Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 2 of 924 (330916 posts in 13848 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 924 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse I don't really like TBOFA compared to AUJ and TDOS... delius82 669 10 6:05am Jump to last post in thread (by mae govannen)
       Collapse Yes.. ecthelionsbeard 376 1 6:10am
           I'm with you on this! Glorfindela 176 0 10:58am
       PJ was right, DOS was the best one of the three MouthofSauron 380 0 6:29am
       Collapse The book also Silverlode 292 3 8:04am
           Collapse and thats why DOS MouthofSauron 242 1 9:16am
               Now We Can Discuss The Effect of Three Films Michelle Johnston 166 0 11:17am
           Quite true and important remark... I will add that mae govannen 98 0 1:42pm
       It's the same in the book... TheHutt 261 0 8:30am
       that is strange mirkwoodwanderer 184 0 11:00am
       Hope you enjoy the EE more... QuackingTroll 107 0 1:39pm

  Collapse The real question is... Saneliur 456 3 5:30am Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       Collapse Dale Mooseboy018 237 1 5:44am
           Bomby wantz it to Become the PARTY TREE! Bombadil 192 0 5:52am
       The significance mirkwoodwanderer 107 0 11:01am

Collapse Whose armor did you like best? Loresilme 396 10 4:25am Jump to last post in thread (by MedwedtoBeorn)
       Hmm... cats16 227 0 4:58am
       Thranduil's looks very movement friendly. Eruonen 206 0 5:21am
       Collapse I liked Kili's Cirashala 153 1 7:58am
           Yes, lionoferebor 123 0 8:20am
       Thorin and Fili's CathrineB 122 0 9:38am
       Really can't make up my mind Glorfindela 106 0 10:57am
       Loved Gloin wearing Gimli's helmet // QuackingTroll 69 0 1:28pm
       Collapse Off the cuff... Otaku-sempai 72 1 1:37pm
           Elrond had two SETS, one in Rivendell & the Other Bombadil 52 0 1:58pm
       Dain MedwedtoBeorn 3 0 20 mins ago

  Collapse Who do you think? lionoferebor 363 5 4:18am Jump to last post in thread (by Ham_Sammy)
       Nori or Gloin, perhaps. Silverlode 199 0 4:22am
       Collapse In his madness grammaboodawg 191 2 4:50am
           He did.... NateGate 37 0 3:26pm
           You would think Ham_Sammy 29 0 3:46pm
       He does not know any more mirkwoodwanderer 84 0 11:03am

  Collapse Legolas Appreciation Laineth 411 20 3:11am Jump to last post in thread (by hobbitylass)
       Collapse It's good that you like the stunts Glorfindela 237 2 3:18am
           Collapse I understand. Laineth 203 1 3:37am
               Exactly!... Great quotes as well...! mae govannen 183 0 3:49am
       Collapse Not I... arithmancer 218 1 3:28am
           He was my favorite, but otherwise I agree mae govannen 178 0 3:55am
       Collapse Yes! Loresilme 196 1 3:34am
           Agree totally with you on all this, Loreilme!. mae govannen 162 0 4:02am
       Collapse Longtime Legolas fan huzzlewhat 196 1 3:41am
           *Standing applause!!!* mae govannen 168 0 4:07am
       I find his stunts great, and a part of his Elvish personality mae govannen 191 0 3:42am
       Collapse Love him :) tarasaurus 168 4 4:12am
           Walking on snow Loresilme 162 0 4:30am
           Collapse Well he did ride the Cave-troll in FOTR... Scorchster 162 1 4:34am
               aaah yes! tarasaurus 153 0 4:44am
           I also liked... arithmancer 12 0 49 mins ago
       The thing that I like... DigificWriter 175 0 4:16am
       I liked him much more in The Battle of Five Armies... delius82 147 0 6:09am
       Collapse PJ just can't make a middle-earth film without Legolas ... MouthofSauron 138 1 6:31am
           At least Glorfindela 74 0 11:06am
       I finally figured out what bothered me about Legolas in these movies hobbitylass 8 0 32 mins ago

Collapse So what happens to Tauriel now? delius82 677 16 2:55am Jump to last post in thread (by Girdle of Melian)
       Collapse Well... Laineth 429 1 3:07am
           Yup! arithmancer 355 0 3:24am
       Re: So what happens to Tauriel now? DigificWriter 353 0 3:30am
       Hmmm marillaraina 305 0 4:08am
       Collapse Well, let's see... Silverlode 298 1 4:13am
           Peter Jackson's Middle-earth Otaku-sempai 92 0 12:40pm
       What happens to Tauriel? Kilidoescartwheels 256 0 4:55am
       In a recent interview, DwellerInDale 305 0 4:56am
       Collapse I believe she returns to Mirkwood grammaboodawg 274 3 4:56am
           Collapse Bombyzz..."Fantasty Theory"? Bombadil 237 2 5:31am
               Collapse Yes, I'd like that too... mae govannen 187 1 7:16am
                   No Cirashala 176 0 7:51am
       Collapse She might be the one responsible for Gollums escape? Lieutenant of Dol Guldur 150 1 10:59am
           Quite right! Eleniel 63 0 2:02pm
       It will be in E.E. mirkwoodwanderer 151 0 11:03am
       I think what they should do is... Girdle of Melian 53 0 3:25pm

Collapse The Curious Case of the Chain-Eyed Troll... NateGate 644 15 2:06am Jump to last post in thread (by MechaGodzilla)
       Are you sure he has no eyes? ecthelionsbeard 320 0 2:32am
       hm deskp 315 0 2:36am
       Collapse It's a completely OTT Jacksonism. Merovech 328 2 2:36am
           Collapse In the movie.. ecthelionsbeard 309 1 2:50am
               the troll has no eyes MouthofSauron 289 0 3:00am
       Collapse Airlifted in by a team of cargo bats? Silverlode 256 1 3:17am
           i think only smaug could airlift that huge troll MouthofSauron 215 0 4:24am
       agree with deskp DisDwarfWoman 246 0 3:27am
       This was ridiculous in so many ways... Eurolock 250 0 4:00am
       Collapse I dont like it Remus 140 3 9:11am
           Collapse it was one of those ideas i bet they were like ... MouthofSauron 148 2 9:18am
               Collapse I agree Mcoull 61 1 1:40pm
                   Exactly... NateGate 31 0 3:50pm
       Collapse I'm not a fan of that scene BlackFox 25 1 4:28pm
           I kinda feel the same MechaGodzilla 6 0 18 mins ago

  Collapse How much more battle footage will we see in the EE ? MouthofSauron 781 18 1:12am Jump to last post in thread (by DjU)
       I hope Ham_Sammy 400 0 1:31am
       Collapse I hope for a lot more as there are some truncated scenes and missing scenes. Eruonen 413 4 1:32am
         Collapse Don't forget Saruman! KingTurgon 237 3 5:26am
               Collapse i wouldn't hold your breath MouthofSauron 224 2 5:29am
                   Collapse Why? KingTurgon 189 1 6:07am
                       Christopher Lee had a pretty good scene in this film MouthofSauron 197 0 6:27am
       More Beorn and especially more Thranduil! Eruvandi 373 0 1:48am
       Hopefully Thrain II 332 0 2:15am
       Collapse I wonder marillaraina 343 2 2:28am
           Yeah i was thinking the same thing on my third viewing today MouthofSauron 317 0 2:36am
           Yeah, another scene from the trailer I forgot about that will be in the EE. Eruonen 218 0 5:29am
       Collapse The Chariot Scene DigificWriter 335 2 2:42am
           Could be... lionoferebor 300 0 3:12am
           It doesn't... DjU 10 0 21 mins ago
       To be honest, I'd rather not see much more Glorfindela 290 0 3:25am
       Dwarfs... Dipling 164 0 7:27am
       I want to see the Orc's "battle beasts" in action... DeadRabbits 158 0 7:54am
       There will be a lot more. mirkwoodwanderer 116 0 11:05am

  Collapse "Bilbo Baggins! You haven't aged a day!" ghost_matt 931 35 12:54am Jump to last post in thread (by xMb)
       Collapse Just another example of why... Aragorn the Elfstone 623 19 12:57am
           Collapse Isn't that what the phrase always means? Spriggan 528 17 1:03am
               or ….. MouthofSauron 346 0 2:37am
               Collapse Exactly. Mooseboy018 259 15 4:21am
                   It's not even a problematic line if they haven't.... DigificWriter 257 0 4:24am
                   Collapse And from the Appendices, we know that... Silverlode 242 13 4:39am
                       Collapse The films have a much different timeline... DigificWriter 224 12 4:44am
                           Collapse Well, yes, there's a missing 16 years or so... Silverlode 217 11 4:54am
                               Collapse Timeline... Aragorn the Elfstone 217 10 5:01am
                                   Collapse I'm very much a Tolkien novice, but... DigificWriter 214 9 5:05am
                                       Collapse Really? Aragorn the Elfstone 204 8 5:13am
                                           Collapse Aside from the Mirkwood thing, none of those.... DigificWriter 201 1 5:15am
                                               Huh? Aragorn the Elfstone 195 0 5:20am
                                           Collapse Hmm, well with LOTR... Silverlode 99 5 7:45am
                                               Collapse Oh, believe me I know... Aragorn the Elfstone 50 3 1:08pm
                                                   Collapse Why is it so hard... DigificWriter 45 2 1:16pm
                                                       Collapse Because for years... Aragorn the Elfstone 45 1 1:24pm
                                                           Okay DigificWriter 36 0 1:31pm
                                             LOL...! THAT history does repeat itself amusingly... mae govannen 28 0 2:17pm
           hm.. xMb 12 0 3:27pm
       Why will it confuse people? Spriggan 465 0 12:58am
       Collapse eh deskp 458 6 1:02am
           Collapse Well, besides the fact it's two different actors.... Name 364 4 1:51am
               Collapse Why would Gandalf be comparing Bilbo with a point 60 years earlier? Spriggan 354 3 1:54am
                   Collapse I don't think he is. I'm with you. Name 348 2 1:59am
                       that's my take Ham_Sammy 320 0 2:20am
                       Ha - well that's ok then. Spriggan 282 0 2:46am
           Exactly: "that's what they always say." Elizabeth 283 0 2:54am
       or ….. MouthofSauron 413 0 1:10am
       Gollum gkgyver 427 0 1:10am
       I'm at a loss as to how... DigificWriter 382 0 1:50am
       It is like your grand mother mirkwoodwanderer 68 0 11:06am
       This is why I'd prefer the ending to involve a younger Ian Holm QuackingTroll 44 0 1:33pm
       Not really... CathrineB 29 0 2:20pm
       It works, if you think harder... xxxyyy 25 0 2:48pm

  Moved: Thorin vs Dwalin - who would win? Kilidoescartwheels - - 12:53am Jump to last post in thread (by Kilidoescartwheels)

  Collapse Just saw the film and i'm not as sad as I thought I would be... delius82 623 13 12:12am Jump to last post in thread (by Avandel)
       Collapse This one is as fast as DOS. Sharkey 295 1 12:34am
           I wonder about the editing pace of BOFA Avandel 99 0 7:41am
       I didn't cry as much as I thought I would Kilidoescartwheels 290 0 12:35am
       Collapse The first time I watch any of these films Loresilme 293 7 12:42am
           Collapse My first viewings have been... Aragorn the Elfstone 293 6 12:50am
               Collapse Interesting that you bring that up Aragorn.. delius82 231 5 1:56am
                   Collapse Oh, MY! Kilidoescartwheels 153 3 4:49am
                       Collapse After view #3, I most likely won't go back to a theater Avandel 117 2 7:21am
                           Collapse This story ends at the beginning of the rise of Sauron. Silverlode 94 1 7:58am
                               Thank you very much for posting this Avandel 15 0 4:46pm
                   I love the melancholy feel Ardamírë 125 0 6:31am
       I sobbed tarasaurus 200 0 2:46am
       that is very sad mirkwoodwanderer 57 0 11:07am

  Collapse Live Bolg Cameo in BotFA? Graffanino 436 2 Sun, 11:58pm Jump to last post in thread (by NoelGallagher)
       Collapse Yeah... ecthelionsbeard 254 1 12:22am
           would go that far NoelGallagher 82 0 7:49am

  Collapse Mountain worms? Aranarth 742 24 Sun, 11:33pm Jump to last post in thread (by hobbitylass)
       Collapse Yes, it was an unnecessary creature....a quibble point for me in Eruonen 432 3 Sun, 11:36pm
           Collapse How else could they do it? AshNazg 375 1 Sun, 11:50pm
               TBF, the book is filled with eccentricities and 'plotholes' in equal measure too! adt100 27 0 3:56pm
           True Aranarth 21 0 4:12pm
       Reek? sharku 389 0 Sun, 11:38pm
       Collapse They are an interpretation of the were worms Spriggan 424 9 Sun, 11:38pm
           Collapse Ah, well at least there is a canonical reference. Eruonen 366 7 Sun, 11:48pm
               Collapse Worm often means dragon in M-E, but hey ho // AshNazg 309 6 12:02am
                   Collapse Based on word origin, which JRRT was certainy aware of as a linguist Eruonen 254 5 1:26am
                       Collapse Based on word origin, Gandalf was a dwarf or an elf. Spriggan 230 4 1:52am
                           Collapse I do think there is a difference between a personal name and Eruonen 211 3 2:03am
                               Collapse It's the same with creatures. Spriggan 193 2 2:37am
                                   Collapse True, however, orcs look like demons and Ents look like giants. Eruonen 151 1 4:17am
                                       I'm not sure what you mean. Spriggan 24 0 4:02pm
           Thanks Aranarth 20 0 4:14pm
       Collapse I immediately thought of Dune (Frank Herbert) and that PJ had ripped it off - and not justifiably either IMO :( // Xanaseb 350 4 Sun, 11:40pm
         Collapse Sorry... IN TRUTH? Frank Herbert read the Hobbit Bombadil 329 3 12:04am
               Cool Loresilme 280 0 12:37am
             Collapse I concur Glorfindela 188 1 3:14am
                 Thang you...OH! "Glorious ONE"!..// Bombadil 95 0 7:58am
       Collapse I was fine with them Glorfindela 365 1 Sun, 11:43pm
           Also, even if Azog had dug under Erebor... AshNazg 337 0 Sun, 11:59pm
       Were-Worms are this Trilogy's version of the Great Beasts... DigificWriter 238 0 2:09am
       I had the same reaction to them hobbitylass 7 0 26 mins ago

  Collapse Middle-Earth Marathon realisation gkgyver 624 24 Sun, 11:27pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Collapse 6 haarp 329 6 Sun, 11:32pm
           Collapse It was rather cool gkgyver 312 5 Sun, 11:45pm
               Collapse Blimey! Glorfindela 273 4 Sun, 11:48pm
                 Collapse Is 'Blimey' mae govannen 129 2 4:20am
                       Collapse Well, 'Blimey' is a Cockney expression Glorfindela 42 1 10:53am
                           Thank you for this kind explanation!...// mae govannen 31 0 11:19am
                   I Plan Something Lke That smtfhw 106 0 5:26am
       Nice!!! Ham_Sammy 291 0 Sun, 11:32pm
     Bomby is SSOoo..Happy for you! CHEERS Gaffer!/// Bombadil 222 0 12:07am
       Collapse I still can't see these films as a chronological six film series... Aragorn the Elfstone 269 3 12:11am
           Collapse The problem is only in your head, actually ... mae govannen 133 2 4:33am
               Collapse Well... Aragorn the Elfstone 122 1 4:41am
                   I understand your points, but mae govannen 114 0 4:52am
       Collapse I found the Black Riders were scarier in FOTR Ataahua 270 4 12:11am
           Collapse How interesting an observation.... mae govannen 130 3 4:34am
             Collapse Did you any of YOU see "The Frighteners" by PJ? Bombadil 75 2 8:25am
                 Collapse NO THANKS!... Not for me!!! mae govannen 53 1 10:12am
                       Me neither Glorfindela 15 0 3:40pm
       i didn't even know these 6 movie marathons exist Me85 235 0 12:22am
       Collapse Nice! I would love to do this Loresilme 225 3 12:29am
           Collapse It was gkgyver 195 2 1:00am
               Collapse It adds such dimension to the character of Bilbo Loresilme 174 1 1:57am
                   It was the same with me, mae govannen 117 0 4:47am
       This is just GREAT... and a great post!!! mae govannen 136 0 4:16am

  Collapse Fili And Kili's death Aranarth 811 22 Sun, 11:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Elanor of Rohan)
       Collapse We have scant details on the circumstances Spriggan 407 1 Sun, 11:42pm
           Well put! adt100 40 0 4:02pm
       Collapse The more I think about it Glorfindela 398 1 Sun, 11:45pm
           I knew everything about Fili's death Elanor of Rohan 4 0 8 mins ago
       Collapse I felt the most during Fili's death actually! painjoiker 389 1 Sun, 11:49pm
           Same here emre43 103 0 8:19am
       Collapse Simple reason gkgyver 377 4 12:09am
           Collapse Exactly Ham_Sammy 275 1 1:14am
               Even though it's just an afterthought it still describes theirdeaths very well Azaghâl 255 0 1:28am
           On the other hand Riven Delve 263 0 1:25am
           I disliked that... Bladerunner 248 0 2:00am
       Finally! FrostyLemon 333 0 12:22am
       Collapse Actually CathrineB 276 8 1:28am
           So did I Ham_Sammy 259 0 1:33am
           Collapse subject marillaraina 257 3 1:36am
               Collapse Fili and Kili's deaths enhance the tragedy of Thorin's death Riven Delve 268 2 1:53am
                   Collapse subject marillaraina 239 1 2:18am
                       Exactly. Totally correct points. // mae govannen 114 0 7:27am
           Collapse Agreed DisDwarfWoman 222 2 2:33am
               Collapse Fili's death Mooseboy018 194 1 4:28am
                   yes DisDwarfWoman 163 0 5:18am
       I see why, But.... Aranarth 33 0 4:35pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 924 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.