Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 3 of 1071 (378160 posts in 16057 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1071 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Re-evaluating Peter Jackson's The Hobbit Chen G. 2655 30 Feb 20, 4:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Chen G.)
       Collapse Excellent evaluation! Legomir 2549 8 Feb 20, 7:57pm
           Collapse Yes Chen G. 2549 7 Feb 20, 8:16pm
               Collapse Those Scenes Legomir 2513 6 Feb 21, 1:19am
                   Collapse Hmm Chen G. 2464 5 Feb 21, 12:22pm
                       Collapse Troll-hoards and Ringwraiths Otaku-sempai 2442 4 Feb 21, 3:27pm
                           Collapse Well... Chen G. 2414 3 Feb 21, 6:49pm
                               Collapse I largely agree Otaku-sempai 2404 2 Feb 21, 7:25pm
                                   Collapse It really is a minor issue Chen G. 2379 1 Feb 21, 7:57pm
                                       The High Fells does work as it is in DOS lurtz2010 2287 0 Feb 22, 7:32am
       I agree with a lot of this lurtz2010 2481 0 Feb 21, 7:39am
       Collapse Can we talk about the third act of DOS? lurtz2010 2283 14 Feb 22, 7:43am
           Collapse I talked about it Chen G. 2274 13 Feb 22, 8:48am
             Collapse You’re right it is good editing lurtz2010 2258 12 Feb 22, 10:01am
                   Collapse I certainly would have trimmed it down more Chen G. 2254 11 Feb 22, 10:12am
                       Collapse Events in 'DoS' are too rushed from Lake-town onward. Otaku-sempai 2191 10 Feb 22, 4:41pm
                           Collapse I wasn't thinking too much about the in-universe chronology Chen G. 2166 9 Feb 22, 5:11pm
                               I was thinking of both. Otaku-sempai 2152 0 Feb 22, 5:51pm
                               Collapse What are your thoughts on the first act of DOS? lurtz2010 2071 7 Feb 23, 9:23am
                                   Collapse Its a short first act Chen G. 2066 1 Feb 23, 9:32am
                                       But it just seems so illogical lurtz2010 2063 0 Feb 23, 9:46am
                                   Collapse Azog in the First Act Legomir 2019 4 Feb 23, 2:09pm
                                       Collapse Wrong goblins? Otaku-sempai 2014 3 Feb 23, 2:48pm
                                           Collapse Yes Chen G. 1981 2 Feb 23, 7:58pm
                                               That's how I took it as well Legomir 1958 0 Feb 23, 9:13pm
                                               Very nice thoughts skyofcoffeebeans 1002 0 Feb 24, 2:35pm
       Collapse Like your others, an excellent post. Noria 1006 2 Feb 24, 3:07pm
           Its not a clear-cut thing Chen G. 987 0 Feb 24, 6:01pm
           The Wight Stuff Otaku-sempai 948 0 Feb 25, 2:31am
       Collapse Thank you sador 785 1 Feb 27, 4:31am
           Thank YOU Chen G. 750 0 Feb 27, 2:39pm

  Collapse The Hobbit Caption Contest LXXXV Darkstone 1269 6 Feb 18, 9:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Griffo Hardbottom at the Free Fair wins the "Pumpkin High-hurddles" by two full lengths. / Bracegirdle 1176 0 Feb 19, 3:24pm
       The lesser known, but vastly more irritating Pumpkin Wizard arrives to engage Bilbo's services. Belegdir 1136 0 Feb 20, 9:12pm
       Collapse “Hobbits are remarkably light on their feet. And in fact pass unseen by most pumpkin farmers. // Loresilme 1129 2 Feb 20, 10:45pm
           Collapse The winner! Darkstone 1017 1 Feb 27, 2:22pm
               Thank you! Loresilme 1002 0 Feb 28, 12:18am
       Nobody had the heart to tell Bilbo that he'd failed to make the Shire's Olympic pumpkin hurdling team. Fereth 1122 0 Feb 21, 2:34am

  Collapse Beorn in Hobbit trilogy: The Story Line grimbeorn15 1618 5 Feb 10, 7:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by MedwedtoBeorn)
       More like the book, but less cinematic Chen G. 1600 0 Feb 10, 7:55pm
       Collapse "You will ruin for my next movie if you do this." Darkstone 1533 1 Feb 12, 2:23pm
           Yes, I think that was the case... Silmaril 1429 0 Feb 14, 1:12pm
       I was Beorn under a wandrin' star Bracegirdle 1341 0 Feb 16, 4:42pm
       I find the what if of Beorn in the GDTduology more interesting MedwedtoBeorn 559 0 Mar 26, 9:39pm

  Collapse The Hobbit Caption Contest LXXXIV Bracegirdle 1336 5 Feb 8, 11:50pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bracegirdle)
       Collapse "Blow in my ear and I'll follow you anywhere!" // Darkstone 1301 1 Feb 9, 12:08am
           ENOUGH! Darkstone your turn (again) Bracegirdle 1112 0 Feb 15, 4:47pm
       And then the hobbit said, "That's not my hand deary." Belegdir 1250 0 Feb 9, 4:53pm
       The Dwarves are estatic when they hear egg-catching will be an Olympic sport! Kilidoescartwheels 1164 0 Feb 14, 10:46pm
       And that's Numberwang! Belegdir 1111 0 Feb 15, 4:39pm

  Collapse Three is company? Chen G. 2422 27 Feb 8, 5:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Chen G.)
       Collapse If the change from two to three films was controversial... Otaku-sempai 2375 2 Feb 8, 7:12pm
           Collapse But! Chen G. 2366 1 Feb 8, 7:48pm
               Three films just seems padded (some might say). Otaku-sempai 2361 0 Feb 8, 8:04pm
       Originally one film for The Hobbit. Darkstone 2341 0 Feb 8, 9:57pm
       Collapse I'm kind of the opposite Kilidoescartwheels 2272 1 Feb 9, 9:36pm
           Theatrical/Extended Chen G. 2261 0 Feb 9, 11:11pm
       Collapse In my opinion AUJ is clearly the best of the three... Silmaril 2112 20 Feb 14, 1:28pm
           Collapse It felt more like "The Hobbit", yes Chen G. 2103 19 Feb 14, 2:44pm
               Collapse I did not say that there are no touching scenes in DOS and BOTFA... Silmaril 2092 18 Feb 14, 3:23pm
                   Collapse I was thinking more along the lines of Thorin and the Dwarves Chen G. 2082 17 Feb 14, 4:37pm
                       Collapse Smaug destroys whole cities... Silmaril 2039 16 Feb 15, 7:50am
                           Collapse Well, he’s a big dragon Chen G. 2027 15 Feb 15, 9:38am
                               Collapse I understand your arguments... Silmaril 2021 14 Feb 15, 10:13am
                                   Collapse And I see what you mean Chen G. 1999 13 Feb 15, 11:18am
                                       Collapse I understand. Otaku-sempai 1975 11 Feb 15, 3:01pm
                                           Collapse Yep Chen G. 1959 10 Feb 15, 4:51pm
                                               Collapse Spear Otaku-sempai 1946 5 Feb 15, 5:22pm
                                                   Collapse Bard's family is the representation of Laketown as a whole Chen G. 1934 4 Feb 15, 5:31pm
                                                       Collapse Bard the Bargeman Otaku-sempai 1919 3 Feb 15, 6:27pm
                                                           Collapse It has a narrative purpose - it adds conflict Chen G. 1909 2 Feb 15, 7:26pm
                                                               Collapse Okay. Otaku-sempai 1907 1 Feb 15, 8:01pm
                                                                   Nah Chen G. 1899 0 Feb 15, 8:07pm
                                               Collapse Yes Laineth 1766 3 Feb 18, 4:58am
                                                   Collapse Not the point I was going for, but yes Chen G. 773 2 Feb 18, 11:49am
                                                       Collapse Yes Laineth 717 1 Feb 19, 5:49pm
                                                           Right Chen G. 652 0 Feb 20, 11:30am
                                       Smaug Laineth 1762 0 Feb 18, 5:13am

  Collapse Cracking the code of The Hobbit Chen G. 3329 29 Feb 3, 3:28pm Jump to last post in thread (by Laineth)
       Collapse Jackson acknowledged this... Eldorion 3195 18 Feb 5, 2:30am
           Collapse If only Jackson had stopped with incorporating the Appendices. Otaku-sempai 3180 17 Feb 5, 4:17am
               Agreed. // Eldorion 3160 0 Feb 5, 5:54am
               Collapse Nah. Chen G. 3148 14 Feb 5, 8:48am
                   Collapse Ch-ch-ch-changes! Otaku-sempai 3112 13 Feb 5, 3:42pm
                       Collapse Adaptations should serve the film, not the novel Chen G. 3083 12 Feb 5, 6:06pm
                           Collapse I agree. Otaku-sempai 3073 1 Feb 5, 6:41pm
                               Ah, I see Chen G. 3055 0 Feb 5, 7:50pm
                           Collapse So to clarify... Eldorion 3038 9 Feb 5, 9:36pm
                               Collapse Well, surely he's entitled to his opinion? Kilidoescartwheels 3024 1 Feb 5, 10:36pm
                                   Yes, which is why I said... Eldorion 3021 0 Feb 5, 10:40pm
                               Collapse YES! Chen G. 2938 6 Feb 6, 12:06pm
                                   Collapse Co-hero? Otaku-sempai 2908 1 Feb 6, 3:36pm
                                       Its not clear-cut, yes Chen G. 2895 0 Feb 6, 4:46pm
                                   Collapse About that split in Laketown Kilidoescartwheels 2832 3 Feb 6, 10:55pm
                                       Collapse Very well said! Chen G. 2758 2 Feb 7, 12:12pm
                                           Collapse A Sense of Urgency Otaku-sempai 2718 1 Feb 7, 4:15pm
                                               Yep Chen G. 2708 0 Feb 7, 4:59pm
               Mileage may vary - let's look at this Kilidoescartwheels 3012 0 Feb 5, 11:06pm
       Collapse Thoughts Laineth 2564 9 Feb 13, 4:00am
           Collapse Movie Slapstick Otaku-sempai 2550 8 Feb 13, 4:51am
               Collapse Humor Chen G. 2508 2 Feb 13, 12:17pm
                   Collapse Only twice? Otaku-sempai 2486 1 Feb 13, 3:14pm
                       I was thinking more along the lines of playing with one's food Chen G. 2466 0 Feb 13, 5:12pm
               Collapse Slapstick Laineth 763 4 Feb 14, 4:47pm
                   Collapse Fair enough. Otaku-sempai 757 1 Feb 14, 5:12pm
                       You're welcome! :) Laineth 645 0 Feb 18, 4:42am
                   Collapse Alfrid Chen G. 749 1 Feb 14, 6:03pm
                       Alfrid and greed Laineth 644 0 Feb 18, 4:49am

  Collapse Hobbit Caption number LXXXIII Kilidoescartwheels 2420 12 Jan 29, 9:28pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bracegirdle)
       Collapse Bilbo chuckles as PJ informs Dwalin that there was just flat-out no more hair to be found. / Bracegirdle 2216 2 Jan 31, 4:03pm
           Collapse Winner by a coin toss Kilidoescartwheels 1908 1 Feb 7, 5:50pm
               Thank you Kilidoes Bracegirdle 1831 0 Feb 8, 3:28pm
       Crikey gents. Belegdir 2215 0 Jan 31, 5:24pm
       Now we've finally emptied theshe barrelsh, let'sh make shome (hic) filmsh!/ L. Ron Halfelven 2160 0 Feb 1, 7:33pm
       Collapse P: And now the surprise, guys! We're going on location!" Lissuin 2133 3 Feb 2, 5:20am
           Collapse Wot's a matamata with that? Belegdir 2101 1 Feb 2, 11:20am
               Will they fall for it, or be cow'ed? // dernwyn 2085 0 Feb 2, 2:33pm
           WOW! Kilidoescartwheels 2084 0 Feb 2, 3:40pm
       "Thanks to a generous grant from the University of Aukland's Physics Department so we could buy these barrels, we will now demonstrate the famous "Schrödinger's Dwarf" experiment!" / Darkstone 2064 0 Feb 2, 6:13pm
       PJ reveals to the guys that asking Benedict to say all his lines backwards was initially just a practical joke thought up by Martin. // Loresilme 2049 0 Feb 2, 9:41pm
       Wow, tough call here! Kilidoescartwheels 1910 0 Feb 7, 5:48pm

  Collapse Hard to believe it has almost been 7 years...time is so fleeting Eruonen 1778 2 Jan 18, 4:32pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       I just noticed that Andy Serkis had two sons (?) in the film Eruonen 1764 0 Jan 18, 4:48pm
       I never tire of those Loresilme 1671 0 Jan 21, 1:57am

  Collapse The Hobbit Caption Contest LXXXII Belegdir 2015 7 Jan 17, 4:17pm Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)
       It is medicinal I tell you! See, this is my prescription! Eruonen 1944 0 Jan 18, 12:10am
       "I hold in my hand the papers. Bracegirdle 1880 0 Jan 18, 9:07pm
       "Dragon, troll, goblin, bear, I smoke, and cast away all care!" / Darkstone 1866 0 Jan 18, 9:40pm
       Collapse Bilbo: Oh great, a button salesman! Maybe if I ignore him he'll go away....// Kilidoescartwheels 1843 2 Jan 19, 4:44am
           Collapse Winner! Belegdir 1574 1 Jan 28, 12:01pm
               Thanks! Kilidoescartwheels 1559 0 Jan 28, 5:18pm
       Forget the smell of dwarf or scent of hobbit ... the odor of Gandalf could clear a 5 mile radius. // Loresilme 1777 0 Jan 20, 1:36am

  Collapse HOBCAPCON LXXXI Meneldor 3310 13 Jan 9, 12:08am Jump to last post in thread (by Belegdir)
       I think you're good with just the link entmaiden 3259 0 Jan 9, 1:21am
       Collapse Thranduil: "My mount has the most bestest antlers!" Otaku-sempai 3256 3 Jan 9, 1:33am
           Twenty-fourth guy western flank, row sixty-six, "I gotta wee!" / Bracegirdle 3144 0 Jan 10, 12:37am
           Collapse Thranduil has a cunning plan to beat the crush at the New Year's sales. / Ataahua 2873 1 Jan 12, 8:12pm
               Lol! // Starling 2861 0 Jan 12, 10:15pm
       *sings* "One of these things is not like the others; one of these things is not quite the same." / Ataahua 3242 0 Jan 9, 3:05am
       Thorin: "I use antlers in all of my decorating, and those will look great over my fireplace!" Lissuin 3229 0 Jan 9, 7:54am
       Collapse Elves directly behind Thanduil. 1. O come on! Belegdir 3199 3 Jan 9, 5:28pm
         Collapse Potty humor! Almost as funny and lucky as dwarves in the toilet. Meneldor 2443 2 Jan 17, 1:32am
               You're welcome on the image. Otaku-sempai 2423 0 Jan 17, 3:38am
               You are too kind. Belegdir 2366 0 Jan 17, 2:24pm
       And their enemy sang as they marched: "I'm a moose! I'm a moose! Will you do the fandango?" but even as the entire Elven-host began to headbang the courage of the Dwarves did not quail. / Darkstone 3181 0 Jan 9, 6:02pm
       Thranduil does his best not to look...... dormouse 3089 0 Jan 10, 7:49pm

  Collapse Now that we are several years out and multiple views later - rank your movie preference Eruonen 3123 13 Jan 4, 7:54pm Jump to last post in thread (by Chen G.)
       My preference is Belegdir 3079 0 Jan 4, 8:02pm
       Always a tough call Kilidoescartwheels 3057 0 Jan 5, 1:41am
       I go back and forth Noria 3021 0 Jan 5, 1:47pm
       Collapse Good question . . . Barrel Rider 2598 2 Jan 16, 2:29pm
           For me Dipling 2541 0 Jan 16, 10:04pm
           just my 2 cents on the BOTFA EE Kilidoescartwheels 2531 0 Jan 16, 11:05pm
       I can't... dormouse 2448 0 Jan 17, 5:29pm
       My favorites --- hirmiestelio 2364 0 Jan 18, 9:16pm
       DOS > AUJ >>> BOFA Eldorion 2186 0 Jan 24, 8:31am
       Collapse I like AUJ best. ange1e4e5 1930 1 Feb 3, 4:15pm
           The Desolation of Smaug is the best Chen G. 1928 0 Feb 3, 4:57pm
       Collapse It's a tie!! hamlet 1765 1 Feb 5, 5:02pm
           But that Alfrid meets the business-end of a troll is a plus Chen G. 1731 0 Feb 6, 12:24pm

  Collapse The Hobbit Caption Contest LXXX (Happy New Year edition!) Loresilme 2612 12 Jan 2, 1:34pm Jump to last post in thread (by Meneldor)
       "According to this record, Mister Baggins, one of your forebears really DID wed a 'fairy wife'!" Otaku-sempai 2557 0 Jan 2, 2:45pm
       Collapse "Do you like me? Check yes or no. _Yes _No" Meneldor 2543 2 Jan 2, 6:55pm
           Collapse And the winner is ...! Loresilme 2233 1 Jan 8, 2:05am
               An unexpected honor (?), to be sure! Meneldor 2127 0 Jan 9, 12:00am
       "You got me a voucher to Gap of Rohan for Christmas? Ataahua 2537 0 Jan 2, 7:07pm
       "You're right! According to the script I say 'Hi, how are you?' not 'How high are you?'!" / Darkstone 2535 0 Jan 2, 7:11pm
       And Eru Ilúvatar said, "Blessed are the short of stature, for theirs is the Kingdom of the Underground." / Bracegirdle 2514 0 Jan 2, 9:10pm
       Elrond couldn't remember 'Tra-la-la-lally' without the aid of the sheet music./ L. Ron Halfelven 2510 0 Jan 2, 10:12pm
       "...you can read it for yourself in this photostatic copy...It's all there, black and white, clear as crystal! You stole our silverware. You bathed in our fountain, which now has to be washed and sterilized, so you get nothing! You lose! Good day sirs!... StingingFly 2469 0 Jan 3, 8:54pm
       Tsk, tsk, tsk. Belegdir 2468 0 Jan 3, 9:01pm
       LOL I just want to say... Loresilme 2456 0 Jan 4, 12:01am
       Elrond: You MAY be Thorin Oakenshield, King Under the Mountain... Kilidoescartwheels 2415 0 Jan 4, 3:31pm

  Collapse TNT playing The Hobbit movies.....I cannot stand to watch w commercials so Eruonen 2126 5 Jan 1, 7:35pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Collapse In addition, they are edited Loresilme 2090 4 Jan 2, 12:25pm
           Hobbits MorgulBlade 2022 0 Jan 4, 7:31pm
           Collapse And sped up. Darkstone 2019 2 Jan 4, 8:11pm
               Collapse Motion blur cats16 1998 1 Jan 5, 4:23am
                   Plus, the discs look much better visually than the broadcast Eruonen 1947 0 Jan 5, 8:46pm

  Collapse Jacksonverse Elves during the Balcoth reign of terror Victariongreyjoy 2107 9 Jan 1, 7:07pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse Balchoth? Otaku-sempai 2088 2 Jan 1, 8:03pm
           Collapse Aragorn, the dunedain and Thranduil Victariongreyjoy 2085 1 Jan 1, 8:09pm
               Thranduil in the Movieverse Otaku-sempai 2074 0 Jan 1, 9:30pm
       Collapse Thranduil was very insular - he did not concern himself with events outside his Eruonen 2056 5 Jan 1, 11:19pm
           Collapse Insular Dwarves Otaku-sempai 2044 4 Jan 1, 11:51pm
               Collapse Taking some liberty Victariongreyjoy 2041 3 Jan 2, 12:17am
                   Collapse Still unlikely Otaku-sempai 2031 2 Jan 2, 3:23am
                       Collapse Fan fiction surely Victariongreyjoy 1968 1 Jan 2, 5:23pm
                           So, not asking as a Loremaster. Otaku-sempai 1965 0 Jan 2, 5:32pm

  Collapse Who is the Hobbit who looks like Sean Astin in the market ExEd scene? hirmiestelio 1850 3 Dec 30 2017, 6:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by Loresilme)
       Collapse It does resemble Sam Loresilme 1720 2 Jan 2, 12:41pm
           Collapse Sam's Grandda? Otaku-sempai 1703 1 Jan 2, 2:34pm
               lol who knew those Gamgee looks run in the family ;) Loresilme 1695 0 Jan 2, 3:02pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1071 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.