Our Sponsor Sideshow Collectibles Send us News
Lord of the Rings Tolkien
Search Tolkien
Lord of The RingsTheOneRing.net - Forged By And For Fans Of JRR Tolkien
Lord of The Rings Serving Middle-Earth Since The First Age

Lord of the Rings Movie News - J.R.R. Tolkien
Do you enjoy the 100% volunteer, not for profit services of TheOneRing.net?
Consider a donation!

  Main Index   Search Posts   Who's Online   Log in
The One Ring Forums: Tolkien Topics:
Movie Discussion: The Hobbit
Page 2 of 992 (354906 posts in 14867 threads)
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 992 Next page Last page
  Subject  Author   Views   Replies  Sort direction Age (creation)
  Collapse what if tauriel and kili did get together... balbo biggins 1209 45 Jul 27, 3:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by lionoferebor)
       Collapse Too different? Otaku-sempai 1083 9 Jul 27, 3:48pm
           Collapse cmon, if course they could! balbo biggins 941 8 Jul 27, 7:50pm
               Collapse You know what happens when you assume. Otaku-sempai 930 7 Jul 27, 8:11pm
                   Collapse but... balbo biggins 905 6 Jul 27, 10:16pm
                       Collapse Don't confuse physical compatability with genetic compatability. Otaku-sempai 852 5 Jul 27, 11:01pm
                           Collapse very similar balbo biggins 827 4 Jul 27, 11:39pm
                               Collapse Fanfic? Otaku-sempai 767 3 Jul 28, 4:23am
                                   Collapse Fanfic! dreamflower 453 2 Wed, 12:04pm
                                       Collapse To fic, or not to fic. Otaku-sempai 416 1 Wed, 2:10pm
                                           That's what I thought dreamflower 407 0 Wed, 2:24pm
       Dwelves? Kilidoescartwheels 1069 0 Jul 27, 4:02pm
       Collapse Wouldn't happen... dormouse 1004 27 Jul 27, 6:25pm
           Collapse Why not? Bishop 888 26 Jul 27, 10:05pm
               Collapse Two reasons... dormouse 760 25 Jul 28, 8:01am
                   By Elbereth, I think you've got it..... the 13th warrior 716 0 Jul 28, 9:32am
                   Courtly Love Otaku-sempai 662 0 Jul 28, 1:27pm
                   Collapse Great post, thanks! But I still disagree Bishop 622 21 Jul 28, 3:38pm
                       My take on the "trousers" line Kilidoescartwheels 592 0 Jul 28, 5:05pm
                       Collapse Feel free to disagree, that's fine by me :-) dormouse 557 19 Jul 28, 7:04pm
                           Collapse Not 5 minutes... Hobbity Hobbit 496 2 Jul 29, 2:19am
                               Collapse Love at first sight dreamflower 445 1 Wed, 12:15pm
                                   Yes Bishop 448 0 Wed, 1:13pm
                           Collapse Most certainly Glorfindela 444 2 Wed, 12:21pm
                               Collapse Well.... dormouse 428 1 Wed, 1:51pm
                                   No Glorfindela 409 0 Wed, 2:22pm
                           Collapse Hey, this is on Jackson Bishop 448 12 Wed, 1:16pm
                               Collapse Yes dormouse 427 11 Wed, 1:54pm
                                   Collapse Kili's survival has nothing to do with it Bishop 422 10 Wed, 1:57pm
                                       Collapse Of course it does.... dormouse 418 9 Wed, 2:09pm
                                           Collapse Well.... Otaku-sempai 411 2 Wed, 2:19pm
                                               Collapse People may be.... dormouse 407 1 Wed, 2:26pm
                                                   Be that as it may... Otaku-sempai 397 0 Wed, 2:40pm
                                           Collapse Tauriel/Kili vs. Galadriel/Gimli lionoferebor 310 5 Thu, 12:56am
                                               I totally agree with this Bishop 291 0 Thu, 2:34am
                                               Collapse Interesting post..... dormouse 249 3 Thu, 8:24am
                                                   Collapse Actually... lionoferebor 213 2 Thu, 1:50pm
                                                       Collapse Whoa, steady on there!.... dormouse 193 1 Thu, 3:07pm
                                                           Hold on... lionoferebor 125 0 Fri, 1:19am
                   Indeed, I agree as JRRT says in Letters Brethil 581 0 Jul 28, 5:37pm
       If you divorce the movies completely from the books... well, pretty much anything is possible. Nomad 876 0 Jul 27, 10:19pm
       Collapse Well Glorfindela 865 3 Jul 27, 10:38pm
           Collapse No, Dwarves are too different. Elizabeth 739 2 Jul 28, 8:15am
               Collapse Bombyzz 14th share of this Conversation..? Bombadil 203 1 Thu, 2:21pm
                   Kind of what I said above Kilidoescartwheels 166 0 Thu, 4:23pm
       Oh well, why not? But there could be problems... Elarie 135 0 Fri, 12:07am

  Collapse Did the moth reappear in BOFA? Earl 482 3 Jul 27, 11:07am Jump to last post in thread (by Kim)
       Collapse I don't believe it did appear. Imladris18 350 2 Jul 27, 4:28pm
           Collapse True Earl 211 1 Jul 28, 8:20am
               You could also look at this way Kim 124 0 Wed, 3:48am

  Collapse The fate of Tauriel, Radagast and Alfrid: what will happen to them? DainPig 973 35 Jul 27, 12:02am Jump to last post in thread (by mirkwoodwanderer)
       Collapse I'm not sure, OldestDaughter 903 1 Jul 27, 12:19am
           okay, he will scape DainPig 898 0 Jul 27, 12:28am
       Collapse Alfrid Otaku-sempai 880 3 Jul 27, 1:20am
         Collapse SPOILER here too about Otaku's post DainPig 869 2 Jul 27, 1:40am
               Collapse official Mooseboy018 863 1 Jul 27, 1:48am
                   To me DainPig 857 0 Jul 27, 1:53am
       Collapse Tauriel and Radagast Mooseboy018 856 1 Jul 27, 1:54am
           Radagast's farewell DainPig 849 0 Jul 27, 2:00am
       Collapse Speaking of unresolved conclusions... MyWeeLadGimli 817 1 Jul 27, 3:35am
           confirmed Mooseboy018 791 0 Jul 27, 4:21am
       Collapse Neither Tauriel nor Radaghast will die Kilidoescartwheels 811 7 Jul 27, 3:41am
           Collapse The Master's (Book) Fate Otaku-sempai 774 6 Jul 27, 4:31am
               Collapse Alfrid dead in the wild? How this would work? DainPig 765 5 Jul 27, 4:44am
                   Collapse In the marshes Otaku-sempai 762 4 Jul 27, 5:00am
                       Collapse For me, no.... Avandel 541 3 Jul 27, 2:46pm
                           Collapse Realism (and Tolkien) has little to do with it. Otaku-sempai 513 2 Jul 27, 3:30pm
                               Collapse LOL realism Avandel 330 1 Jul 27, 6:40pm
                                   I'm still not sure about the end. Otaku-sempai 298 0 Jul 27, 8:01pm
       Collapse How about nothing? dormouse 720 6 Jul 27, 7:10am
           Alfrid's death was in an early cut of BotFA in October or so, I believe, according to Doug Adams IIRC. // Bofur01 628 0 Jul 27, 11:13am
           Agree Avandel 548 0 Jul 27, 2:37pm
           Collapse How about nothing indeed Glorfindela 533 3 Jul 27, 2:48pm
               Collapse Well, re Radagast... Avandel 529 2 Jul 27, 2:54pm
                   Collapse But Glorfindela 526 1 Jul 27, 3:01pm
                       Of course - love Beorn! Avandel 330 0 Jul 27, 6:46pm
       Hmm CathrineB 632 0 Jul 27, 10:58am
       I remember some interview shortly after the BotFA release where... Imladris18 493 0 Jul 27, 4:37pm
       Collapse Radagast - no staff, no wizard DainPig 272 1 Jul 27, 11:49pm
           Well, had to do a quick look-up on wizard staffs.... Avandel 266 0 Jul 28, 12:28am
       Collapse Hmm Bernhardina 219 1 Jul 28, 1:45pm
           On Radagast in LOTR Spriggan 200 0 Jul 28, 2:45pm
       Collapse Tauriel's fate. Bumblingidiot 183 2 Jul 28, 4:50pm
         Collapse Elves being ineffable??? Avandel 160 1 Jul 28, 8:28pm
               I hadn't realised, Bumblingidiot 94 0 Thu, 5:14pm
       Radagast might marry with Tauriel and they adopt Alfred mirkwoodwanderer 40 0 Sat, 8:31pm

Collapse US/Canada EE release date Nov. 17th PryftanAW 1073 11 Jul 26, 5:08pm Jump to last post in thread (by Dipling)
       That's not the type of EE news I wanted to hear tsmith675 886 0 Jul 26, 9:10pm
       Really sad news DainPig 797 0 Jul 26, 11:28pm
       booooooooo Mooseboy018 744 0 Jul 27, 1:56am
       Collapse Aargh...! *big sigh* mae govannen 571 4 Jul 27, 1:55pm
           Collapse Well, it's really just about the same wait as before, isn't it... dormouse 535 3 Jul 27, 3:14pm
               Agreed, besides, what is the rush? Avandel 426 0 Jul 27, 6:50pm
               Collapse All true, certainly, but mae govannen 117 1 Fri, 11:11am
                   I hope Dipling 107 0 Fri, 12:04pm
       Collapse The link doesn't give a date Kilidoescartwheels 500 2 Jul 27, 4:31pm
           I'm afraid it does.... dormouse 447 0 Jul 27, 6:18pm
           Anyway everything says 'November', mae govannen 114 0 Fri, 11:22am

  Collapse Jason Isaacs would have made a great Thranduil had he not been cast Eruonen 725 12 Jul 25, 6:23pm Jump to last post in thread (by Eruonen)
       Collapse Eeeh CathrineB 676 1 Jul 25, 6:53pm
           To me, as Lucius, he looks very elvish Eruonen 663 0 Jul 25, 7:04pm
       Collapse He would have been my choice for Elrond. Silverlode 637 3 Jul 25, 8:02pm
           Pace is one of the standout actors in the trilogy NoelGallagher 627 0 Jul 25, 8:18pm
           Collapse Lee Pace did a terrific job, no doubt. Eruonen 596 1 Jul 25, 9:27pm
               Before the films .... dormouse 585 0 Jul 25, 10:09pm
       Collapse Maybe Adrianna 568 5 Jul 25, 10:48pm
           Collapse Agree Glorfindela 532 4 Jul 26, 12:49am
               Collapse Mmm! Adrianna 502 3 Jul 26, 3:26am
                   Collapse I'd say Glorfindela 399 2 Jul 26, 11:38am
                       Exactly. Mooseboy018 301 0 Jul 26, 5:28pm
                       It is too bad we could not have it all. Eruonen 250 0 Jul 26, 10:17pm

  Collapse Azog playing Old Bolg part? Mr. Arkenstone (isaac) 702 13 Jul 25, 10:06am Jump to last post in thread (by Smaug the iron)
       Collapse Well, yeah Thrain II 620 12 Jul 25, 12:20pm
           Collapse hmm Goldeneye 553 11 Jul 25, 3:40pm
               Collapse No Smaug the iron 550 10 Jul 25, 3:49pm
                   Collapse I'm not so sure. Mooseboy018 511 1 Jul 25, 5:36pm
                       Yes but Smaug the iron 504 0 Jul 25, 5:52pm
                   Collapse You sure about that? Salmacis81 331 7 Jul 26, 4:42pm
                       Collapse Well Yes Smaug the iron 319 5 Jul 26, 5:14pm
                           Collapse The original concept Beorn killed Bolg... AshNazg 226 4 Jul 27, 12:52pm
                               Collapse How do you know? Smaug the iron 214 3 Jul 27, 1:12pm
                                   Collapse no matter what NoelGallagher 198 2 Jul 27, 2:52pm
                                       Collapse Legolas Mooseboy018 168 1 Jul 27, 5:55pm
                                           Even Smaug the iron 166 0 Jul 27, 6:00pm
                       bear claws Mooseboy018 311 0 Jul 26, 5:30pm

  Collapse Bilbo's goodbye analysis DainPig 615 5 Jul 24, 8:41pm Jump to last post in thread (by CathrineB)
       Collapse I LOVE this scene Legomir 570 1 Jul 24, 8:56pm
         Yes DainPig 564 0 Jul 24, 9:01pm
       Bifur's missing axe Pandallo 483 0 Jul 24, 11:45pm
       Spring forward? Otaku-sempai 349 0 Jul 25, 12:22pm
       Ah yes! CathrineB 280 0 Jul 25, 7:00pm

  Collapse Who would you cast as Thorin if Richard Armitage didn't take the part? Goldeneye 793 39 Jul 24, 5:36pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       We shoud see an audition Elanor of Rohan 702 0 Jul 24, 5:51pm
       Collapse It would depend how the part was written.... dormouse 686 4 Jul 24, 6:49pm
           Collapse re: Goldeneye 637 3 Jul 24, 8:07pm
               Collapse I've never seen your man act.... dormouse 596 2 Jul 24, 9:51pm
                   Collapse Ha Goldeneye 582 1 Jul 24, 10:25pm
                       Game of Thrones isn't shown on UK terrestrial TV... dormouse 424 0 Jul 25, 8:30am
       Collapse Well, Thorin was younger in the films. Otaku-sempai 676 2 Jul 24, 7:13pm
           Collapse Reminds me of the Yoda logic AshNazg 24 1 Sun, 12:13pm
               Young Thorin Otaku-sempai 18 0 Sun, 12:53pm
       Dillane would've made a fantastic Denethor... Elutherian 629 0 Jul 24, 8:23pm
       I've no idea why that man is Glorfindela 568 0 Jul 24, 10:47pm
       Loved Dillane as Stannis Baratheon... Salmacis81 551 0 Jul 24, 11:24pm
       Collapse Okay, for sake of argument... Kilidoescartwheels 550 10 Jul 24, 11:36pm
           Collapse The explanation I heard... Salmacis81 538 3 Jul 24, 11:44pm
               Collapse On that topic... Pandallo 530 1 Jul 24, 11:51pm
                   I never really bought their whole "friendship" though... Salmacis81 519 0 Jul 25, 12:03am
               Have you seen him lately? Kilidoescartwheels 505 0 Jul 25, 12:25am
           Collapse Brian Cox Mooseboy018 536 5 Jul 24, 11:45pm
               Collapse Really? That's interesting Kilidoescartwheels 505 4 Jul 25, 12:26am
                   Collapse GTD Mooseboy018 447 3 Jul 25, 6:42am
                       Collapse I don't think so. Glorfindela 418 2 Jul 25, 9:07am
                           Agreed on all counts dormouse 394 0 Jul 25, 12:21pm
                           Rollicking and Rumbustious! Goldeneye 352 0 Jul 25, 2:13pm
       Collapse I had assume Thorin would be like Theoden! Avandel 523 12 Jul 25, 12:04am
           Collapse If another actor had fallen over... Macfeast 382 11 Jul 25, 1:07pm
               Collapse *Bows* and in no way was I..... Avandel 335 2 Jul 25, 3:39pm
                   Collapse Of course. I know you to be very fair. Macfeast 294 1 Jul 25, 4:30pm
                       Jean Reno (the actor who played 'Leon with young Natalie Portman') Milieuterrien 167 0 Jul 27, 4:36pm
               Collapse Oliver Reed was famous for (among many other things) Starling 260 7 Jul 25, 9:07pm
                   We shared a crush, Starling.... dormouse 249 0 Jul 25, 10:06pm
                   Collapse Of course Richard Armitage owns the role now iduna 82 5 Thu, 4:57pm
                       Collapse Oliver Reed can even Starling 76 4 Thu, 5:55pm
                           Collapse *fans self vigorously* iduna 75 3 Thu, 6:02pm
                               Collapse I am watching The Three Musketeers now Starling 50 2 Sun, 4:39am
                                   Collapse Of course! iduna 48 1 Sun, 4:59am
                                       When I manage to tear my eyes away Starling 44 0 Sun, 5:08am
       Collapse Dillane's Great, but what of Clive Standen or Eric Bana or Clive Owen??? the 13th warrior 242 2 Jul 25, 10:36pm
           Collapse I doubt Clive Standring is old enough Kilidoescartwheels 176 1 Jul 27, 4:04pm
               I think I might rank them..... the 13th warrior 137 0 Jul 28, 8:55am

  Collapse predictions for EE announcement Mooseboy018 1595 21 Jul 24, 7:59am Jump to last post in thread (by Mooseboy018)
       I agree on the date Shagrat 1493 0 Jul 24, 8:43am
       I think Smaug the iron 1433 0 Jul 24, 10:39am
       Collapse I hope it's not the 4th of August.... dormouse 1413 9 Jul 24, 11:34am
           Hmm CathrineB 1382 0 Jul 24, 12:16pm
         Collapse For sure! Avandel 1269 6 Jul 24, 3:37pm
               Collapse Calm before the storm? dormouse 1270 5 Jul 24, 3:41pm
                 Love has a price Avandel 1231 0 Jul 24, 4:29pm
                 Collapse Quite, Dormouse! Brethil 1083 1 Jul 24, 7:29pm
                       Lets! :-) // dormouse 976 0 Jul 24, 9:36pm
                   I agree! Bishop 947 0 Jul 24, 10:26pm
                   Thanks for understanding TheRealPeterJackson 562 0 Jul 26, 2:02am
           Fili would be a nice idea in the trailer Elanor of Rohan 1211 0 Jul 24, 4:46pm
       Collapse Confirmed EE scenes so far Gandalf the Green 1102 1 Jul 24, 7:09pm
           sounds about right Mooseboy018 970 0 Jul 24, 9:44pm
       August 10th DainPig 1069 0 Jul 24, 7:40pm
       Collapse I have no clue... lionoferebor 909 3 Jul 24, 11:18pm
           Collapse Well... Mooseboy018 894 2 Jul 24, 11:47pm
               Collapse Hmmm..... Avandel 879 1 Jul 25, 12:19am
                   possible trailer Mooseboy018 877 0 Jul 25, 12:27am
       Collapse When were the previous EEs announced? seelbach 503 1 Jul 26, 8:20am
           from memory Mooseboy018 379 0 Jul 26, 5:36pm

  Collapse The Legolas-Defying-Gravity controversy Legolas_Shoehorn 1029 26 Jul 24, 6:02am Jump to last post in thread (by Lindelorne)
       I'm with you CathrineB 919 0 Jul 24, 6:33am
       Collapse It wasn't OK Never_Underestimate_A_Dwarf 854 2 Jul 24, 10:46am
           I agree Glorfindela 799 0 Jul 24, 12:45pm
           Ditto Avandel 662 0 Jul 24, 4:05pm
       Collapse I think Skaan 840 1 Jul 24, 11:24am
           Actually Goldeneye 699 0 Jul 24, 2:54pm
       Collapse Is there a controversy? dormouse 842 8 Jul 24, 11:26am
           Collapse It might be unfair... Macfeast 796 2 Jul 24, 1:04pm
               Collapse Ah..... dormouse 779 1 Jul 24, 1:28pm
                   Fair enough. Macfeast 738 0 Jul 24, 2:09pm
           Collapse I guess I have to be in the minority here (which I can live with!) I like the scene. Brethil 208 4 Jul 27, 10:31pm
               Collapse Oh Brethil, I'm glad you're here.... dormouse 199 3 Jul 27, 11:00pm
                 Collapse Waste of a good turnip! Meneldor 189 1 Jul 28, 12:06am
                       Yes, it didn't really work as an effect for me, in terms of the look of the thing. Spriggan 86 0 Jul 28, 2:52pm
                 Would that be a sharpened turnip? Particularly dangerous. // Brethil 181 0 Jul 28, 12:27am
       I don't mind the Legolas scenes Elarie 789 0 Jul 24, 1:11pm
       I think there were two factors with Legolas Bishop 618 0 Jul 24, 6:14pm
       I love Legolas the Elf, just as he is mae govannen 480 0 Jul 25, 8:28am
       Collapse I agree it's the scene, not the character Kilidoescartwheels 355 2 Jul 26, 9:21pm
           These specific objections I can understand mae govannen 292 0 Jul 27, 1:42pm
           The scene would have been perfect Milieuterrien 257 0 Jul 27, 4:44pm
       Collapse It seems like nobody has the cajones to tell Peter..."ahh, let us not do that" Eruonen 275 3 Jul 27, 4:02pm
           I wouldn't mind 45+ minutes Kilidoescartwheels 261 0 Jul 27, 4:36pm
           Collapse From the sound of the commentaries... AshNazg 256 1 Jul 27, 5:06pm
               I recall the bunny sled meeting, there were some uneasy looks at the table Eruonen 252 0 Jul 27, 5:09pm
       I find most of legolas scenes ok it's just the barrel fight ... Lindelorne 28 0 Sun, 12:58am

  Collapse Aidan turner opens up about embarrassing scene with Ian mackellan. Smaug the iron 1068 9 Jul 23, 1:42pm Jump to last post in thread (by dormouse)
     ONLY IAN can get away with Calling AT.. Bombadil 1009 0 Jul 23, 1:46pm
       Collapse Huh? Otaku-sempai 991 5 Jul 23, 2:08pm
           Collapse Put it this way... it isn't you! // dormouse 829 2 Jul 23, 5:20pm
               Collapse Thanks Otaku-sempai 737 1 Jul 23, 8:07pm
                   Please... smtfhw 441 0 Jul 24, 7:41pm
           Collapse Yes, but who exactly is Ian McKellan? Bumblingidiot 408 1 Jul 24, 10:04pm
               Wow! Otaku-sempai 326 0 Jul 25, 12:04pm
       Collapse well Crunchable Birdses 278 1 Jul 25, 8:39pm
           That would depend on the audience // dormouse 255 0 Jul 25, 10:02pm

Collapse A little History on "The Wilhelm SCREAM".. Bombadil 649 9 Jul 23, 1:40am Jump to last post in thread (by Bishop)
       Sneaky? Mooseboy018 588 0 Jul 23, 2:52am
       Collapse Sorry, I can't help myself Bishop 560 5 Jul 23, 5:18am
         Collapse From ONE B-Boy? to another B-Boy Bombadil 359 2 Jul 23, 6:07pm
               Collapse A little side note... Ilmatar 339 1 Jul 23, 7:36pm
                 THANKs..on ANOTHER Side Note Bombadil 283 0 Jul 24, 2:48am
           Collapse OMG! FoFo64 150 1 Jul 26, 2:08am
               :) Bishop 64 0 Jul 27, 6:18pm
       Collapse Personally, I'm on the verge of being familiar with it. Bumblingidiot 480 1 Jul 23, 11:54am
         IF Memory Serves...WHEN Bombadil 438 0 Jul 23, 1:40pm

  Collapse Nationality list of the actors DainPig 419 3 Jul 22, 10:15pm Jump to last post in thread (by adt100)
       Callen? CathrineB 393 0 Jul 22, 10:49pm
       Not sure how Hugo Weaving gets to be Nigerian.... dormouse 305 0 Jul 23, 7:35am
       Very British cast... adt100 282 0 Jul 23, 8:44am

  Collapse DOS: Thrain running around in Dol Goldur Legolas_Shoehorn 952 18 Jul 21, 9:10pm Jump to last post in thread (by Glorfindela)
       Collapse I don't think it was supposed to make sense Bishop 877 1 Jul 21, 9:41pm
           it was wise and fantastic mirkwoodwanderer 849 0 Jul 21, 10:18pm
       Collapse Don't forget about the vines Kilidoescartwheels 847 1 Jul 21, 10:22pm
           That was my understanding, also. Spriggan 815 0 Jul 21, 11:12pm
       I think Thrain wasn't in a cell or in chains.... dormouse 846 0 Jul 21, 10:23pm
       Even Azog seemed to ignore him. OldestDaughter 806 0 Jul 21, 11:26pm
       Collapse Honestly speaking Glorfindela 802 10 Jul 21, 11:39pm
           Collapse Well, yes and no.... dormouse 678 9 Jul 22, 7:52am
               Collapse I don't think it's to do with that Glorfindela 636 8 Jul 22, 9:43am
                   It depends on the question, I think. Spriggan 590 0 Jul 22, 12:29pm
                   Some love plot holes Milieuterrien 552 0 Jul 22, 1:18pm
                   Collapse This is what's wrong with publishing. Bumblingidiot 522 5 Jul 22, 2:22pm
                       Collapse Pray tell me Glorfindela 469 4 Jul 22, 5:11pm
                           Collapse "readers should not be left questioning facts that are in a book" Bumblingidiot 181 3 Jul 24, 10:11pm
                               Collapse There seems to be a bit of a mix-up here Glorfindela 175 2 Jul 24, 10:45pm
                                   Collapse My point was that readers are left questioning facts in classic books. Bumblingidiot 51 1 Thu, 12:10pm
                                       Quick response Glorfindela 49 0 Thu, 12:17pm
       Ha Goldeneye 299 0 Jul 23, 2:43pm

  Collapse The white moose DainPig 1026 27 Jul 20, 10:18pm Jump to last post in thread (by Otaku-sempai)
       Collapse I think the extras/commentary say... AshNazg 954 24 Jul 20, 10:29pm
           Collapse Well, I think this scene is unecessary DainPig 946 23 Jul 20, 10:34pm
               Collapse Does everything have to be necessary? AshNazg 921 7 Jul 20, 11:15pm
                   Collapse Yes DainPig 915 5 Jul 20, 11:22pm
                       projection Mooseboy018 879 0 Jul 21, 12:29am
                       Collapse I suppose so, although... AshNazg 540 3 Jul 21, 8:10pm
                           Collapse There is no moose in the films. Bumblingidiot 419 2 Jul 22, 11:38am
                               Collapse And of course... smtfhw 381 1 Jul 22, 2:11pm
                                   White Hart as a symbol of the King. Bumblingidiot 133 0 Jul 22, 8:22pm
                   Quite agree - things don't have to be necessary. Bumblingidiot 390 0 Jul 22, 1:06pm
               No stag, no elves coming to save the dwarves from the spiders. Milieuterrien 899 0 Jul 20, 11:27pm
               Well... Mooseboy018 873 0 Jul 21, 12:27am
               Collapse IMO it's necessary - and wondrous..... Avandel 879 5 Jul 21, 12:30am
                   Collapse Indeed! Voronwë_the_Faithful 870 4 Jul 21, 12:54am
                       Collapse Yes! *smiles* Avandel 559 3 Jul 21, 7:33pm
                           Collapse Enchanting! Ilmatar 534 2 Jul 21, 8:18pm
                               Collapse *waves at Ilmatar!!!!* Avandel 477 1 Jul 21, 11:31pm
                                   Certainly :) Ilmatar 176 0 Jul 22, 2:46pm
               Collapse Do you? I think it's one of the best scenes in the film... dormouse 764 6 Jul 21, 7:45am
                   Collapse Yes, the link between the stag and Thranduil can't be missed Milieuterrien 739 4 Jul 21, 9:10am
                       Collapse That is not true. Otaku-sempai 699 3 Jul 21, 11:57am
                           Collapse What the book left unclear is Milieuterrien 694 2 Jul 21, 12:06pm
                               Collapse Flies and Spiders Otaku-sempai 688 1 Jul 21, 12:14pm
                                   It could be that Milieuterrien 678 0 Jul 21, 12:33pm
                 Yes - IMO in the film it was art Avandel 552 0 Jul 21, 7:41pm
       Oh cool! CathrineB 915 0 Jul 20, 11:16pm
       Well... Otaku-sempai 127 0 Jul 22, 9:19pm
First page Previous page 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 ... 992 Next page Last page


Search for (options) Powered by Gossamer Forum v.1.2.3

home | advertising | contact us | back to top | search news | join list | Content Rating

This site is maintained and updated by fans of The Lord of the Rings, and is in no way affiliated with Tolkien Enterprises or the Tolkien Estate. We in no way claim the artwork displayed to be our own. Copyrights and trademarks for the books, films, articles, and other promotional materials are held by their respective owners and their use is allowed under the fair use clause of the Copyright Law. Design and original photography however are copyright © 1999-2012 TheOneRing.net. Binary hosting provided by Nexcess.net

Do not follow this link, or your host will be blocked from this site. This is a spider trap.