 10:19am
       Collapse Origin in Esgaroth? Otaku-sempai 862 1 Jul 11, 12:43pm
         Thang you Berry Buch! O-S// Bombadil 757 0 Jul 12, 12:08am
       Collapse Tapestry and prophecy Ilmatar 714 20 Jul 12, 11:26am
           Collapse Well... Otaku-sempai 678 2 Jul 12, 3:23pm
               Collapse But then again... Ilmatar 669 1 Jul 12, 4:03pm
                   Fair point. Otaku-sempai 658 0 Jul 12, 4:27pm
         Collapse oooh - this is all fascinating IMO - thanks for posting and to Otaku-sempai too Avandel 639 3 Jul 12, 7:26pm
               Collapse Some random thoughts :) Ilmatar 603 2 Jul 12, 9:07pm
                 Collapse IMO this is great stuff Avandel 573 1 Jul 12, 11:10pm
                       Cultural exchange Ilmatar 519 0 Jul 13, 7:33am
           Collapse Very interesting Kim 617 3 Jul 12, 8:15pm
               Collapse Even more questions... ;) Ilmatar 601 1 Jul 12, 9:14pm
                   Frerin arithmancer 43 0 Jul 19, 5:44pm
               Translating the Runes Otaku-sempai 597 0 Jul 12, 9:32pm
           Collapse They should have kept the original one Kilidoescartwheels 567 8 Jul 13, 12:12am
               Collapse Agreed. Otaku-sempai 482 7 Jul 13, 2:46pm
                   Collapse Another version Ilmatar 431 6 Jul 13, 10:21pm
                       Collapse The complete song. Otaku-sempai 418 5 Jul 13, 11:28pm
                           Collapse It's just another POV :) Ilmatar 391 4 Jul 14, 6:56am
                               Collapse Yes, in the book thorin pulled out a harp and played in Bag End Eleniel 375 3 Jul 14, 10:16am
                                   Collapse But of course... Ilmatar 356 1 Jul 14, 2:12pm
                                       Yes... Avandel 113 0 Jul 14, 4:11pm
                                   Thank you for that detail! Avandel 339 0 Jul 14, 3:54pm

  Collapse Middle-earth tribute Númenórean 522 4 Jul 10, 10:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Wonderful video. Smaug the iron 450 0 Jul 10, 11:43pm
       Collapse I enjoyed watching that.... dormouse 335 1 Jul 11, 8:48am
           Putting Both Trilogies Together! Bombadil 318 0 Jul 11, 10:04am
       Very good – thank you Glorfindela 311 0 Jul 11, 10:19am

  Collapse The Return Journey EE DainPig 933 3 Jul 10, 7:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
       For the EE... Dcole4 892 0 Jul 10, 8:12pm
       Collapse The Return Otaku-sempai 883 1 Jul 10, 8:16pm
           Well, as it turned out there was a place for a young Aragorn..... dormouse 786 0 Jul 10, 10:09pm

  Collapse No-one seems to talk about Luke Evans' Bard! Thoughts? Avandel 1149 35 Jul 10, 1:44pm Jump to last post in thread (by OldestDaughter)
       I love him! CathrineB 1016 0 Jul 10, 2:08pm
       Probably because his performance was very good it passes under the radar... Eruonen 1006 0 Jul 10, 2:45pm
       Collapse Evans as Bard Otaku-sempai 968 7 Jul 10, 4:11pm
           There are a few wrong things Smaug the iron 931 0 Jul 10, 5:25pm
           Collapse But, but...re the blog link Avandel 843 4 Jul 10, 7:44pm
               Collapse Archery on Film Otaku-sempai 836 3 Jul 10, 8:04pm
                   Collapse But are you sure the expert is voicing the only possible opinion? dormouse 799 1 Jul 10, 10:05pm
                       Agreed. Otaku-sempai 689 0 Jul 11, 11:58am
                   It's not that uncommon, even for small bows... Bofur01 722 0 Jul 11, 9:17am
           His bad form Kilidoescartwheels 486 0 Jul 12, 11:15pm
       Collapse It's a quiet performance.... dormouse 909 2 Jul 10, 5:42pm
         Collapse Now that you mention it...Bard in DALE? Bombadil 894 1 Jul 10, 6:14pm
               Well I guess he had to kill that Troll thing with the wagon Kilidoescartwheels 483 0 Jul 12, 11:22pm
       Collapse A hairy favourite, definitely! Greenwood Hobbit 731 11 Jul 11, 8:11am
           Collapse Good point on family, Greenwood! the 13th warrior 181 10 Jul 15, 10:53pm
               Collapse I love the family man in Bard OldestDaughter 160 9 Jul 16, 1:09pm
                   Collapse Welcome to the forum OldestDaughter Smaug the iron 152 1 Jul 16, 1:34pm
                       Thank you Smaug the iron! OldestDaughter 148 0 Jul 16, 1:45pm
                   Collapse Welcome to TORN Otaku-sempai 140 2 Jul 16, 2:07pm
                       Collapse Oh I forgot about Theodred! OldestDaughter 124 1 Jul 16, 3:46pm
                           Bard of the Book Otaku-sempai 96 0 Jul 16, 7:40pm
                   Collapse Hi Oldest Daughter! Avandel 123 1 Jul 16, 3:53pm
                       Thank you! OldestDaughter 120 0 Jul 16, 3:57pm
                   Collapse Glimpses of children in LOTR/Hobbit..... the 13th warrior 101 1 Jul 16, 7:14pm
                       Thank you! OldestDaughter 90 0 Jul 16, 8:23pm
       Collapse Casting and performance was on point marary 658 6 Jul 11, 3:33pm
           Collapse Oh yes! Avandel 637 5 Jul 11, 5:28pm
               Collapse the three kings marary 629 4 Jul 11, 5:52pm
                 Collapse WOW you are Absolutely Right! Bombadil 554 3 Jul 12, 10:07am
                       Collapse Great-great-grandfather? Otaku-sempai 533 2 Jul 12, 3:28pm
                           Collapse Girion marary 516 1 Jul 12, 6:06pm
                               Yes. Otaku-sempai 510 0 Jul 12, 6:16pm
       Seen him in several movies Kilidoescartwheels 482 0 Jul 12, 11:54pm
       Collapse I think there are several obvious reasons why Bard isn't so much talked about elostirion74 426 1 Jul 13, 3:05pm
           Thoughtful and interesting IMO - thank you for posting! Avandel 358 0 Jul 14, 4:39pm

  Collapse Here is an Exercise you ALL might want to DO? Bombadil 927 18 Jul 10, 1:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Collapse Eh Gandalf the Green 770 4 Jul 10, 6:54am
           Collapse for his way of directing The Hobbit. NoelGallagher 764 3 Jul 10, 7:11am
             Collapse NoelG is right, people might want to Bombadil 722 2 Jul 10, 9:18am
                   Collapse I see it differently. Merovech 564 1 Jul 10, 6:01pm
                       OKAY...BUT? Bombadil 549 0 Jul 10, 6:30pm
       Nice reminder Elarie 662 0 Jul 10, 12:03pm
       Collapse I love commentaries... lionoferebor 524 11 Jul 10, 7:15pm
           Collapse Funny, I really don't like commentaries.... dormouse 475 10 Jul 10, 10:13pm
               I can't bear commentaries, Starling 459 0 Jul 10, 11:01pm
               Collapse Uh... lionoferebor 455 6 Jul 10, 11:09pm
                   Collapse But you are watching the film while the commentary track is playing.... dormouse 412 5 Jul 11, 8:19am
                       Collapse dmouse, dear..what the two, DO is fade themselves out? Bombadil 397 2 Jul 11, 10:47am
                           Collapse Oh, I feel privileged to have been around long enough to see these films... dormouse 343 1 Jul 11, 6:06pm
                             dmouse...Here is something to consider..? Bombadil 212 0 Jul 14, 12:18am
                       Actually... lionoferebor 377 0 Jul 11, 12:44pm
                       I get what you're saying Elarie 369 0 Jul 11, 1:21pm
               Collapse You are so on the money. Michelle Johnston 296 1 Jul 12, 7:35am
                   Thanks.... dormouse 296 0 Jul 12, 7:51am
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 991 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.