Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 2 of 1001 (357768 posts in 15004 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1001 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse Thorin, Kili, and the Elves... lionoferebor 1041 37 Thu, 5:19am Jump to last post in thread (by lionoferebor)
     Collapse unfortunately Avandel 943 34 Thu, 6:41am
           Collapse Conversations that never happened. Arannir 862 11 Thu, 9:42am
               Collapse Well Smaug the iron 236 1 Fri, 8:28am
                   Yes, I think you're absolutely right.... dormouse 195 0 Fri, 1:27pm
               Collapse Even Thorin looked surprised lionoferebor 126 8 Sat, 6:57am
                   Collapse Bilbo sees them coming from affar Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 111 7 Sat, 8:35am
                       Collapse Well yes, lionoferebor 93 6 Sat, 10:55am
                           yes I get that Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 90 0 Sat, 10:56am
                           Collapse Oddities...... Avandel 59 4 Sat, 5:20pm
                               Collapse Thorin may not have allowed it. Cirashala 45 3 Sat, 7:11pm
                                   Collapse True enough IMO Avandel 31 1 Sat, 8:00pm
                                       Fast-forward dragon sickness? Ilmatar 24 0 Sat, 9:21pm
                                   The plummet lionoferebor 8 0 3:39am
           Collapse I definitely missed those conversations in these films Earl 845 11 Thu, 10:00am
               Agreed CathrineB 832 0 Thu, 10:13am
               Collapse Maybe they went..... dormouse 787 9 Thu, 11:42am
                   Collapse Hilda lionoferebor 739 3 Thu, 12:56pm
                       Collapse Hilda Smaug the iron 724 2 Thu, 1:11pm
                           Speaking of her... Arannir 719 0 Thu, 1:14pm
                           Thank you lionoferebor 707 0 Thu, 1:19pm
                   Collapse I think that's the problem... Earl 736 3 Thu, 1:01pm
                       Collapse Agreed and 100% signed. Arannir 727 1 Thu, 1:07pm
                           Let's hope the coming years bring us some Hobbit soundtrack goodies Earl 714 0 Thu, 1:16pm
                       You had to look before.... dormouse 699 0 Thu, 1:23pm
                   not turned on IMO - HUNGRY, rather.... Avandel 616 0 Thu, 3:11pm
           Collapse They were filmed... lionoferebor 721 9 Thu, 1:15pm
               Collapse Wait... Dcole4 681 4 Thu, 1:48pm
                   Collapse There is still hope... lionoferebor 483 3 Thu, 5:22pm
                       Collapse Wow. Mooseboy018 430 2 Thu, 6:32pm
                           Seriously. Dcole4 413 0 Thu, 6:49pm
                           *meh* Avandel 273 0 Fri, 12:18am
               Collapse glad you understand! Avandel 598 3 Thu, 3:23pm
                   It is strange that Fili is quiet on the matter Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 565 0 Thu, 3:50pm
                   I've said this before, but... Kilidoescartwheels 534 0 Thu, 4:25pm
                   Avandel... lionoferebor 495 0 Thu, 5:08pm
       Collapse In response to the OP Susan 389 1 Thu, 6:59pm
           I understand what you're saying... lionoferebor 136 0 Sat, 6:43am

  Collapse All 9 armoured Nazgul Designs? QueenCirce 1101 35 Thu, 2:25am Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       Hopefully in the EE bonus features // QuackingTroll 1032 0 Thu, 2:27am
       Collapse The Weta Chronicles Book... Pandallo 967 1 Thu, 4:13am
           Wow excellent thank you! QueenCirce 957 0 Thu, 4:26am
       Six of nine... TheHutt 929 0 Thu, 5:10am
       Trying to speak more about what I LIKE about these movies... Arannir 830 0 Thu, 8:06am
       Collapse They are one of the aspects of the film that really bug me actually! adt100 718 27 Thu, 11:45am
           Collapse aGREED! Dcole4 516 26 Thu, 7:03pm
               Collapse Would you say the Nazgul are consistent beings Spriggan 464 24 Thu, 9:12pm
                   Collapse Not sure I follow! Bishop 373 23 Fri, 9:43am
                       Collapse Oh I would say they are hugely inconsistent and mysterious beings Spriggan 363 22 Fri, 10:21am
                           Collapse But if it's the films we're looking at Bishop 355 21 Fri, 10:52am
                               Don't know what Spriggan thinks, but for me there is a kind of logic to it.... dormouse 324 0 Fri, 1:22pm
                               Collapse I think that's my argument. Spriggan 241 19 Fri, 5:54pm
                                   Collapse What is inconsistent in the books?? QuackingTroll 239 6 Fri, 6:04pm
                                       Was wondering that myself... Salmacis81 201 0 Fri, 8:36pm
                                       Collapse Oh their appearances are the least of their inconsistencies but Spriggan 112 4 Sat, 3:50pm
                                           Collapse Any specific examples? QuackingTroll 61 3 Sat, 7:19pm
                                               Collapse They are all specific examples. Spriggan 30 2 12:06am
                                                   Collapse Those aren't examples, they're questions... QuackingTroll 27 1 12:10am
                                                       Just one example Spriggan 25 0 12:29am
                                   Collapse It's not "creature rules" Bishop 198 11 Fri, 8:45pm
                                       Collapse The Ring does exactly that. Spriggan 107 10 Sat, 3:55pm
                                           Collapse No, it doesn't Bishop 91 9 Sat, 4:48pm
                                               Collapse Ha - I took those to be examples. Spriggan 79 8 Sat, 4:56pm
                                                   Collapse oh, really? Bishop 53 7 Sat, 6:21pm
                                                       Collapse Just for a change, Spriggan 69 6 Sat, 6:36pm
                                                           Collapse I'm totally game for this amazing challenge Bishop 51 4 Sat, 8:07pm
                                                               Collapse ...Grimbold? // QuackingTroll 47 1 Sat, 8:10pm
                                                                   Close! Bishop 40 0 Sat, 9:09pm
                                                               Collapse Odd that you don't seem able to come up with anything. Spriggan 29 1 12:08am
                                                                   You're the one who'is dodging Bishop 16 0 1:05am
                                                           What is the relevance of your question? QuackingTroll 15 0 1:51am
             their style is strategy Wasserwaldnymphe 257 0 Fri, 5:13pm
       Collapse I agree with a couple posters here Bishop 539 1 Thu, 6:35pm
           About this issue NManfredi 72 0 Sat, 4:58pm

  Collapse PJs Hobbit vs Bakshis LOTR balbo biggins 751 17 Thu, 12:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Eldorion)
       I love Bakshi's version of the man in the moon song. Much more than Bofur's // QuackingTroll 682 0 Thu, 12:59am
       Fair enough. Spriggan 688 0 Thu, 12:59am
       PJs CathrineB 668 0 Thu, 1:23am
       Successful? Mooseboy018 652 0 Thu, 1:33am
       Well I enjoy both droidsocket 631 0 Thu, 1:54am
       I'll never for the life of me... Aragorn the Elfstone 629 0 Thu, 1:57am
       Nah... Arannir 512 0 Thu, 7:19am
       I think the Bakshi is dreadful... dormouse 483 0 Thu, 8:32am
       It begins well but rapidly goes downhill! adt100 422 0 Thu, 11:54am
       Collapse I like it ghost_matt 335 4 Thu, 5:18pm
           Collapse script Mooseboy018 290 2 Thu, 6:39pm
               And lest we forget 'Aruman of many colours!' adt100 213 0 Thu, 11:00pm
               That's only really a problem if you've read the book... QuackingTroll 207 0 Thu, 11:34pm
           Rotoscoping Eldorion 164 0 Fri, 5:31am
       I saw it on DVD Elanor of Rohan 256 0 Thu, 7:51pm
       Drogo led a Bakshi discussion back in 2007. Darkstone 239 0 Thu, 9:34pm
       Why are we comparing adaptations of two different books? Eldorion 164 0 Fri, 5:37am

  Collapse All the new BOFA EE clips in one short video Goldeneye 1820 48 Thu, 12:17am Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       So excited!! EgyptRaider 1711 0 Thu, 12:23am
       Collapse CGI balbo biggins 1702 2 Thu, 12:28am
           Collapse Look on the bright side... Brandybuckled 660 1 Thu, 11:34pm
               Don't get your hopes up Goldeneye 648 0 Thu, 11:48pm
       Awesome, thank you! Voronwë_the_Faithful 1681 0 Thu, 12:38am
       Great highlight reel of new stuff! Eldorion 1466 0 Thu, 4:38am
       Video game or movie??? Avnar 1455 0 Thu, 4:44am
       Collapse I'm not so sure about ... Legolas_Shoehorn 1420 1 Thu, 5:11am
           They are. Mooseboy018 1329 0 Thu, 6:49am
       Collapse ... Dipling 1337 4 Thu, 6:44am
           Collapse What are swirling ballista arrows? Eruonen 673 3 Thu, 11:23pm
               Collapse This... Dipling 249 2 Fri, 7:56pm
                   Collapse Yes, but what are they? Why do they swirl? Coriolis effect from power? Eruonen 239 1 Fri, 8:13pm
                       I imagine they're just blades... QuackingTroll 234 0 Fri, 8:18pm
       Thanks.... dormouse 1247 0 Thu, 8:27am
       Thanks for this :) Arannir 1054 0 Thu, 1:08pm
       Collapse Thank you! Susan 945 4 Thu, 3:39pm
           Collapse The Beorn scene is in the theatrical version. Smaug the iron 937 1 Thu, 3:41pm
               Aww, darn it Susan 929 0 Thu, 3:44pm
           Collapse Oops Goldeneye 918 1 Thu, 3:47pm
               At least we know Beorn's entrance isn't changed // QuackingTroll 634 0 Fri, 12:26am
       Ugh, more upside Legolas....... Eruonen 648 0 Thu, 11:48pm
       Collapse Thank you, GE – nice job. Glorfindela 525 16 Fri, 9:36am
           Collapse If PJ like Legolas doing impossible things Smaug the iron 519 10 Fri, 9:54am
               I realize that Glorfindela 502 0 Fri, 10:00am
               Collapse My Problem With Legolas AndHeHandedHimTheTobaccoJar 429 8 Fri, 1:09pm
                   coolest shot tattooed_dwarf 384 0 Fri, 3:36pm
                   Collapse Also... how and why? QuackingTroll 353 6 Fri, 3:59pm
                       Collapse Er..... dormouse 313 5 Fri, 5:40pm
                           Collapse Um. Goldeneye 277 4 Fri, 7:14pm
                               Collapse Legolodes? / Darkstone 269 1 Fri, 7:20pm
                                   Legolas in esperanto DainPig 265 0 Fri, 7:27pm
                               Probably.... dormouse 214 0 Fri, 10:06pm
                               Well Glorfindela 181 0 Fri, 11:18pm
           Collapse For the plain reason NecromancerRising 499 3 Fri, 10:02am
               Well, all I can say is: Glorfindela 476 0 Fri, 10:37am
               Collapse grrrrr Cillendor 380 1 Fri, 3:40pm
                   Absolument! NecromancerRising 344 0 Fri, 4:12pm
           Thanks Goldeneye 460 0 Fri, 12:24pm
       Collapse Dwarves in real costumes! Also, Greetings to all NManfredi 209 6 Fri, 10:34pm
           Collapse Here... Dipling 187 3 Fri, 11:14pm
               Collapse Maybe you're right NManfredi 163 2 Sat, 1:11am
                   Collapse I think... Withywindle 145 1 Sat, 2:23am
                       Thanks NManfredi 138 0 Sat, 2:39am
           Collapse Hello, NManfredi Glorfindela 182 1 Fri, 11:21pm
               Hello, Glorfindela NManfredi 159 0 Sat, 1:16am
       Collapse I'm sorry PJ. Farficom 118 1 Sat, 3:57am
           Give us the details! Mooseboy018 93 0 Sat, 4:52am

  Collapse BOFA EE DVD/Bluray found on Amazon OldestDaughter 460 3 Wed, 10:48pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
     Collapse You are late, oldaughy DainPig 433 1 Wed, 10:56pm
         I knew the news and saw all the headlines! OldestDaughter 422 0 Wed, 11:01pm
       It is interesting there is only $1.00 difference between DVD and BluRay Eruonen 375 0 Wed, 11:37pm

  Collapse Where did this pic of Bilbo come from? Kilidoescartwheels 639 10 Wed, 9:55pm Jump to last post in thread (by Barrow-Wight)
       Likes like it's in the Goblin Caves SafeUnderHill 608 0 Wed, 9:57pm
       AUJ Mooseboy018 602 0 Wed, 9:58pm
       Never saw this one DainPig 593 0 Wed, 10:01pm
       Collapse I know what that is... They shot a dream sequence... QuackingTroll 590 5 Wed, 10:06pm
           Actually, that might have been an early rumour... QuackingTroll 567 0 Wed, 10:12pm
           Collapse Interesting... Dcole4 536 2 Wed, 10:28pm
               Collapse Here's the shot in the trailer: QuackingTroll 533 1 Wed, 10:32pm
                   Wow SafeUnderHill 525 0 Wed, 10:39pm
           the dream in the book Barrow-Wight 474 0 Wed, 11:11pm
       Hmmm.... Dcole4 541 0 Wed, 10:27pm

  Collapse that is so cool mirkwoodwanderer 642 6 Wed, 9:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Smaug the iron)
       Yes, I had heard it before DainPig 582 0 Wed, 9:37pm
       Collapse I wonder if someone could edit what we have together? QuackingTroll 565 2 Wed, 9:47pm
           Collapse Ask and ye shall receive Goldeneye 419 1 Thu, 12:07am
               Awesome! // adt100 203 0 Thu, 11:49am
       iiit iss!!! Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 278 0 Thu, 7:23am
       Here is a video Smaug the iron 31 0 Sat, 10:05am

  Collapse I bought my tickets to all three Hobbit EE movie showings in October! elf_wannabee 357 5 Wed, 7:59pm Jump to last post in thread (by Bombadil)
       Really hope this comes to the UK // QuackingTroll 332 0 Wed, 8:02pm
       Great, have fun :) Arannir 328 0 Wed, 8:13pm
       Well a friend is supposed to pick some up today Kilidoescartwheels 276 0 Wed, 8:58pm
       Collapse Nope, I don't live in the US... Queen of Erebor 217 1 Wed, 10:25pm
           Lucky Bomby, in Denver about Bombadil 99 0 Thu, 2:31pm

  Collapse What's wrong with this picture? Kilidoescartwheels 1402 64 Wed, 4:52pm Jump to last post in thread (by Arveldis)
       Collapse What's the purpose of the picture? Spriggan 1214 13 Wed, 5:04pm
           Collapse Of that particular picture? Kilidoescartwheels 1207 12 Wed, 5:07pm
               Collapse Only partially agree. Spriggan 1194 11 Wed, 5:10pm
                   Collapse Most marketable in THEIR opinion Kilidoescartwheels 1138 9 Wed, 5:28pm
                       Collapse Well, in their professional opinion, yes. Spriggan 1118 2 Wed, 5:35pm
                           Collapse Well I'm not basing it on sales Kilidoescartwheels 844 1 Wed, 7:16pm
                               That's a horse of a different colour. Spriggan 369 0 Wed, 7:29pm
                       Collapse Your opinion is invalid because you can't prove otherwise QuackingTroll 1073 5 Wed, 5:49pm
                           Collapse The effectiveness of marketing isn't a matter of opinion. Spriggan 1033 4 Wed, 5:58pm
                               Collapse You're the only one discussing sales figures... QuackingTroll 1010 3 Wed, 6:04pm
                                   Collapse No that's not true. Spriggan 999 2 Wed, 6:09pm
                                       Collapse Well that's not really what I wanted to talk about Kilidoescartwheels 378 1 Wed, 7:18pm
                                           Who knows? Spriggan 365 0 Wed, 7:35pm
                   Agreed! It’s all about the Do-Re-Mi . . . $ $ $ Bracegirdle 1131 0 Wed, 5:28pm
       Collapse Stuff like this Shagrat 1218 1 Wed, 5:04pm
           A little unfair IMO, it's called marketing.... adt100 272 0 Wed, 10:05pm
       Collapse It makes more sense then your suggestions EgyptRaider 1100 1 Wed, 5:44pm
           This. Aragorn the Elfstone 1028 0 Wed, 6:01pm
       Too much text! TheHutt 1077 0 Wed, 5:45pm
       I hate it CathrineB 1071 0 Wed, 5:46pm
       Collapse But logically... Darkstone 1071 2 Wed, 5:48pm
           Collapse the LotR EE sold just fine with no picture at all // QuackingTroll 1036 1 Wed, 5:55pm
               Exactly! TheHutt 1026 0 Wed, 5:59pm
       Collapse Marketing Susan 1020 1 Wed, 6:01pm
           They should just put a big picture of Legolas.. QuackingTroll 967 0 Wed, 6:19pm
       Depends who's asking and why, I suppose.... dormouse 1013 0 Wed, 6:03pm
       nothing balbo biggins 933 0 Wed, 6:30pm
       Collapse Well... Arannir 879 1 Wed, 6:59pm
           Oh please, no Alfrid! Kilidoescartwheels 380 0 Wed, 7:17pm
       Collapse *bows* - thank you for the compliment and... Avandel 383 3 Wed, 7:20pm
           Collapse Oh, but, Avandel... Arveldis 235 2 Wed, 11:20pm
             Collapse LOL Avandel 280 1 Thu, 6:10am
                   I'm sure the kiddies would love it. Arveldis 25 0 Sat, 2:28am
       Collapse I don't get it Lindele 363 2 Wed, 7:57pm
           Collapse True Elanor of Rohan 344 1 Wed, 8:19pm
               You mean Theatrical edition? DainPig 310 0 Wed, 8:42pm
       Collapse Where is Azog? DainPig 325 26 Wed, 8:34pm
           Collapse Why Azog? Salmacis81 259 25 Wed, 11:01pm
               Collapse Why Legolas? DainPig 251 1 Wed, 11:09pm
                   And Azog is supposed to be in The Hobbit? Salmacis81 235 0 Wed, 11:19pm
               Collapse THIS Avandel 232 22 Wed, 11:31pm
                   Yes... Salmacis81 211 0 Wed, 11:58pm
                   Collapse The image is probably a reasonable indication. Spriggan 213 20 Thu, 12:05am
                       Collapse The movies would have sold just as well... Salmacis81 209 19 Thu, 12:13am
                           Collapse I don't know what we would base that on. Spriggan 205 18 Thu, 12:19am
                               Collapse I remember the excitement in the lead-up to AUJ... Salmacis81 198 17 Thu, 12:39am
                                   Collapse I'm not sure what you mean. Spriggan 197 16 Thu, 12:56am
                                       Collapse Excitement Mooseboy018 179 1 Thu, 1:44am
                                           Well quite. Spriggan 173 0 Thu, 1:55am
                                       Collapse The Phantom Menace and Prometheus.. QuackingTroll 175 10 Thu, 2:19am
                                           Collapse Are you pulling my leg? Spriggan 265 9 Thu, 8:00am
                                               Collapse Yes it's a spoof answer QuackingTroll 239 8 Thu, 11:11am
                                                   Collapse It depends on what people are saying. Spriggan 232 7 Thu, 11:38am
                                                       Collapse You were asking someone to provide evidence of measured excitement QuackingTroll 216 3 Thu, 11:53am
                                                           Collapse Sigh. Spriggan 206 2 Thu, 1:09pm
                                                               Collapse personal taste Kilidoescartwheels 198 1 Thu, 1:46pm
                                                                   I agree - I said that further up, at least a couple of times. Spriggan 192 0 Thu, 1:55pm
                                                       Collapse Seriously, you do go overboard sometimes Kilidoescartwheels 204 2 Thu, 1:44pm
                                                           Collapse I agree. Spriggan 191 1 Thu, 1:59pm
                                                               Maybe it's time to move on to other topics entmaiden 188 0 Thu, 2:19pm
                                       Collapse Media buzz... Salmacis81 154 2 Thu, 5:52pm
                                           Collapse Probably going to do well Spriggan 115 1 Thu, 9:20pm
                                               But odds were always stacked in favor of these movies doing well... Salmacis81 33 0 Fri, 10:48pm
       The picture sums up perfectly... Salmacis81 263 0 Wed, 10:58pm

  Collapse Dain's Arrival/Dwarven Cavalry (EE Spoilers) Shagrat 1244 13 Wed, 1:46pm Jump to last post in thread (by xMb)
       Collapse Even if things turn out NecromancerRising 1184 4 Wed, 1:55pm
           It is Shagrat 1157 0 Wed, 2:00pm
           This! Avandel 999 0 Wed, 3:04pm
           Collapse Rams vs Wargs? Kilidoescartwheels 789 1 Wed, 4:56pm
               It really could NecromancerRising 520 0 Wed, 8:41pm
       Collapse A bit of both. Arannir 1102 5 Wed, 2:20pm
           Collapse Use of 'Battle for the Mountain' Shagrat 1025 3 Wed, 2:56pm
               Collapse Thanks for that. Arannir 1012 2 Wed, 3:00pm
                   Collapse My problem Shagrat 983 1 Wed, 3:07pm
                       Changes To The Battle brotherbeck 919 0 Wed, 3:39pm
           And Faleel 767 0 Wed, 5:07pm
       Perhaps we will even get Gandalf's "... how shall this day end" line Earl 1046 0 Wed, 2:51pm
       wargs xMb 321 0 Thu, 2:58am

  Collapse SEE trilogy packshots (open!) TheHutt 1284 16 Wed, 8:20am Jump to last post in thread (by balbo biggins)
       wow Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 1198 0 Wed, 8:31am
       Collapse Greeeeeeey... adt100 937 7 Wed, 12:31pm
           Collapse .... Dcole4 922 6 Wed, 12:38pm
               Collapse I don't think TABA is happening Eldorion 839 4 Wed, 1:36pm
                   Collapse I think PJ would have like a There And Back Again box set... QuackingTroll 813 1 Wed, 1:47pm
                       That's true too Eldorion 777 0 Wed, 2:06pm
                   Collapse Could very well be the case... Dcole4 763 1 Wed, 2:14pm
                       RE: the three film split Eldorion 707 0 Wed, 2:36pm
               Maybe, though I'm not convinced! adt100 735 0 Wed, 2:28pm
       I like 'em Eldorion 843 0 Wed, 1:34pm
     Bomby wantzzz to Thank YOU...The Hutt Bombadil 603 0 Wed, 3:48pm
       Collapse Are you working on the booklet, Hutt? QuackingTroll 596 1 Wed, 3:52pm
           Most definitely! TheHutt 505 0 Wed, 5:10pm
       Collapse question balbo biggins 430 2 Wed, 6:34pm
           Collapse The Blu-ray box set doesn't just match the dimensions, it's the same box... QuackingTroll 422 1 Wed, 6:41pm
               duh balbo biggins 367 0 Wed, 7:19pm

  Collapse The fish is not already cooked? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 648 3 Wed, 7:07am Jump to last post in thread (by QuackingTroll)
       Hm NoelGallagher 617 0 Wed, 7:14am
       I wouldn't be surprised Eldorion 377 0 Wed, 1:13pm
       Hope he doesn't pull an Avatar... QuackingTroll 365 0 Wed, 1:17pm

  Collapse will Peter Jackson address any of the controversies in his commentary 1924 1235 57 Wed, 5:20am Jump to last post in thread (by Goldeneye)
       Controversies Arannir 1092 0 Wed, 6:52am
       Collapse Probably SafeUnderHill 1074 2 Wed, 7:06am
           Well, good Glorfindela 986 0 Wed, 9:21am
           Coming from an American... lionoferebor 820 0 Wed, 12:47pm
       Collapse Has he directly addressed the criticism of the Hobbit to date? Goldeneye 896 23 Wed, 11:54am
           Collapse The Tauriel empowerment thing is nuts... Dcole4 892 15 Wed, 12:01pm
               Now Eowyn, that's a good role model... QuackingTroll 878 0 Wed, 12:09pm
               Collapse Regardless of the character people would still have complained.... adt100 857 12 Wed, 12:36pm
                   Collapse True.. Dcole4 837 1 Wed, 12:42pm
                       Agreed Goldeneye 664 0 Wed, 2:38pm
                   Collapse As one of the "not in the book" complainers... RosieLass 377 9 Wed, 4:29pm
                       Collapse I wonder if people would've had a problem if Legolas killed Smaug? QuackingTroll 198 8 Wed, 11:06pm
                           Some people probably would not have cared... Salmacis81 180 0 Wed, 11:38pm
                           Collapse I often wonder how some defenders of the films... Salmacis81 176 1 Wed, 11:46pm
                               I don't know about people Spriggan 158 0 Thu, 1:08am
                           Collapse The difference there is in the importance of the victim, not the killer..... dormouse 189 4 Thu, 8:15am
                               Collapse Beorn in the BoFA Otaku-sempai 142 2 Thu, 12:52pm
                                   Collapse That's a very interesting way of looking at it.... dormouse 137 1 Thu, 1:20pm
                                       Beorn's Story Otaku-sempai 111 0 Thu, 2:21pm
                               Agreed on Beorn carrying Thorin's body. Arannir 130 0 Thu, 1:28pm
               So true! Kilidoescartwheels 355 0 Wed, 5:01pm
           Yes SafeUnderHill 227 0 Wed, 9:03pm
           Collapse Well, here's the thing.... dormouse 204 5 Wed, 10:34pm
               Collapse Peter Jackson is probably the most open and candid major filmmaker there is Voronwë_the_Faithful 194 1 Wed, 10:51pm
                   Hear, hear! Dipling 125 0 Thu, 6:54am
               Collapse Agreed with most of this. Arannir 182 1 Thu, 8:26am
                   Assuming that you are referring to me. Spriggan 171 0 Thu, 8:44am
               Thanks for the video link Goldeneye 102 0 Thu, 2:35pm
       Collapse Hopefully not much. Spriggan 822 28 Wed, 12:53pm
           LOL, NecromancerRising 801 0 Wed, 12:59pm
           Collapse You are ignoring... Arannir 794 18 Wed, 1:05pm
               I'm not ignoring it. Spriggan 757 0 Wed, 1:16pm
               Collapse But they didn't, though...... dormouse 699 16 Wed, 2:23pm
                   You didn't discredit anyone. Arannir 670 0 Wed, 2:37pm
                   Collapse The critics thing always leaves me scratching my head. Spriggan 412 14 Wed, 3:39pm
                       Collapse There are many. Arannir 405 13 Wed, 3:49pm
                           Collapse Perhaps your comment mischaracterised your view. Spriggan 394 12 Wed, 4:01pm
                             Collapse The second statement was meant to... Arannir 337 11 Wed, 6:19pm
                                   Collapse Yes definitely confusing then. Spriggan 324 10 Wed, 6:31pm
                                       Collapse Well both. Arannir 314 9 Wed, 6:55pm
                                           Collapse Well it can't be both. Spriggan 308 8 Wed, 7:09pm
                                               Collapse We apparantly read very different reviews then. Arannir 306 7 Wed, 7:13pm
                                                   Collapse Which reviews are you thinking of? Spriggan 296 6 Wed, 7:20pm
                                                       Collapse Here - QuackingTroll 293 3 Wed, 7:29pm
                                                           Collapse Ha, I think we might need more than one to get to a majority. Spriggan 290 2 Wed, 7:32pm
                                                               Collapse Oh okay, you're right... what was your point again? QuackingTroll 275 1 Wed, 7:44pm
                                                                   No - you can read my point if you scroll up. Spriggan 269 0 Wed, 7:51pm
                                                       Collapse Did you even read my last posts? Arannir 258 1 Wed, 8:10pm
                                                           Sure, but I'm responding to the element which interested me Spriggan 231 0 Wed, 9:00pm
           Collapse Do people from the film crew still read the Tolkien forums? Eldorion 662 7 Wed, 2:39pm
               Collapse Surely not! Spriggan 654 6 Wed, 2:46pm
                   Collapse I'm not saying we have influence Eldorion 629 5 Wed, 3:00pm
                       Collapse I would say that is a form of influence Spriggan 624 4 Wed, 3:02pm
                           Collapse Okay... Eldorion 611 3 Wed, 3:07pm
                               Collapse Yap. Arannir 600 1 Wed, 3:11pm
                                   Thanks for the confirmation Eldorion 580 0 Wed, 3:29pm
                               I wouldn't say they are the same thing. Spriggan 589 0 Wed, 3:26pm

  Collapse Alternate Scenes In Extended Edition? MJM 1184 29 Wed, 5:02am Jump to last post in thread (by lionoferebor)
       We have already seen an altered scene NecromancerRising 1155 0 Wed, 5:04am
       Collapse It will be a mix Eldorion 1144 16 Wed, 5:06am
           Collapse .. pulpfiction16 1108 15 Wed, 5:25am
               Collapse Day/night switching Eldorion 1096 11 Wed, 5:28am
                   Collapse That is correct. NecromancerRising 1084 5 Wed, 5:30am
                       Collapse I appreciate the confirmation Eldorion 1077 4 Wed, 5:31am
                           Collapse I had a LOTR marathon not more NecromancerRising 1062 3 Wed, 5:35am
                               Collapse Back in the day... Eldorion 1057 2 Wed, 5:37am
                                   Collapse You never tried it? NecromancerRising 1049 1 Wed, 5:41am
                                       Lack of a group was the main obstacle Eldorion 1038 0 Wed, 5:46am
                   Collapse Probably the biggest LOTR EE scene switch Silverlode 1043 4 Wed, 5:45am
                       Collapse Very interesting Eldorion 1033 2 Wed, 5:47am
                           Collapse The FOTR TE might be worth a rewatch... Silverlode 1001 1 Wed, 6:08am
                               I have seen both versions of the prologue Eldorion 992 0 Wed, 6:11am
                       There were also some alternative shots with no time difference... TheHutt 937 0 Wed, 6:53am
               Collapse DoS EE Mooseboy018 1081 1 Wed, 5:30am
                   Actually... TheHutt 952 0 Wed, 6:49am
               DOS extra footage... lionoferebor 619 0 Wed, 1:14pm
       Collapse That is what I am hoping for. Arannir 922 1 Wed, 7:02am
           The trailer says OVER 20 minutes of new and extended footage... QuackingTroll 703 0 Wed, 12:17pm
       Collapse This is complete speculation... lionoferebor 640 8 Wed, 1:07pm
           Collapse The studio forced him to cut out Legolas hanging from the bat // QuackingTroll 607 6 Wed, 1:20pm
               Collapse Who said that? Arannir 582 5 Wed, 1:25pm
                   Collapse I was joking. No-one wanted that shot... QuackingTroll 571 4 Wed, 1:27pm
                       Ah, okay. Sorry. Arannir 302 0 Wed, 1:31pm
                       Collapse I literally screamed Elanor of Rohan 271 2 Wed, 2:04pm
                           Collapse But ... Avandel 238 1 Wed, 3:22pm
                               Oh my, oh my lionoferebor 198 0 Wed, 4:22pm
           It's quite likely that Peter Jackson wasn't entirely satisfied.... dormouse 293 0 Wed, 1:46pm

  Collapse (BotFA EE Spoilers) Legolas ... Inverted ... Legolas_Shoehorn 987 13 Wed, 5:01am Jump to last post in thread (by Dcole4)
       It was me Eldorion 939 0 Wed, 5:08am
       Collapse I thought it would be amusing. Aragorn the Elfstone 915 2 Wed, 5:25am
           Fili Mooseboy018 892 0 Wed, 5:33am
           I emailed PJ too a few minutes ago Legolas_Shoehorn 874 0 Wed, 5:38am
       Collapse Blame me NecromancerRising 882 1 Wed, 5:37am
           *A gentle snigger is heard from inside the teapot.... :-) // dormouse 716 0 Wed, 8:39am
       Collapse Sorry, I started a petition for this months ago... QuackingTroll 610 1 Wed, 11:43am
           Two or three...? dormouse 496 0 Wed, 1:40pm
       Collapse For all we know, this shot will replace his fight with Bolg and Beorn will do the honors. Imladris18 464 4 Wed, 1:59pm
           Collapse If that is the case... Arannir 458 3 Wed, 2:00pm
               Collapse Agreed! // Eldorion 406 1 Wed, 2:40pm
                   Ditto Avandel 245 0 Wed, 7:49pm
               I will follow suit! Dcole4 202 0 Wed, 8:43pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 1001 Next page Last page

Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.